Skip to content
GuideEvergreen guide

How to draw down your savings without running out

The order you spend from, the rate you spend at, and the years you spend it in matter more than which funds you picked.

By Ray Okonkwo · Money & Business6 min read

The biggest financial decision left in front of you isn't which fund to own. It's how much comes out each month, from which account, and what you do when the market has a bad year. Get those three right and a modest portfolio can hold up for decades. Get them wrong and a large one can get thin fast.

Start by paying yourself properly.

Give yourself a paycheck again

For forty years the money arrived on the same day every month and you budgeted around it. Then it stopped, and most people replace it with something ragged — a withdrawal when the checking account looks low, a bigger one before a trip, a nervous one after a scary headline. That's how you lose track.

Set up a cash account that acts as your paycheck. Keep somewhere between one and two years of spending in it, in something boring that doesn't move — a high-yield savings account, a money market fund, short Treasuries. Then set an automatic transfer into checking on the first of the month. Same amount, every month.

You refill that cash account once or twice a year from the portfolio, on a date you choose in advance, not on a date the news chooses for you. When markets are up you refill from stocks. When they're down you refill from bonds or you let the cash run down a little. The point is that your grocery money is never sitting in something that can fall 20 per cent in a quarter.

Count your floor before you count your portfolio

Write down the income that arrives whether or not markets cooperate. Social Security, any pension, any annuity payment, rental income if it's genuinely reliable. That's your floor.

Then write down what you actually spend in a year. Not what you think you spend — go back through twelve months of statements and add it up. Most people are off by a few thousand dollars, always in the same direction.

The gap between those two numbers is the only thing your savings has to cover. If you need $66,000 a year and your floor is $46,000, the portfolio is on the hook for $20,000, not $66,000. That's a very different conversation, and it's usually a calmer one than people expect.

Social Security timing is the biggest lever most people still have

Claiming early permanently reduces the monthly benefit. Delaying past full retirement age increases it, up to age 70, after which there's no further credit for waiting. Those increases are locked in for life and they adjust with inflation.

For a married couple, the decision isn't symmetrical. When one spouse dies, the household keeps the larger of the two benefits and loses the smaller one. Delaying the higher earner's claim raises the floor for whichever of you lives longest — and that's frequently the spouse with the smaller work record and the longer life expectancy.

Delaying isn't automatically right. Poor health, a genuine need for cash now, or a job you can't keep all change the math. But the default of claiming at 62 because it's available deserves a hard look before you take it. Run your own numbers on the Social Security Administration's site, and talk it through with a fee-only planner who doesn't earn a commission on what you do next.

Pick a withdrawal rate, then build in guardrails

The old rule of thumb says you can take about 4 per cent of the starting balance in year one and adjust that dollar amount for inflation each year after. It's a starting point for conversation, not a law of nature. It was built on a particular set of historical assumptions and a 30-year horizon.

What matters more than the exact number is having a rule for bad years. A simple version: if the portfolio drops significantly, you skip the inflation raise for a year. If it drops a lot, you cut discretionary spending — travel, gifts, the kitchen project — by 10 per cent until it recovers. You write that rule down now, while you're calm, so that you're following a plan later instead of reacting.

Small, early adjustments do enormous work. Large, late ones often come too late to help.

The first five years carry most of the risk

A bad market in year twenty is unpleasant. A bad market in year two, while you're selling shares every month to eat, is structural. You're liquidating at low prices and those shares never come back to participate in the recovery.

That's the whole argument for the cash buffer and the flexible spending rule. Both exist to keep you from being a forced seller early. If you retired recently, or you're about to, this is the period to be conservative about big one-time expenditures — the second home, the boat, the large gift to a child. Those are much easier to fund once you've got a few years of history behind you.

Order your withdrawals for taxes, not habit

The common default is to spend taxable accounts first, then tax-deferred (traditional IRA and 401(k)), then Roth last. It's a reasonable starting frame, and it's frequently not optimal.

A few things to raise with a CPA or planner:

  • The low-bracket window. Between retiring and starting Social Security and required distributions, many people have unusually low taxable income. That's often the cheapest time in your life to convert traditional IRA money to Roth, or to realize capital gains deliberately.
  • Required minimum distributions. They currently begin in your early seventies — the age has been changed twice in recent years, so confirm the number that applies to your birth year. Large untouched traditional balances can force you into a higher bracket later whether you need the money or not.
  • Medicare surcharges. Higher-income retirees pay more for Parts B and D, based on a tax return from two years prior. A single big withdrawal or Roth conversion can raise your premiums two years down the road.
  • Qualified charitable distributions. If you're giving to church or charity anyway and you're old enough to qualify, giving directly from an IRA can be more efficient than writing a check.

None of that is advice for your situation. It's the list of questions worth an hour of a professional's time.

Fixed costs are the lever you actually control

Markets don't take instructions. Your monthly obligations do.

Housing is usually the biggest line, and it's the one people protect longest. A paid-off house still costs money — taxes, insurance, maintenance, and the steady creep of all three. Downsizing isn't a defeat. It's often the single move that makes everything else work, and it's far easier at 68 than at 81.

Look hard at cars, subscriptions, and insurance you bought for a life you no longer live. Term life policies covering income you no longer earn. Disability coverage on a job you left. Those premiums buy nothing now.

Long-term care is the expense most likely to break a plan. Medicare does not cover extended custodial care. Decide as a family, in advance, what the plan is — insurance, self-funding, a move near an adult child, or a frank agreement about what you're willing to spend. Deciding during a hospital discharge meeting is the worst possible time.

Protect the survivor and protect yourself from generosity

When one spouse dies, one Social Security check stops and the survivor often files as a single taxpayer, with narrower brackets on similar income. Household expenses don't fall by half. Make sure both of you know where everything is, what the passwords are, and who to call.

And be honest about adult children. Helping is good. Quietly funding an able-bodied adult for years while your own margin thins out isn't generosity, it's a transfer of risk onto the person least able to go back to work. Give from surplus, give with a defined end, and say so out loud.

Put a date on the calendar — mid-January works — for one long morning a year at the kitchen table with the statements, the spending total, and a pot of coffee. One morning a year is what keeps this from ever becoming an emergency.

Share

Ray Okonkwo

Money & Business

Former commercial banker turned small-business owner. Covers salary, credit, margins and the arithmetic nobody does before signing.