Skip to content
GuideEvergreen guide

Pay yourself the payment for three months before you borrow

A $12,000 loan at 12.9 percent hands the lender $3,424. Saving the same monthly amount gets you there in 36 months instead of 48, and the math is yours to check.

By Ray Okonkwo · Money & Business5 min read
Share

Say the thing costs $12,000. A used truck, a new HVAC system, a travel trailer, a kitchen you've been staring at for two years. The finance manager offers you 48 months at 12.9 percent. Your payment is $321 a month.

Run it out. Forty-eight payments of $321 is $15,424. The lender keeps $3,424 of that for the service of letting you have the thing early.

Now flip it. Put that same $321 a month into a savings account paying 4 percent instead, and you cross $12,000 somewhere in month 36. Three years, not four. And instead of handing over $3,424, you collect roughly $270 in interest along the way.

Same monthly cash. Same object at the end. A gap of about $3,700 and twelve months of your life.

This is general education, not advice about your situation. Your rate, your tax picture and your timeline are yours, and a licensed advisor or accountant is the person to ask about them.

The number the salesman won't say out loud

Dealers and contractors quote payments because payments are small and prices aren't. "Three twenty-one a month" sounds like a phone bill. "Fifteen thousand four hundred" sounds like what it's.

So do the multiplication yourself, in front of them if you like. Payment times number of payments. That's the real price. Subtract the sticker and you've got the finance charge, which is the fee for impatience.

On a $12,000 loan at 12.9 percent over four years, impatience costs about $71 a month. Every month. For four years.

The three-month audition

Before you sign anything, do this. Open a separate savings account, name it after the thing, and move the exact loan payment into it on payday. Not the day before rent. The day the money lands.

Do it for three months. Don't touch it.

If you get to month three and the account has $963 in it, you've proven you can carry the payment, and you've also proven you don't need the loan. You're already a quarter of the way to a down payment that kills most of the interest.

If you get to month three and the account has $400 in it because February went sideways, you just learned something a lender would never have told you. You couldn't have made those payments either. The loan would have been fine right up until it wasn't, and then it would have been a repossession or a collections call.

The audition is free. Missing payments isn't.

Yes, the price goes up while you wait

Here's the honest trade-off, and anybody who skips it's selling you something. Things cost more in three years than they cost today. Call it 3 percent a year on a $12,000 item and you're looking at roughly $13,100 by the time you've saved. That's about $1,100 of purchasing power gone.

It's a real cost. It's also less than a third of the $3,424 in interest.

And the arithmetic often runs the other way on the specific item you want. A truck that's $12,000 today is a cheaper truck in three years, because you'll be shopping the model year that's aged into your budget. Appliances go on sale. Contractors quote lower in the off-season. Waiting gives you the one thing borrowers never have: the ability to walk away from a bad price.

Where the money sits

Not in checking. Checking money is spent money that hasn't found its excuse yet.

Put it somewhere with a different login and a transfer delay. A high-yield savings account at a separate bank is the standard move. You want it earning something and you want it slightly annoying to reach.

Automate the transfer for the day after payday. Manual saving works until the month you're tired, and then it stops forever.

Name the account. "Roof." "Truck." "Anna's braces." A labeled account gets raided less than a generic one, because pulling from it feels like stealing from a specific plan instead of moving money around.

If your purchase is two years out or less, don't get clever with it. Stocks are a fine place for money you won't need for a decade and a terrible place for money you'll need in eighteen months. The goal for a sinking fund isn't growth. It's being there in full on the day you need it.

When borrowing actually wins

There are real cases, and pretending otherwise makes you look silly.

Genuine zero percent, with no cash discount. If a manufacturer offers 0 percent for 36 months and the cash price is identical, take the loan and keep your money in a 4 percent account. You'll clear a few hundred dollars. Check the cash price first. Very often the "0 percent" costs $1,500 in a rebate you'd otherwise get.

Emergencies that get worse by the week. A leaking roof isn't a savings project. Water damage compounds faster than any interest rate. Same with a furnace in January and a transmission when you drive to work.

A house. Nobody saves $300,000 in cash, and shelter is a cost you're paying either way.

Tools that earn. If a $9,000 piece of equipment adds $1,500 a month to your business income, the loan pays for itself in the first quarter. That's not consumption, that's capital.

Everything else is a want with a deadline you invented.

The half measure that still works

Sometimes you genuinely can't wait 36 months and it's not an emergency. Fine. Save for twelve and finance the rest.

Twelve months at $321 gets you $3,920 with interest. Finance $8,080 instead of $12,000 at that same 12.9 percent over 36 months and your payment is about $272. Total interest drops to roughly $1,700. You cut the finance charge in half and shortened the term by a year.

Partial cash isn't a failure. It's the entire game. Every dollar you bring to the table is a dollar you don't rent.

What changes in your head

The part that doesn't show up in a spreadsheet is what happens when the money is already sitting there.

You get picky. You start comparing two units instead of taking the one on the lot. You ask what a cash price looks like. You notice that the $12,000 version and the $9,400 version do the same job, and you keep the difference, which never happens when the conversation is about payments.

Saved money buys better than borrowed money, because borrowed money is in a hurry.

Three years from now you'll have the truck either way. The only question on the table is whether a finance company owns a piece of it, and whether you spent the extra twelve months working to make that true.

Open the account today. Move $321 tomorrow. Let the number tell you what you can afford.

Share this article

Ray Okonkwo

Money & Business

Former commercial banker turned small-business owner. Covers salary, credit, margins and the arithmetic nobody does before signing.

Watch

Worth an hour of your evening

More from Money.

From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.

    Graham Stephan23 Sept

    Ranking The BEST Credit Cards 💳

    Graham Stephan22 Sept

    “$0 Tax On ALL Profits!” - This NEW Housing Market Proposal Is INSANE

    Graham Stephan22 Sept

    Ranking The BEST Money Books 📚

    Shay Budgets19 Jul

    HOW TO: THE EASIEST AND SIMPLEST WAY TO CREATE A MONTHLY BUDGET! 6-MINUTES PROCESS