Skip to content
GuideEvergreen guide

She likes you. You don't feel the same. Say so kindly.

Ghosting, hinting and hiding all feel easier than one honest sentence. They hurt her more. Here's how to say it straight and keep your friendship decent.

By Ade Fisher · Young Men5 min read
She likes you. You don't feel the same. Say so kindly.

Quick answer: Tell her the truth, privately, briefly and kindly. Don't ghost her, don't drop hints, and don't tell your friends first. One clear sentence from you now saves her weeks of guessing.

The situation nobody trained you for

A girl from youth group has been laughing at everything you say. Then a friend of hers tells your friend, who tells you, that she likes you. Or she tells you herself, in a text with three nervous emoji.

You feel a few things at once. A little flattered, a little panicked, maybe a little annoyed. All normal. And you have no idea what to do, so you do the easiest thing, which is nothing.

That's the mistake. Nothing is not neutral. To her, silence reads as maybe, and maybe hurts longer than no.

Why the easy options are worse

Ghosting. You stop answering. It costs you nothing today. It costs her days of rereading old messages and wondering what she did wrong. She did nothing wrong. She liked somebody, which isn't a crime.

Hinting. You get a little distant, say you're "super busy," and hope she works it out. She might. She might also decide you're playing games. Either way, you've made her do the work of a conversation you should have had.

Enjoying it. This one's quiet and it's the worst. You keep the texts going because it feels good to be liked, even though you know where it ends. You're using her feelings as a boost for your ego. Jesus' standard is plain: "So whatever you wish that others would do to you, do also to them" (Matthew 7:12, ESV). You wouldn't want to be strung along. Don't do it to her.

Scripture sets the bar for how you treat girls your age in one line: "younger women as sisters, in all purity" (1 Timothy 5:2, ESV). You'd never leave your sister guessing. You'd also never embarrass her in front of people.

The three things that make it kind

Kind and honest aren't opposites. Paul says to grow up by "speaking the truth in love" (Ephesians 4:15, ESV). You need both halves. Truth with no love is a slap. Love with no truth is a fog.

  1. Be private. Not in the hallway, not at lunch with her friends watching, not in a group chat. A quiet moment after youth group, or a short call. If it has to be a text, make it a short, private one, and never the first thing she sees from you in a week.
  2. Be short. The longer you talk, the more you'll say that isn't true or isn't needed.
  3. Be true. Say what's real and stop.

Jesus said, "Let what you say be simply 'Yes' or 'No'" (Matthew 5:37, ESV). Here that means a clear no, said gently.

What it actually sounds like

Try something like this:

"Hey, I heard you like me, and I'm really glad you were brave enough to say it. I don't feel the same way, and I didn't want to leave you guessing. I hope we can still be friendly at youth group."

That's three sentences. It thanks her, it's honest, and it leaves the door open for a normal friendship. Change the words so they sound like you, but keep the shape.

A few things to leave out:

  • Fake excuses. "I'm too busy" or "I'm not allowed" only work if they're true. If your parents really have a no-dating rule at your age, say so. If they don't, you're lying, and she'll find out.
  • "It's not you, it's me." Everyone knows it's a dodge.
  • A list of reasons. Don't explain what's missing in her. You'd just be handing her something to carry around.
  • "Maybe later." Unless you mean it, don't say it. It keeps her hoping.

You also don't owe her a debate. If she asks why, "I just don't feel that way, and I'd rather be honest than pretend" is a complete answer.

Waiting is allowed

You might not be interested in her because she isn't your type. You might also not be interested in dating anyone right now. At 14 or 16, that's a strong place to be. Wanting to wait, to focus on school, family, friends and who you're becoming, is a standard worth holding. You don't owe anybody a relationship because they were nice to you, and nobody owes you one either.

Tell your mom or dad what's going on, too. Not every detail. Just something like "a girl at church likes me and I'm going to tell her I'm not interested." A parent has seen this a hundred times and will often hand you a better sentence than the one you wrote. It also keeps you from carrying it alone.

After you say it

Keep it to yourself. Don't screenshot her message, don't show your buddies, don't make it a story. She trusted you with something tender. That's the same discipline as the guy who doesn't open the test answers in the group chat. Some things you protect even when sharing them would get you a laugh.

Then be normal. Say hi. Don't avoid her seat, don't turn icy, don't act like it never happened. It'll be awkward for a couple of weeks, and that's okay. If you're still working out the whole youth group scene, remember that it only works when people feel safe. You're helping build that by being the guy who handled this well.

If she's hurt, let her be. You can't fix it, and trying to will usually go badly. Don't change your answer to make her feel better. Kindness doesn't guarantee nobody gets hurt. It just means you didn't cause more of it than you had to.

When to bring in an adult

Most of the time this resolves in a couple of awkward conversations. Go to a parent, youth leader or pastor if:

  • she keeps pushing after you've said no clearly
  • she or her friends start pressuring you, or spreading things about you
  • she asks you to send pictures or meet up privately, or to keep any of this secret from your parents
  • she seems to be struggling with something much heavier than a crush, and you're worried about her

You won't be in trouble for any of that. Telling a trusted adult isn't snitching. It's what a young man does when something is bigger than he should handle alone.

The thing she'll remember

Years from now, she won't remember that you said no. She'll remember how. Did you treat her like a person, or like a problem to get rid of? A clean, kind no is one of the most respectful things you can give a girl who took a risk on you.

Practice it once, and the next hard conversation gets easier too.

Ade Fisher

Young Men

Teaches the trades intake at a community college. Writes the manual he wishes his students arrived with.