Skip to content
GuideEvergreen guide

Why your mom or dad sees what you can't about him yet

Your parents aren't psychic and they aren't against you. They've just watched a lot of people, and that's worth hearing out.

By Nina Castellan · BRO for Her5 min read
Why your mom or dad sees what you can't about him yet

You come home, and your mom gets a look. Or your dad asks one extra question about a guy, and it's the question you were hoping nobody would ask.

You get annoyed. They've barely met him. How could they know anything?

They don't know everything. But they may know one thing you don't have yet, and it has nothing to do with being smarter than you.

What they have that you don't

Your parents have watched people for decades. They've seen friends who were sweet in September and different by spring. They've seen how a guy talks about his last girlfriend and how that usually ends up sounding about a year later. They've probably been fooled once or twice themselves.

That's pattern recognition. You can't get it from being clever, because it only comes from time. A fifteen-year-old doesn't have thirty years of watching people, and that isn't a flaw in you. It's arithmetic.

The Bible has a plain word for this. "The simple believes everything, but the prudent gives thought to his steps" (Proverbs 14:15, ESV). "Simple" there doesn't mean dumb. It means untested. And a few verses later: "Without counsel plans fail, but with many advisers they succeed" (Proverbs 15:22, ESV).

Many advisers. Not one. Not just your best friend, who is also fifteen and also only hears the good parts.

Why you can't see it yet

Early on, almost everybody is on their best behavior. That's normal, and it's not even dishonest. He's trying to impress you. You're trying to impress him. Nobody's tired, nobody's been embarrassed, nobody's heard the word "no" yet.

And it feels so good to be noticed that it fogs the windshield. You aren't foolish for that. It happens to smart, grounded girls constantly. But it means you're judging him on the best two percent of what he is.

Your parents are standing outside the fog. They see him arrive. They see what he does when he thinks you're not looking. They see how you've changed since he showed up, which is a thing you almost never notice yourself.

What they're probably picking up on

Ask your mom or dad to say it out loud, and the answer is usually small and specific, not dramatic. Here are the things worth listening for:

  • How he treats people who can't do anything for him. The waiter, his little brother, the guy mowing the field.
  • How he talks about his parents. Contempt for his own family tells you how he'll handle yours.
  • Whether he's at ease around your family. A guy who goes quiet and slippery around adults is telling you something.
  • What happens when you disagree. Does he sulk, joke, push, or actually listen?
  • Whether your world is getting smaller. Fewer friends, fewer youth group nights, less time with your family. A good guy adds to your life.

Then there's the biggest one, and it's worth putting in its own corner.

Secrecy is the loudest alarm

If anyone, at any age, asks you to keep something hidden from your parents, treat that as a warning. "Don't tell your mom." "Let's keep this between us." "They wouldn't understand." Any version of it.

A person with good intentions can stand being seen. Hiding is what people do when the light would change the picture.

The same goes for anyone you've only met online. Don't plan to meet them, don't send photos, and don't keep the conversation hidden. If a message has already made you uneasy, tell a parent, a youth leader, a pastor or a school nurse today. You won't be in trouble. The adults in your life would much rather hear it early and awkward than late and serious.

And one line that never moves: nobody is owed anything physical from you. Not for a gift, not for a date, not because it's been three months, not because they'd be upset. Someone who respects you can hear "no" and stay respectful. If you want to think more about where your own lines sit, How Far Is Too Far Is the Wrong Question is a good next read.

When they're being unfair

Sometimes a parent is wrong. Fear makes people rigid, and some moms and dads would find something wrong with anyone who walked through the door. That's real, and you're allowed to notice it.

But don't use it as a loophole. "Honor your father and your mother" doesn't come with an exception for when you feel sure (Exodus 20:12, ESV). And "Children, obey your parents in the Lord, for this is right" (Ephesians 6:1, ESV) is written to people who sometimes disagreed with their parents too.

Honoring them doesn't mean going silent. It means being straight with them and giving them room to be straight with you.

Try this instead of arguing:

  1. Ask a real question. "What are you seeing that I'm not?" Then stay quiet and let them answer.
  2. Ask for specifics. "I'm worried about him" isn't enough to work with. "He didn't look you in the eye" is something you can think about.
  3. Take it away and sit with it. Don't defend him in the moment. Give it a few days.
  4. Watch for it yourself. If they're right, you'll see it. If they're wrong, you'll see that too, and you'll have something to say back.
  5. Bring in another adult. If you and your parents are stuck, a youth leader, pastor or an aunt you trust can sit between you. That's not going around them. It's asking for another adviser, which is exactly what Proverbs recommends.

The other side of this

Your parents need to hear you out as well. Say so, calmly. "I know you're worried. Can I tell you what I actually like about him?" Parents who feel shut out dig in. Parents who feel trusted usually loosen up.

And if a guy is truly worth your time, he'll pass the test of your family's dinner table. He'll shake your dad's hand and put up with the questions. He won't need your parents to be fooled. A person who's good for you doesn't mind being known.

Guard the thing that's yours

"Keep your heart with all vigilance, for from it flow the springs of life" (Proverbs 4:23, ESV). Your heart is worth guarding because it's valuable, not because you're fragile. Your parents are some of the best guards you've got. They're on your side of the fence even when it doesn't feel like it. If you'd like to be reminded what you're worth before anyone has an opinion, read Your Worth Was Settled Before You Had One Follower.

You don't have to see everything yet. You just have to be willing to hear from the people who can.

Tonight, ask your mom or dad one question: "What did you notice about the first person you dated that you wish somebody had told you?" Then listen. You might get the best fifteen minutes of advice you'll ever get for free.

Nina Castellan

BRO for Her

Runs the women-facing desk. Same standard, same tools, written for a different reader — not a softer one.