Skip to content
GuideEvergreen guide

You're not the referee between Mom and Dad

When your parents give you two different answers, don't pick the easy one. Here's how to get a real answer without starting a fight.

By Nina Castellan · BRO for Her5 min read
You're not the referee between Mom and Dad

Quick answer: Don't carry messages between your parents, and don't go to the one who'll say yes. Ask them both for one answer, give them the details they need, and follow the stricter rule until they decide.

Why the middle is a bad place to stand

Say you want to go to a movie with friends on Friday. Mom says home by 10. Dad says 11 is fine. The movie ends at 10:20.

You know what's tempting. Go to Dad, get the yes, and leave Mom out of it. It'll probably work once.

Then Mom finds out. Now the argument isn't about a curfew. It's about whether you can be trusted, and Dad's in trouble too. Both of them get a little tighter the next time. You got one late night and paid for it with a month of harder questions.

Carrying messages is the other trap. "Dad says you're being unreasonable." "Mom says that's not what she said." Once you're the messenger, you're the target. Whatever your parents feel about each other lands on you.

You can stay out of both. It takes three moves.

Step one: ask for one answer

Don't pick a side. Say what happened, plainly, to both of them:

"Mom said 10 and Dad said 11. I want to do this right, so can you two decide on one and let me know?"

Say it calmly and say it early. Not at 9:45 on Friday with your shoes already on. Not in the middle of an argument. Ask a couple of days ahead, when nobody's rushed.

Notice what that sentence does. It doesn't accuse either parent. It doesn't ask for the easier rule. It tells them you'd rather have a straight answer than a loophole. Most parents hear that and soften a little, because it's a grown-up thing to say.

Step two: make it easy to say yes

Parents often disagree because each one is picturing something different. One is thinking about the drive home. The other is thinking about the friends. Neither has the whole picture.

So give them the whole picture:

  • Who's going, and whether any adults will be around
  • Where it is, and who's driving both ways
  • Exactly when you'll be home
  • When you'll check in by text

Then ask the question that does the most work: "What's the part that worries you?" Listen to the answer. If Mom's worried about the ride home, you can offer a fix. If Dad's worried about the second location, you can promise to stay at the first.

Parents say yes faster to a plan than to a request. You'd be surprised how often the disagreement was really about a missing detail.

Step three: the stricter rule stands until they decide

This is the annoying part. If your parents can't agree, or haven't gotten around to it, you follow the stricter answer. Every time.

It feels unfair when the movie ends at 10:20. Sometimes you'll miss the last half hour of something. Sometimes a friend will say, "Just tell them Dad said it was fine." That's a friend asking you to carry the risk for her. You can tell her, "I'm waiting until they sort it out," and leave it there. If she keeps pushing, how to say no to a friend and still be friends Monday has the exact words.

And be extra strict with yourself on anything involving rides, locations, and who'll be there. Those are the rules parents care about most for good reason. A late curfew is a small risk. Getting into a car you weren't cleared for isn't.

Waiting pays off, because both parents watch you do it. That counts for more than the extra hour would have.

What if your parents live in two homes?

Then you're not in the middle of a disagreement. You're living by two sets of rules, and that's normal.

At Mom's house, Mom's rules. At Dad's house, Dad's rules. Learn both and follow whichever one applies where you're standing. "But Dad lets me" is a line that starts an argument at Mom's and wins nothing. Asking works better: "What's the rule here for phones at night?"

One more thing. Don't use one house as ammunition against the other. Repeating what Mom said about Dad, or what Dad said about Mom, makes you the person in the middle again.

But if a rule at one house is about your safety and the other parent doesn't know it, that's different. A parent should know where you are, who you're with, and who's driving. Telling them isn't tattling. It's keeping them able to look after you.

When it's more than a disagreement

Sometimes the fight isn't about a curfew anymore. It's about you, or it's loud and ugly, or you've started feeling like if you just behaved perfectly, they'd stop.

That isn't your job and it isn't your fault. Nobody your age should be holding a marriage or a household together.

Talk to a trusted adult today. A school counselor, a teacher, the school nurse, a youth leader, a grandparent, an aunt. Tell them what's going on at home and how it's affecting you. You won't be in trouble for telling. Helping with exactly this is what those people are there for.

The same goes if a rule question ever involves someone you met online, a ride from someone who makes you uneasy, or a plan one parent doesn't know about. Don't sit on it. Tell both of your parents, or an adult you trust, the same day.

What this buys you

Parents loosen the rules for a daughter they trust. That's how it goes.

The girl who says, "I'll wait until you two decide," is showing them something. She can hear two opinions and not exploit the gap. She can keep her word when nobody's checking. She asks questions out loud instead of working around people.

That's the daughter who gets the later curfew in the end. Not because she won an argument. Because they stopped needing to argue about her.

Nina Castellan

BRO for Her

Runs the women-facing desk. Same standard, same tools, written for a different reader — not a softer one.