Skip to content
GuideEvergreen guide

Questions to ask before your kid is alone with a tutor

Most tutors and mentors are exactly who they say they are. Ten minutes of plain questions up front helps you know which ones are.

By Josh Halloran · Christian Bro5 min read
Questions to ask before your kid is alone with a tutor

Quick answer: Before the first session, ask where it happens, who can see in, how the adult communicates with your child, and what the organization does to screen and supervise. A good tutor or mentor will answer without a flicker. Anyone who bristles has just told you something.

The setup that worries people, and the one that should

Picture a Tuesday at 4:30. The tutor's car pulls in, your daughter heads to the back bedroom, the door closes. Algebra, presumably. You're making dinner.

Almost certainly, that's all it is. The vast majority of tutors, coaches and mentors are decent people doing hard work for modest pay, and a good one can change a kid's year. Nobody should treat them like suspects.

But the risk was never the stranger in a van. The Department of Homeland Security's Blue Campaign and the Polaris Project both say that people who exploit children are very often someone the child already knows. The Department of Justice and the National Center for Missing & Exploited Children (NCMEC) describe the pattern the same way: it's gradual. An adult earns trust, becomes the kid's favorite grown-up, and gets time alone. Then comes the request to keep something between the two of them.

So the question isn't "is this person good?" You can't see that from a résumé. The question is whether the arrangement makes it easy or hard for anything to go wrong unseen. You control the arrangement.

Ask these before the first session

You don't need a clipboard. Work them into the first phone call or email.

  • Where will you meet? The best answers are a kitchen table, a library, a school room, a church fellowship hall. A bedroom with the door shut is the worst answer you'll hear.
  • Can the door stay open, or can I be in the house? Say it as a house rule, not an accusation. "We keep doors open here" works.
  • Can I sit in on the first session? A pro says yes and means it. It's also how you'll see how they talk to your child.
  • How will you contact my child? The answer you want is that all scheduling goes through you, by text or email you can read. Private social media messages, disappearing-message apps and "just text him directly" are all out.
  • Will you ever drive my child anywhere? The answer is no, or only with your advance permission.
  • If this comes through an organization: what's your screening and supervision policy? Ask whether staff are background checked, whether there's a rule against one adult being alone with one child, and who a parent contacts with a concern.

If you're hiring a neighbor's college kid directly, you still get to ask the first five. Skip the last one and ask instead who else knows this arrangement exists.

What a good answer sounds like

"Sure, sit in as long as you like." "We always keep the door open." "I'd rather everything go through you." A professional has been asked these before and is glad you asked. Some will say it's the first time a parent ever did, and that's a sad commentary on the rest of us.

Pay attention to the opposite:

  • "Kids open up more when parents aren't around."
  • "I don't really do it that way."
  • Annoyance, or a joke that's really a dodge.
  • Pushing for extra, unscheduled time, or for meeting somewhere else.
  • Gifts, favors or special treatment your child gets that others don't.
  • Any request that your child keep something quiet. Any request. A secret about a grade, a secret about a text, a secret about a "surprise."

One red flag isn't a verdict. But you don't have to prove anything to end an arrangement. "This isn't the right fit for us" is a complete sentence, and it costs you one awkward email.

A clear background check isn't a clean bill of health

If an organization says its people are background checked, good. Ask what that covers. A check finds a record. It can't find the person who hasn't been caught, and it says nothing about how someone behaves when they're alone with a kid and nobody's watching.

Screening is the first layer. Visibility is the second, and it's the one you own. Open doors, shared messages and a parent who occasionally walks through with a glass of water do more than any form.

What to say to your kid

The adults can do everything right and the kid is still the last line. Give your child one rule in plain language: surprises are fine, secrets aren't. A surprise has an end date. "We're making Mom a card" is a surprise. "Don't tell your parents" is a secret, and a secret from you is always a reason to tell you.

Then say the other half out loud: you can tell me anything, even if someone told you not to, and I won't be angry at you. That second sentence matters more than the first. Kids stay quiet when they think the news will cost them their phone, their activity or your approval. How you react the first time they tell you something small sets what they'll do with something big.

Afterward, ask the dull questions regularly. "What did you work on?" "Anything weird or uncomfortable?" Keep it casual, in the car or over dinner, not as an interrogation. And pop in unannounced now and then. A good tutor won't mind. If you want more on this, see what to say to your kids about online safety, age by age and the warning signs that matter, and the ones that are just being 14.

When the sessions are online

Video tutoring from a bedroom has the same problem with a screen on it. Put the laptop in the kitchen or living room. Keep the camera facing the table, not the bed. Keep all contact inside the tutoring platform or your own email, not a side channel. Lock down the device too: the phone settings that actually protect kids covers it device by device.

Coaches, youth leaders and churches

Everything above applies to anyone who works with kids, and the burden is heavier on institutions. If you run a team, a youth group or a tutoring program, write the policy down: no one adult alone with one child, windows in doors, group messaging with parents included, two adults on every ride. Make parents' questions welcome. A program that gets defensive about transparency is protecting the wrong thing.

What you can do

Ask the questions. Keep the door open. Teach the surprises-and-secrets rule, and make sure your child knows telling you is always safe.

If you come across online exploitation of a child, report it to the NCMEC CyberTipline at report.cybertip.org (in Canada, Cybertip.ca). Take any concern about a child to local police. If a program or organization is involved, tell its leadership too, but don't let that replace the report.

Josh Halloran

Christian Bro

Leads a mid-week mens group and has done for eleven years. Writes about faith as a practice rather than a position.

Watch

Worth an hour of your evening

More from Protect the Children.

From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.

    keenansolutionsMay 28

    Child Abuse Prevention -- 10 Things You Must Know About Mandatory Reporting

    Local 3 NewsJan 16

    'EVERYONE HAS TO REPORT' How to protect children from perpetrators

    Fight Child AbuseAug 10

    Protect Yourself Rules - Safe Touch / Unsafe Touch

    MyProgressionOct 16

    How to Report a Safeguarding Concern - Safeguarding and Child Protection