Skip to content
GuideEvergreen guide

The compliments that feel wrong, and how kids can tell

Praise from a coach and flattery from a groomer can sound alike. The difference is what each one wants from the kid, and a child can learn to spot it.

By Josh Halloran · Christian Bro5 min read
The compliments that feel wrong, and how kids can tell

Quick answer: Real encouragement is about what a kid did, it works in front of anyone, and it asks nothing back. Grooming flattery is about how special the kid is, it works best in private, and sooner or later it asks for something. Teach children to check three things: who it's for, whether it can be said out loud, and what it wants in return.

The same sentence, two different jobs

A coach says, "That was a great read on defense, Tyler. Do it again Thursday." Tyler's teammates hear it. His dad hears it from the bleachers. Nobody has to think twice about it.

Now picture a message from an adult Tyler met in a game chat, arriving late at night: "You're way more mature than the guys your age. Most people don't get you like I do."

Both are compliments, and both feel good. Only one of them is doing a job on Tyler.

The National Center for Missing & Exploited Children (NCMEC) describes grooming as a process of building trust and an emotional connection with a child so the child will lower their guard. The FBI's public guidance for parents says the same thing from the enforcement side. Offenders commonly start with attention and friendliness, and often try to move the conversation to a private app. Polaris Project, which analyzes trafficking cases in the United States, reports that traffickers commonly pick up on what a young person is missing, such as affection, belonging, money or a place to stay, and offer to supply it.

Notice what that means. Grooming rarely starts with anything that feels wrong. It starts with something that feels like the best part of the kid's week.

Four marks of flattery with an agenda

None of these proves anything alone. Together they should make an adult sit up.

It's about the kid being special, not the kid doing something. Encouragement names a behavior: you stayed after to stack chairs, your essay's second paragraph got sharper. Flattery names a trait nobody can verify: you're gifted, you're different, you're an old soul.

It sets the kid apart from everyone else. "You're not like other kids." "Your parents don't really see what you can do." The comparison is the point. A child who feels misunderstood at home is a child who might lean toward the one person who "gets" them.

It likes privacy. Genuine praise gets handed out in the open because the person giving it's proud. Flattery with an agenda prefers a direct message, a separate app, a quiet moment, and eventually a request to keep things between the two of you. Secrecy is the hinge. Everything else on this list is survivable. A request for secrecy from an adult to a child is the signal to act on.

It comes with an invoice. Sometimes the bill arrives fast and sometimes it takes months. A gift, a favor, extra attention, then a small ask. Then a slightly bigger one. The kindness gets reclassified as a debt.

What a good mentor does differently

Be fair to the good ones, because most adults who invest in kids are exactly what they look like. A coach who stays late to run drills isn't a red flag. A youth pastor who texts a teenager before a big game isn't either.

The difference is transparency. Good mentors are comfortable with parents in the room, copy a second adult on messages, and don't mind a rule that says no one-on-one private messaging with minors. They'd rather have the rule than the suspicion. If you run a team, a classroom or a youth group, adopt that rule before anybody asks you to. It protects the kids, and it protects you.

It also gives you a standard for your own praise. Try this:

  • Say it out loud, in front of people, when you can.
  • Attach it to something the kid actually did.
  • Make it about growth: "that's better than last week" beats "you're the best I've got."
  • Don't ask for anything back, not even a favor or a secret.

Give kids a test they can run themselves

A child can't be expected to read an adult's motives. But a ten-year-old can run a simple check, and a sixteen-year-old will respect one that doesn't treat them like a baby.

Tell them: a good compliment still works when your mom is reading over your shoulder. If you'd feel the need to hide it, delete it or explain it away, that's your answer. Nothing more is required of them. They don't have to prove anything or confront anyone.

Then add the second half, which matters more: you will never be in trouble for telling me. Kids stay quiet when they think the reaction will be about them. They talk when the reaction is about the adult. NCMEC's guidance to parents stresses this point: a child who is being manipulated is the one being wronged, and should hear that first.

For more on keeping that door open, see what to say to your kids about online safety, age by age. And since so much of this starts in chat windows, who's talking to your kid inside the games they play is worth reading next.

If you've already seen it

You find messages that read like the second example. Here's the order.

  1. Stay calm in front of the child. Your first reaction decides whether they tell you the rest.
  2. Don't delete anything. Take screenshots of the conversation and the profile name, and leave the original in place.
  3. Don't confront the adult. It warns them, and it can cost you evidence.
  4. Tell the child plainly that they did nothing wrong. Say it more than once.
  5. Report it. Details are below.

If money or threats have entered the picture, move fast. What to do in the first hour after a sextortion threat walks through it.

Not every odd message means the worst. A friendly adult who's clumsy with boundaries is a conversation, and a good one for a parent or pastor to have. But an adult who asks a child for secrecy is a concern, and concerns go to someone whose job is to look into them.

What you can do, and where to report

Start tonight. Ask your kid what the nicest thing anyone said to them this week was, and who said it. Don't ask it like an interview. Ask it like you want to hear the answer, because you do.

Then make the three-question check part of the house: Who is it for? Could I say it in front of your mom? What does it want back?

Where to report: report online exploitation of a child to the NCMEC CyberTipline at report.cybertip.org (in Canada, Cybertip.ca), and take any concern about a child to local police.

Josh Halloran

Christian Bro

Leads a mid-week mens group and has done for eleven years. Writes about faith as a practice rather than a position.

Watch

Worth an hour of your evening

More from Protect the Children.

From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.

    keenansolutionsMay 28

    Child Abuse Prevention -- 10 Things You Must Know About Mandatory Reporting

    Local 3 NewsJan 16

    'EVERYONE HAS TO REPORT' How to protect children from perpetrators

    Fight Child AbuseAug 10

    Protect Yourself Rules - Safe Touch / Unsafe Touch

    MyProgressionOct 16

    How to Report a Safeguarding Concern - Safeguarding and Child Protection