Skip to content
GuideEvergreen guide

Your job in the first five minutes is to listen, not investigate

When a child tells you something that stops your heart, what you say next matters most. Short scripts, common mistakes, and what happens after you report.

By Josh Halloran · Christian Bro6 min read
Your job in the first five minutes is to listen, not investigate

Quick answer: Stay calm, believe them, thank them for telling you, and don't ask for details. Never promise to keep it secret. Then report it to local police the same day, because your part is to listen and pass it on, not to investigate.

Why this goes wrong

You're driving home from practice. Or folding laundry. Or staying behind to stack chairs. A child says something sideways, almost like a test: "Can I tell you something if you don't get mad?"

Every instinct you have will fire at once. Ask questions. Find out who. Fix it tonight. Those instincts come from love, and they're the ones most likely to do harm.

The reason is simple. Many children disclose in pieces, and they watch your face and your voice after the first piece to decide whether to give you the rest. Children's advocacy centers, which are staffed by people trained to talk with children for investigators, see this pattern constantly. A shocked reaction, an angry one or a flood of questions can make a child feel they've caused a crisis. Some go quiet and don't come back to it for a long time.

So the first five minutes aren't about getting the story. They're about proving you're safe to tell.

What to say

Keep it short. You need about five sentences, and you can say them in your own voice.

  • "Thank you for telling me."
  • "I believe you."
  • "It's not your fault."
  • "I'm glad you told me. You're not in trouble."
  • "I'm going to get help from people whose job is to keep kids safe."

Then stop talking and let them lead. If they want to say more, listen. If they go quiet, don't fill the silence with questions. Sit with them. Hand them a glass of water if that helps.

Keep your face steady. You can be sad. You can't be horrified. If you feel your voice shake, slow down and say less.

What not to do

Every one of these is a normal, human reaction. Know them in advance, so you can catch yourself.

  • Don't interrogate. Skip "Are you sure?", "What exactly happened?" and "Why didn't you tell me sooner?" If you need to clarify something, use open prompts like "Tell me more about that," and only once or twice. Leading questions can damage a later investigation, because the child's own words matter most.
  • Don't promise secrecy. It's the most common mistake and it comes from kindness. You can't keep that promise, and a broken one costs the child more trust than an honest one. Say instead: "I can't keep this just between us, because keeping you safe matters more. But I'll be with you through it."
  • Don't confront the person. Whether it's a relative, a coach, a family friend or someone online, don't call them, message them or have it out with them. It can put the child at greater risk, warn the person to destroy evidence, and wreck the investigation.
  • Don't promise outcomes. "He'll never touch you again" and "you'll be fine" aren't yours to promise. "I'm going to do everything I can" is.
  • Don't delete or forward anything. If the disclosure involves messages, images or an account online, leave it as it is. Don't screenshot and send it around. Don't ask the child to show it to others. The first-hour guide for sextortion threats covers what to preserve.

Why "someone they know" matters here

The white-van picture in most people's heads is wrong. The U.S. Department of Justice and the Child Welfare Information Gateway, a service of the Department of Health and Human Services, both describe the same pattern: children are most often harmed by someone they know and trust. For online exploitation, NCMEC describes people who first make contact through games, apps and social media. We covered that in why the white van myth leaves kids unprotected.

That means the person a child names may be someone you like. Someone your church loves or your family trusts. It can feel impossible. It isn't. Believing a child doesn't mean you've decided anyone's guilt. It means you've decided the adults whose job it's will look into it.

Report it the same day

If you're a teacher, coach, youth leader or other professional who works with children, the law very likely requires you to report. Every U.S. state has mandatory reporting laws, and the Child Welfare Information Gateway publishes a state-by-state summary. Some states require every adult to report. In Canada, child protection is a provincial responsibility, and in many provinces the duty falls on everyone, so check yours.

Even where the law doesn't require you, report anyway. Take it to local police. They work with child protective services and, in many communities, with a children's advocacy center.

Churches and youth organizations, take note. Don't handle it internally. Don't hold a meeting first, don't ask the accused for their side, and don't wait for a board to convene. Report to police, then follow your own policies on notifying leadership. If a child is in immediate danger, none of the above applies. Get the child to safety and get police involved now.

Write down what the child said, in their words, as soon as you can. Include the date and time and where you were. Stick to what they said and what you saw, with no guesses or conclusions. You're making a note for investigators, not building a case.

What comes next

Knowing the road ahead helps you walk it with a child, and it helps you answer their questions honestly.

After a report, police and child protective services decide how to respond. In communities with a children's advocacy center, the child is typically interviewed once by a specially trained interviewer, with police, child protective services, prosecutors and medical and mental health professionals working as a team. The aim, according to National Children's Alliance, the network that accredits these centers, is to avoid making a child tell the story over and over.

You won't always be told much afterward, and that's hard. Confidentiality rules protect the child. Silence from the agencies doesn't mean nothing is happening.

What the child needs from you doesn't change:

  • Routine. School, meals, bedtime, practice. Normal is steadying.
  • Presence. You don't have to talk about it. Be around.
  • Honest answers. "I don't know yet" is a fine answer.
  • Professional help. Ask the children's advocacy center, the child's pediatrician or the school counselor about counseling for the child. Many centers offer or can refer to support for families too.

And take care of yourself. You've just heard something heavy. Talk it through with a counselor or a trusted professional, not with the neighbors. Don't discuss it in front of other kids, and don't share the child's name.

What you can do

Before anyone discloses anything, tell the children in your care that they can tell you hard things and you won't be angry. Say it plainly, once a year, in the car. The age-by-age online safety guide gives you wording for each stage.

If you want to volunteer or give, choose established organizations. Check any charity first: look it up on the IRS Tax Exempt Organization Search, read its latest Form 990, and see whether an independent evaluator like Charity Navigator has reviewed it. In Canada, search the Canada Revenue Agency's charities listing.

Report online exploitation of a child to the NCMEC CyberTipline at report.cybertip.org (in Canada, Cybertip.ca), and take any concern about a child to local police.

Josh Halloran

Christian Bro

Leads a mid-week mens group and has done for eleven years. Writes about faith as a practice rather than a position.

Watch

Worth an hour of your evening

More from Protect the Children.

From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.

    All Pro DadMay 31

    The Scary Truth About Child Grooming and How to Protect Your Kids

    KPRC 2 Click2HoustonSep 2

    How parents can watch for signs of grooming

    eSafety OfficeAug 20

    eSafety for parents - Online grooming - Sharon's vlog

    WCCO - CBS MinnesotaOct 24

    Signs of grooming parents and kids should watch for