Bring your Bible Sunday and check the sermon against it
A pastor can quote Scripture all morning and never teach it. Here's how to tell the difference from the pew, without being a jerk about it.

Quick answer: Open a paper Bible Sunday and follow along. If the sermon stays in the passage, explains what it says, and lands on Christ, you're being taught. If the verse is read once and never visited again, it's decoration.
A pastor reads Jeremiah 29:11 off the screen. "For I know the plans I have for you." Then he talks for thirty minutes about chasing your dreams, and you leave feeling great. Nobody mentions that the verse was written to exiles in Babylon, who were told to build houses, plant gardens and sit tight for seventy years.
That's the whole problem in one sermon. The Bible was present. It just wasn't doing anything.
The verse is a hood ornament
Decoration has a recognizable shape. A verse opens the message, a story fills the middle, and the application could have been delivered by a motivational speaker with no Bible at all. Take the verse away and nothing collapses.
Real teaching works the other way. The passage carries the weight. Paul told Timothy that all Scripture is God-breathed and useful for teaching, rebuking, correcting and training (2 Timothy 3:16). Notice the list. Rebuking and correcting are in there. A sermon that only encourages has dropped half the job.
Nehemiah 8:8 shows the pattern. The Levites read the Law aloud, "gave the sense," and helped the people understand. Read it, explain it, apply it, in that order.
Bring a paper Bible
This is the simplest test, and it costs nothing. Carry a physical Bible in and track the sermon with your finger.
Count how many times the pastor sends you to the text. Count how often he stays in it long enough for you to see where his points came from. A good preacher makes you want to check his work. The Bereans in Acts 17:11 "examined the Scriptures daily to see if these things were so," and Luke calls them noble for it.
If the message can't survive that, it was never built on the text.
One concession. A topical sermon isn't automatically a bad one. A pastor can teach on marriage or money by walking through several passages, and do it well. What matters is whether each point is pulled out of a text or merely attached to one.
Ask what the sermon asks of you
Think back over the last month. Has anything you heard from that pulpit cost you something? Has the pastor preached a hard passage on anger, forgiveness, sexual purity, giving, or the way you talk about your boss?
Paul warned that a time would come when people wouldn't put up with sound teaching and would pile up teachers to suit their own desires, itching ears and all (2 Timothy 4:3-4). A church that only ever tells you what you want to hear is a church that has chosen its audience over its text.
Watch for a few specific tells:
- Hard passages get skipped, softened, or "reframed" until they say nothing.
- Every message is about you, and none are about God.
- The pastor never says "I was wrong about this" or "this text corrects me."
A man preaching the Bible will eventually preach something that stings him too.
Read the statement of faith, then ask about it
Every sound church has one, and it's usually a click away. Read it. Does it say plainly that Jesus is God's Son, crucified and risen? That Scripture is true and authoritative? That salvation is by grace through faith in Christ alone?
Then ask a staff member a direct question: "Is this what you actually teach on Sunday?" Churches are free to hold and state their beliefs, as a court recently affirmed when it ruled that a Maine school board couldn't refuse a church a lease over its beliefs. Which means you're entitled to know what they are before you give them your family's Sundays.
A good statement with weak preaching is common. A thin statement is worse. Some churches post two vague paragraphs about "community" and "journey" and leave out the cross. That tells you something.
Listen for the cross
Decoration can quote every verse on the page and still miss the point. So listen for the gospel itself. Does the church tell you plainly that you're a sinner, that Christ died for your sins and rose again, and that Jesus is the only way to the Father (John 14:6, Acts 4:12)? Is repentance preached, or only "your best life"?
This is our opinion, and we'll argue it from the text. We believe the health-and-wealth message, where faith is a lever for money and comfort, swaps the gospel for self-help. It has to ignore Jesus telling would-be followers to take up a cross (Luke 9:23) and Paul's own list of beatings and shipwrecks. You don't need to name names to spot it. If God's job in the sermon is to make you rich, that's not the God of the book.
Galatians 1:8 is blunt about any message that departs from the gospel. Don't treat it lightly, and don't use it as a club on a pastor who's merely dull.
Judge the pattern, not the Sunday
One bad sermon proves nothing. Every pastor has an off week, and some tuck a lazy illustration into a good text. Look at a season. Does the church work through whole books of the Bible, or does it hop between series titled like self-help paperbacks? Does the teaching make you want to read more at home, or less?
Church history is a long record of believers sorting the sound from the showy, and the weekly Christian history roundup is a decent reminder that none of this is new. Two things hold across the centuries: the Word is the standard, and the people who keep to it tend to outlast the fashion.
What to do when you find decoration
Don't launch a crusade from the third row. Start with a conversation. Ask your pastor, kindly, how he prepares a sermon and why he chose a certain passage. A humble man will tell you, and some will welcome the question.
Then decide which kind of problem you've got. If it's style, say a pastor who's dry or a service that's louder than you'd like, stay. Serve, give, show up early and stay to stack the chairs. Leave the place better than you found it. Preferences aren't a reason to walk out on people.
If the gospel is missing, or hard texts are routinely dodged, or the pastor can't be questioned, that's different. Hold the line. You're responsible for your wife, your kids, and what they hear every week. Leave quietly, without a scene and without gossip, and find a church that opens the book and sits under it.
Visit three or four times before you decide. Take your Bible. And pay attention to whether, after the benediction, you're thinking about the pastor or about the passage.
Cal Brennan
Fitness
Strength coach. Trains fathers, tradesmen and desk workers, which means programs that survive a bad week.
Watch
Worth an hour of your evening
More from Christian Bro.
From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.
Read next
