Skip to content
BRO TakeEvergreen guide

The coworker who makes you nervous has something you need

That tight feeling when a peer wins the room is information. Here's how to turn it into a skill instead of a grudge.

By Marcus Vale · Editor-in-Chief5 min read
The coworker who makes you nervous has something you need

Commentary.

Quick answer: The guy who makes your stomach tighten in the meeting is showing you a gap. Name the gap, ask him about it, borrow one skill, and keep your own character while you do it.

It's the Tuesday staff meeting. Your peer finishes a two-minute update and the VP says, "Good. Let's do it that way." You've been on this team three years. So has he. Your stomach does that thing.

Most men respond one of two ways. They shrink and decide the game is rigged, or they sharpen their elbows and start keeping score. Both cost you months, and neither teaches you anything.

The tightening in your gut is data. You don't feel threatened by people who have nothing you want. You feel it when someone has a thing you value and you've been pretending you don't.

Name what actually stung

"He's just political" isn't an answer. Neither is "he's a natural." Get specific, and write it on paper if you have to.

What did he do in that meeting? Maybe he framed the ask in the VP's own numbers instead of his team's. Maybe he sent a one-page summary the night before so nobody was hearing it cold. Maybe he'd already talked to finance, so the room had no surprises. Maybe he said "no" to a side request in one sentence without apologizing for it.

Those are behaviors. Behaviors can be copied.

If you can't name one, you're envying the outcome, not studying the man. Keep digging until you've got a verb. "He pre-wires his meetings" is useful. "He's good with people" is a mood.

Sort the skill from the sin

Some men win honestly. Some win by taking credit that isn't theirs or by quietly undercutting the guy next to them. You don't want to learn the second kind, and you should be able to tell them apart.

Watch for a few things over a couple of weeks. Do his people stay with him? Does he give credit out loud when something goes well? Do folks in other departments return his calls the same day? If so, you're looking at a skill, and a good one.

If he wins by leaving bodies behind him, you still learned something. You learned to document your work, put your name on it, and keep your manager in the loop. You also learned what you won't do. That's worth knowing, but it isn't the guy to apprentice yourself to.

Be careful here, though. Plenty of honest men write off every successful peer as a schemer, because that's easier than admitting he's better at something. I made the case in Staying out of office politics is how honest men lose that refusing to see how influence works isn't virtue. It's just losing with a clear conscience you didn't have to earn.

Ask him

This is the step nobody takes, because it feels like admitting he's ahead of you.

He's ahead of you on one thing. Admitting it costs you a sentence. Not admitting it can cost you three more years.

Catch him after a meeting and keep it short. "The way you set up that budget ask was sharp. How'd you prep it?" That's the whole move. No flattery speech, no hidden agenda. Most people like being asked about their craft, and they'll talk longer than you expect.

The annoying part is that it's awkward. He might shrug and say "nothing special." He might be too busy that week. Try once more a month later with a narrower question, like "How do you decide who to talk to before the meeting?" If he still brushes you off, let it go. Some men guard what they know. You've lost nothing, and you can still watch him work.

Borrow one thing

Pick a single behavior and run it for a month. Send the pre-read the night before. Talk to finance before the meeting, not in it. Lead with the VP's number.

Don't try to become him. You'll end up as a bad copy of a good original, and people can smell it. Take the one tool and fit it to your own voice.

Notice, too, what's under the tool. When people already follow a man, it's usually because he's been reliable in small things for a long time. I wrote about that in The promotion goes to the guy people already follow. The tactic is the visible part. The trust took years.

Watch the price tag

Say he's answering email at 11 p.m. and missed his kid's Saturday game twice this month. That's part of how he got where he is.

You can learn his preparation without paying his hours. Decide ahead of time what you're willing to spend. Maybe it's thirty extra minutes of prep on the nights before big meetings. It isn't your dinner table, your wife's evenings, or your kids' ballgames.

The concession is real. Holding that line may mean he gets a particular promotion before you do, or instead of you. That's a fair trade for a man who wants to be known at home as more than the guy who's usually at the office. Make it with your eyes open, and don't sulk about it later.

Hold a second line too. If a peer takes your idea and presents it as his, say so once, calmly, in the room. "Glad that landed. It's the approach I sent over on the ninth." No heat, no speech. Serving your team is one thing. Letting someone walk on you is another.

Pay it back

When his tip works, tell him. Better yet, tell his boss, or say it in the next team meeting. Credit is free, and it's the kind of thing people remember.

Then pass it down. Some junior guy on your team is watching you the way you watched your peer. Show him the pre-read trick before he has to ask. Leave the place a little better than you found it. If you're heading toward management, hand off the work you're best at first is the same idea at a larger scale.

Next Tuesday, he'll finish his update and the room will nod. Your stomach will tighten again. Let it. Then take out a notebook.

Marcus Vale

Editor-in-Chief

Twenty years in magazines, most of it deciding what to cut. Writes about work, discipline and the decisions that compound.

Watch

Worth an hour of your evening

More from Corporate Men.

From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.

    Business InsiderJan 13

    Barbara Corcoran Explains How To Ask For A Raise

    Andrew LaCivitaMar 31

    How to Negotiate a Raise During Your Promotion

    AdviceWithErinMar 20

    How to: Ask for a Raise (& actually get it!)

    CareerVidzNov 4

    HOW TO ASK FOR A RAISE! (7 SALARY NEGOTIATION TIPS for Getting a PAY RISE at Work!)