Skip to content
GuideEvergreen guide

Take the token out and see what's left

One question sorts most crypto projects into real or hype in about five minutes, and the people selling the token hope you never ask it.

By Ray Okonkwo · Money & Business6 min read
crypto section

Quick answer: Delete the token from the pitch and see what's left. If someone would still pay for what remains, you may be looking at a real project. If nothing's left, the token was the product, and you're the customer.

Picture the pitch. A friend forwards you a link. There's a 40-page white paper, a four-phase roadmap and a chat server with tens of thousands of people in it. The project promises to "bring supply chain tracking on-chain." Everybody in the chat is excited. Nobody in the chat is a freight dispatcher.

Before you read page two, ask what happens if the token disappears.

The deletion test

A trucking company that wants to track shipments needs a database. Databases are cheap, fast and boring. They exist today, and the company's own IT guy can run one. Put that same job on a blockchain and it gets slower and more expensive, and it needs a token that somebody has to buy.

So who benefits from the token? Whoever holds it early.

That's the tell. When the "solution" works fine without the coin, the coin isn't solving anything. It's the thing for sale, and the logistics story is the packaging.

Run the test on any project. Strip out the token, strip out the word "decentralized," and write down in one plain sentence what's left and who needs it. If you can't write the sentence, you're done. If the sentence is "it lets early holders profit when new buyers arrive," you're done faster.

Where the token really does earn its keep

The test isn't a trick that kills everything. Some projects pass it, and you should know why.

Bitcoin passes. The coin isn't decorating a product. The coin is the product: a scarce asset capped at 21 million units, with no company behind it, that pays the people who secure the network. Take the token out and there's no network. If you skipped the last decade, this explainer on Bitcoin covers the basics.

Dollar-backed stablecoins pass for a different reason. Moving dollars across a border on a Sunday night, with no bank in the middle, is a job people have always paid to get done. The token is the dollar. There's nothing to speculate on, which is the point.

The pattern is the same in both. The token does work that a plain database can't do. It carries value, or it pays for security, and the project says so in one sentence.

Name the customer

Real products have a specific person on the other end. A guy sending part of his paycheck to his mother overseas. A shop owner sick of card fees. A saver in a country where the currency loses value every year.

"Everyone" isn't a customer. "The world" isn't a customer. Neither is "the community."

Ask three questions about the person you've named:

  • What do they use today?
  • What does it cost them?
  • Why would they bother switching, given that switching is a hassle?

If the answer to the last one is "because it's on a blockchain," the project is asking users to take on risk and learn a new tool for nothing in return. Real customers move for a better price, a faster result or a freedom they didn't have. Almost nobody moves for a buzzword.

Follow the money inside the project

Find out where the revenue comes from. Not the price. The revenue.

A real project earns fees from people who got something they wanted. A hype project pays its "returns" with newly issued tokens or with money from the next wave of buyers. If the yield is paid in the project's own coin, it's being printed. If the pitch promises a fixed return, treat it as a warning. Real businesses don't guarantee 20 percent on anything. The crypto scams that catch careful people too walks through how those pitches are built, and why smart readers fall for them.

If a public company is attached to the project, the old habit applies. Read the filings before you buy the ticker. The number a company puts in a press release and the number it signs under penalty of law are often different numbers.

Check who holds the supply

This one's dull and it saves people money.

Most projects publish how the tokens are split. Look for the share held by the founders, the team and the early investors, and then for the unlock schedule. If a big slice of the supply is held by insiders and unlocks in the next year, those insiders have a reason to sell to you. They got in at a fraction of your price and they have a date on the calendar.

Compare that with Bitcoin, where nobody got a founder's allocation to unload on the public. That's a design choice, and it matters.

Anonymous teams deserve a straight answer too. Bitcoin's creator was anonymous, and the system worked anyway. But he wasn't selling anybody a token or asking for money. An anonymous team asking for yours is a different situation entirely.

The hype tells

You can spot most of these in the first minute on a project's website.

  • The price chart is the first thing you see.
  • The roadmap is mostly partnerships "in talks," not things that shipped.
  • Celebrity or influencer endorsements stand in for a working product.
  • Nobody can explain it in one sentence without saying "ecosystem."
  • The marketing is done by holders who are hoping you'll buy.
  • There's a countdown timer.

One of these means look closer. Three means walk away.

A five-question scorecard

Write the answers down. Don't hold them in your head, because your head wants the trade to work.

  1. What does the project do if you delete the token?
  2. Who is the specific customer, and why would they switch?
  3. Where does the revenue come from, besides new buyers?
  4. How much of the supply do insiders hold, and when does it unlock?
  5. Has anything actually shipped that a stranger uses and pays for?

A project with clean answers to all five is worth more of your time. A project that dodges two or more is chasing hype, however good the graphics are.

What a passing score still doesn't mean

A real problem doesn't make the token a good buy. A project can solve something useful and still be priced for perfection, or lose to a better competitor, or run out of money. The test sorts projects into "worth studying" and "skip," and that's all it does.

If you do put money in, keep it to what you can lose without it touching the mortgage, the grocery budget or your family's emergency fund. For taxes and for your particular situation, talk to a CPA or a licensed financial advisor who understands digital assets. And keep your records in order, because the biggest threat to your crypto is your own filing system.

One opinion, labeled as such. The original promise of this technology was money that doesn't need anyone's permission and a way for ordinary people to hold their own wealth free of someone else's printing press. That's a real problem, and a few projects solve it. A lot of the rest is a casino with a white paper.

A real problem doesn't need a countdown timer.

Ray Okonkwo

Money & Business

Former commercial banker turned small-business owner. Covers salary, credit, margins and the arithmetic nobody does before signing.

Watch

Worth an hour of your evening

More from Crypto.

From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.

    Graham StephanNov 16

    What EVERYONE Needs To Do With Their Money ASAP

    Graham StephanNov 12

    NBA Player On Flying Private...

    Graham StephanNov 11

    How Is This Legal??

    Crypto TipsNov 11

    5 Red Weeks for Bitcoin: What History Says Happens Next