Before you share it, ask who would actually know
A claim is only as good as its distance from someone who saw it, signed it or studied it. Here's how to measure that distance in under five minutes.

Quick answer: Before you believe or share a claim, name the person who would know if it were true: the witness, the record-keeper, the specialist. Then check whether the post in front of you comes from that person, or from someone repeating someone repeating them. The more hops, the less you have.
On April 23, 2013, a tweet went out from the Associated Press account: two explosions at the White House, and the president was hurt. It was false. The account had been hacked. Stock prices dipped sharply and recovered within minutes, which tells you how many people and machines acted on a single post from a source they trusted.
Nobody in that chain was stupid. The account looked right, so everyone assumed the person behind it knew. That assumption is the sourcing gap.
The gap has a length
Every claim travels from someone who knows to you. Count the hops.
A nurse tells you what happened on her shift. That's zero hops. Her cousin tells you. One hop. A stranger posts "my cousin's friend is a nurse and says." Three. A screenshot of that post, cropped, with a caption in all capitals. Now you're holding something that may have started with a real person, or may have started with nobody.
Social media doesn't create bad information. It deletes the hop count. A screenshot looks the same whether it's one step from the source or ten. So you have to rebuild the count yourself.
Name the person who'd know
This is the whole method, and it takes ten seconds. Finish the sentence: "The person who would actually know this is ______."
- A claim about a school board vote: the minutes, or someone who sat in the room.
- A claim about what a bill does: the text of the bill.
- A claim about a drug: the label, or a pharmacist or physician.
- A claim about a crime: the police report, the charging document, the court docket.
- A claim about what someone said: the full recording or transcript.
Then look at what you've actually been given. Is it that person, or that document? Or is it someone's feelings about it?
Most viral claims fail right here. The post says "they're hiding this," and nobody who'd know is named, linked or quoted.
What a crowd of amateurs gets wrong
After the 2013 Boston Marathon bombing, users on Reddit tried to identify the bombers from photos. They settled on Sunil Tripathi, a missing Brown University student, who had nothing to do with it. His family was flooded with messages while they were searching for their son. He was later found dead, and Reddit's leadership publicly apologized for the pile-on.
The crowd had enthusiasm, free time and photographs. What it lacked was access to anything that could confirm a name. The people who knew, the investigators, weren't talking yet. Amateurs filled the vacuum with a guess and handed the guess a face.
Whenever the real source is silent, expect the feed to be loudest.
Speed hurts the careful side too
In January 2019, a short video clip from the Lincoln Memorial spread fast. It appeared to show a group of Covington Catholic High School students, one in a MAGA hat, mocking a Native American elder. Condemnation was swift, and not only from anonymous accounts. Public figures and news outlets weighed in within hours.
Longer footage emerged the next day and complicated the picture. The students had been taunted beforehand by a separate group, and the encounter looked less one-sided than the clip suggested. The student at the center, Nick Sandmann, later sued several outlets over their coverage, and some of those suits were settled.
Conservatives are right to be angry about how that went. Big outlets treated a snippet as a verdict. But the lesson cuts in every direction. A clip is a claim about what happened, and the claim is only as good as what was cropped out of it. That's true when the clip flatters your side, and it's true when it flatters the other.
The five-minute check
- Find the original. Search a distinctive phrase from the post, or run an image through a reverse image search. Ask whether the full video, full document or full quote exists somewhere.
- Click the account. When was it created? Does it name a real person? Does it post about one subject or about everything? A brand-new account with ten thousand followers and no history deserves suspicion.
- Look for the link. A real claim usually points at something: a filing, a study, a transcript. If the post points only at other posts, that's a loop.
- Check for a second, independent path. Not another account repeating the first. A different person who'd have their own way of knowing. For help judging when someone unnamed deserves belief, see When an Anonymous Source Is Worth Believing, and When It Isn't.
- Look at the timestamp. Is it a breaking claim? The first hour of any big story is the least reliable. Details get revised, and people get misidentified.
If you've done all five and you're still unsure, that's your answer. You don't know yet.
When the post is the source
There's a fair objection here. Sometimes a social media post is the primary source.
A sitting president posting a statement is the best evidence of what he said. A witness filming an event as it happens is a first-hand source. A surgeon explaining a procedure she performs weekly knows more than most reporters. Dismissing them because of the platform is its own laziness.
The distinction is narrow but it matters. A post proves that the person said it. It doesn't prove what they said is true. A senator's post about a bill is primary evidence of the senator's position, and tells you nothing yet about the bill. Check the bill. That rule applies to officials you like and officials you don't.
The expert on your feed
Credentials help, but only inside their lane. A cardiologist talking about hearts has earned a hearing. The same cardiologist talking about election law has an opinion, the same as your neighbor.
Ask three things. Is the person speaking within what they've actually trained in? Do they show their work, with studies, data or examples you can check? And do they ever say "I don't know" or "I got that wrong"? Anyone who has never been wrong in public is either not checking or not telling you. The same test applies to outlets, and How to Tell Which Outlets Actually Own Their Mistakes walks through it.
The cheapest tool you own
Waiting is free. Most false claims lose their grip in a day or two, when the person who knows finally speaks. Anyone who shares in the first ten minutes is betting you won't remember that they were wrong.
Don't make that bet for them. If you can't name who'd know, and can't find that person's fingerprints on the claim, leave it where you found it. Nobody's ever been embarrassed by saying "I'll wait and see."
Your feed can't tell you who's close to the truth. You have to ask.
Marcus Vale
Editor-in-Chief
Twenty years in magazines, most of it deciding what to cut. Writes about work, discipline and the decisions that compound.
Watch
Worth an hour of your evening
More from Media Literacy.
From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.
Read next
