Skip to content
GuideEvergreen guide

The cheap tax years start when the second paycheck stops

Two spouses, two retirement dates, one tax return. Get the order right and you can buy decades of lower taxes in the gap between them.

By Ray Okonkwo · Money & Business6 min read
The cheap tax years start when the second paycheck stops

Quick answer: Your retirement date isn't one date. It's at least five: when each of you stops working, when each of you turns 65, and when each of you claims Social Security. Line them up on a single calendar before you pick any of them. The low-tax window usually opens when the second paycheck stops, not the first.

This is general education, not individual financial, tax or legal advice. Limits, ages and thresholds change every year or so. Check anything you plan to act on at SSA.gov, Medicare.gov and IRS.gov, then run it past a fee-only fiduciary adviser or a CPA.

Start with the insurance, not the party

The first spouse to retire usually sets the date because of how they feel. The date that matters more is when each of you has health coverage that isn't a problem.

Medicare starts at 65, and it covers the person, not the household. If you're 66 and your wife is 61, you're on Medicare and she isn't. She needs her own coverage for four years. That could be her employer's plan if she keeps working, COBRA for a limited stretch, or a marketplace plan.

That's the quiet reason many couples stagger on purpose. One keeps working, and the plan comes along for the other. It's an ordinary, sensible arrangement, and it's worth real money.

Two traps sit on the Medicare side:

  • Part B late penalty. Miss your enrollment window and the premium goes up 10 percent for each full year you were late, for as long as you have Part B. Coverage through your own current job generally lets you wait. Retiree coverage and COBRA generally don't. Confirm with Medicare.gov and your HR office before you rely on it.
  • HSA contributions. Once Medicare Part A starts, you can't keep contributing to a health savings account. Part A can reach back up to six months, so stop earlier than you'd think.

Why the first retirement isn't the cheap year

This is where most couples get it backward.

Say you retire first and stop earning. It feels like the start of your low-income years. But if your wife is still pulling a salary, your joint tax return is built on her wages. Anything you withdraw from a traditional IRA stacks on top of that salary. You'd be converting money to a Roth at her top rate, not at a low one.

The cheap years arrive when both paychecks are gone and Social Security hasn't started. For many couples that window runs a few years, sometimes more. Income is whatever you choose to pull from your accounts, which means you control which bracket you land in. Few people ever get that kind of control over their tax rate. Spending it well is the real work of timing your dates.

A worked example (invented numbers, for illustration only)

Frank is 64 and retires. His wife Linda is 61 and works three more years at $80,000. Frank is the higher earner and plans to claim Social Security at 70. Linda plans to claim at 67.

During those three years, Linda's wages and her employer's insurance carry the household. Frank takes nothing out of his IRA. A Roth conversion now would be taxed on top of her salary, so he skips it.

At 64, Linda retires. Frank is 67. They have no wages and no Social Security, and they spend roughly $80,000 a year from savings. This is the window. A CPA might show them they can pull that $80,000 from the traditional accounts and add a Roth conversion on top, staying inside a bracket they're comfortable with. They'd do it for three years, until Frank claims at 70.

Those numbers are made up and aren't a forecast. The shape is the point. You fill a bracket you chose on purpose now, so you aren't forced into a bigger one later.

Why bother converting at all

Two reasons, both plain arithmetic.

First, required minimum distributions. The age they start depends on your birth year (currently 73 or 75). A large pre-tax balance forces withdrawals at that age whether you need the money or not, and they land on top of Social Security. Check IRS.gov for your date.

Second, the survivor. When one spouse dies, the other files as a single person. The brackets get narrower while the income often drops only a little. That's sometimes called the widow's penalty, and it hits widowers just as hard. Paying tax at a modest married rate now can beat paying a higher single rate on the same money later.

For the order in which to spend your accounts, see Which Retirement Account To Spend From First.

Social Security: the bigger check protects the survivor

The usual staggered approach has the lower earner claim earlier and the higher earner wait. It works because when one spouse dies, the survivor keeps the larger of the two benefits, not both. The higher earner's benefit grows about 8 percent a year if you delay past full retirement age until 70. That's a bigger check for whoever outlives the other.

The trade-off is cash flow. Delaying means living off savings in the meantime. That's the same savings pool you were going to draw on for conversions, so the two strategies compete for dollars and need to be planned together.

Concede the other side too. If the higher earner is in poor health, or you simply need the income, claiming earlier can be the right call. A delay only pays off if you live long enough to collect it.

A few mechanics to confirm at SSA.gov:

  • Claiming before full retirement age means a permanently smaller benefit.
  • Working while claiming before full retirement age can trigger the earnings test, which withholds benefits above a yearly limit.
  • A spousal benefit is capped at roughly half the worker's full-retirement-age benefit, and the worker generally has to have filed first. Delaying past full retirement age doesn't increase it.

Pensions add one more decision. If either of you has one, the survivor option you pick at retirement is usually permanent. A single-life pension pays more now and nothing to the widow. Many plans require the spouse's written consent to choose it. Don't sign anything until you've seen both versions side by side.

The Medicare surcharge that arrives two years late

A big conversion year raises your income, and Medicare premiums can rise with it. The surcharge, called IRMAA, looks back two years at your tax return. A large conversion at 65 can show up in your Part B and Part D premiums at 67.

It's a cost, not a reason to freeze. Count it when you size a conversion. And if your income dropped because you stopped working, you can ask the Social Security Administration to use a more recent year. Retirement counts as a qualifying life event.

Bring this to the table

Before the first meeting with a CPA or adviser, put these on one page:

  • Both birthdays and the month you'd each like to stop working.
  • Which spouse's employer coverage you'd rely on, and until when.
  • Your best guess at each Social Security benefit, from your statements at SSA.gov.
  • Balances split into pre-tax, Roth and taxable.
  • Any pension, and whether a survivor option is on the table.
  • The yearly spending you'd actually need.

If a mortgage is still running, When To Pay Off The Mortgage Before You Retire belongs on that page too. And if one of you will be home on a weekday while the other isn't, What to do with Tuesday morning when you retire is worth reading before the calendar gets final.

Retirement is the one project you and your wife get to design together. Two dates, two checks, one return. Draw it on paper first, and let the tax code work for you for a change.

Ray Okonkwo

Money & Business

Former commercial banker turned small-business owner. Covers salary, credit, margins and the arithmetic nobody does before signing.

Watch

Worth an hour of your evening

More from Retirement.

From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.

    Erin Talks Money | Erin MoriarityJan 1

    Step-by-Step Guide to Tax-Efficient Retirement Withdrawals: Social Security, Roth IRAs & 401(k)s

    The Ramsey Show HighlightsDec 16

    What's The Right Way To Invest 15% Of Your Income?

    Our Rich JourneySep 13

    Roth IRAs and How They Can Help You Retire Early

    Rose HanJan 8

    5 Best Investments for Your Roth IRA