Skip to content
GuideEvergreen guide

The coach everyone loves keeps bending one rule

Rule-bending in youth sports usually looks like kindness. Here's how to spot the pattern early, say something politely, and know where to take it.

By Josh Halloran · Christian Bro6 min read
The coach everyone loves keeps bending one rule

Quick answer: A good coach doesn't mind rules about private rides, private texts and closed doors. He's glad to have them. When a coach keeps bending those, don't weigh his win record. Weigh the pattern, and ask about it early, calmly and out loud.

The third ride home

The first time Coach drove your daughter home, he had a reason. It was on his way. Practice ran late. You were stuck at work, and you were grateful.

The second time, same reason. The third time, she was already in his truck when you pulled up. Then came a text thread you weren't on, a pair of free cleats, and a line about how she's got real talent and he'd hate to see it wasted.

Nothing on that list is a crime. Every item has an innocent explanation. That's exactly why it works on a busy parent, and why you're the one to catch it.

Why the small stuff matters

The FBI and the National Center for Missing & Exploited Children (NCMEC) both describe grooming as gradual. It starts with attention, favors and a growing sense that the child is special. Then come small exceptions to the normal rules, each a little bigger than the last. Nobody opens with the worst thing. They open with a ride, a text, a gift, and they watch what the adults around the child do about it.

If the adults say nothing, the next exception gets easier. If the child is made to feel that the arrangement is a secret or a privilege, that's the point where it gets harder to undo.

The adult is also rarely a stranger. The old picture of a van at the mall misses how this usually happens, as this piece on the white van myth lays out. The people who get close to kids are usually people the family already trusts. A coach qualifies. So does a youth leader, a tutor, a friendly neighbor.

Concede the obvious. Most coaches who run late, text the team and give a kid a ride are just busy volunteers doing a good thing with bad logistics. You aren't looking for villains. You're looking for the habit of working around the rules, because a well-run program makes those workarounds unnecessary.

Why you see it first

The league board sees a coach with a winning record. The other coaches see a colleague. The kids see an adult who believes in them.

You're the only one who sees the whole picture: the rides, the texts, the gifts and the way your kid's mood changes around the subject. That's not paranoia. It's a vantage point nobody else has.

It's also why a program that says "everybody loves him" isn't offering you evidence. Popular and safe aren't the same word.

What a good program already does

The U.S. Center for SafeSport was set up under a 2017 federal law to handle abuse in Olympic and amateur sport. It publishes Minor Athlete Abuse Prevention Policies for the organizations it oversees. They rest on a few plain ideas:

  • One-on-one time between an adult and a minor should be observable and interruptible, meaning in the open, where another adult can walk in.
  • Electronic messages with minor athletes should be transparent, with a parent or another adult copied.
  • Private travel and overnight lodging with minors get firm limits.

In Canada, the Coaching Association of Canada's Responsible Coaching Movement promotes the Rule of Two. In short, a coach isn't alone with a minor athlete.

Your Saturday rec league or church team may not fall under any of that. Which is the first thing to find out. Ask what the rules are. If there aren't any, that's your answer too.

The first conversation

Keep it friendly and keep it a question. You aren't accusing anybody. You're a parent asking a normal parent question.

  • "What's the policy on rides? I'd rather pick up myself, or have a second adult in the car."
  • "Can you add me to the team group chat? I'd like to see what's going out."
  • "Is there a rule about coaches messaging kids one-on-one?"

Then watch how the answer lands.

A good coach says, "Glad you asked. Here's how we do it." Some will thank you. The best ones will say it should've been in the welcome packet.

Be concerned if you get any of these:

  • Offense. "Don't you trust me?"
  • Pressure. "You're making this weird."
  • Contempt for the rule itself. "Kids need toughening up, not hand-holding."
  • Anything that lands on your child afterward: cooler treatment, sudden benching, or hints that you're hurting their chances.

A coach who punishes a child for a parent's question has told you what you needed to know.

What isn't the warning sign

Don't confuse intensity with a problem. Brutal conditioning, hard words about effort, a kid who sits the bench after a bad week. That's coaching, and a lot of tough coaches are the safest people in the building. Their tough standards are out in the open, applied to everybody, and they'd never ask a kid to keep quiet.

The signs worth acting on are about privacy and exclusivity:

  • Time alone with one child, especially away from the field or gym
  • Gifts and favors that aren't offered to the whole team
  • Private messages, especially late at night or on apps that delete themselves
  • Special status for one child, along with a quiet chill toward the parents
  • Any request that a child keep something from Mom and Dad

For the difference between a real flag and an ordinary teenage mood swing, read the warning signs that matter, and the ones that are just being 14. A teacher's eye picks up some of the same changes in this piece on what teachers see first.

Talk to your kid before you need to

You don't need a frightening speech. You need three sentences your child hears often:

  • No adult should ask you to keep a secret from us.
  • Your body and your messages are yours.
  • You will never be in trouble for telling us something, even if somebody said you would be.

Say them at breakfast, in the car, when you're driving to practice on your own. The age-by-age guide to online safety has wording for younger and older kids.

Then do the old-fashioned part. Show up early. Stay to stack the chairs. Volunteer to be one of the two adults at practice, and pass the background check your program asks for. A parent in the bleachers is the cheapest protection a team has.

What to do and where to report

If a coach keeps bending the rules after you've asked, take it to the league director, club board or school athletic director, in writing, with dates. Write down what you saw and when. Don't investigate on your own, and don't confront anyone in front of the kids.

If the organization is under a national governing body, you can also go to the U.S. Center for SafeSport at uscenterforsafesport.org. Federal law requires covered adults in those organizations to report suspected abuse to the authorities.

A coach worth trusting with your child won't need you to look away.

Report online exploitation of a child to the NCMEC CyberTipline at report.cybertip.org (in Canada, Cybertip.ca), and take any concern about a child to local police.

Josh Halloran

Christian Bro

Leads a mid-week mens group and has done for eleven years. Writes about faith as a practice rather than a position.

Watch

Worth an hour of your evening

More from Protect the Children.

From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.

    keenansolutionsMay 28

    Child Abuse Prevention -- 10 Things You Must Know About Mandatory Reporting

    Local 3 NewsJan 16

    'EVERYONE HAS TO REPORT' How to protect children from perpetrators

    Fight Child AbuseAug 10

    Protect Yourself Rules - Safe Touch / Unsafe Touch

    MyProgressionOct 16

    How to Report a Safeguarding Concern - Safeguarding and Child Protection