Skip to content
GuideEvergreen guide

When the tithe feels impossible, start at one percent

Ten percent can look like a fantasy when the account's nearly empty. Scripture asks for something smaller and harder: a decision made before the bills get a vote.

By Cal Brennan · Fitness5 min read
When the tithe feels impossible, start at one percent

Quick answer: Pay for the roof and the groceries first. Then pick a percentage you can actually keep, even if it's one, and give it on payday before anything else gets a claim on it. Raise it as you're able.

Say you take home $3,200 a month. A tenth is $320. If the rent is $1,400, the truck payment is $450 and the groceries are climbing, that $320 isn't a gift. It's a hole in the budget with a church's name on it.

So you skip the offering plate, feel a little worse each Sunday, and tell yourself you'll start when things ease up. They don't ease up on their own. They almost never do.

Here's a better way to think about it.

Start with the roof

Paul doesn't hedge in 1 Timothy 5:8. A man who won't provide for his own household has denied the faith and is worse than an unbeliever. That's about as blunt as the New Testament gets, and it's in the same book that tells churches to honor their teachers.

So giving can't be the thing that puts your family on the street. Nobody's asking you to miss the mortgage to hit a number. A church that tells you otherwise has stopped teaching Scripture and started collecting.

But notice what that verse doesn't say. It doesn't say your family's needs get covered first and then you give whatever's left. The leftover almost always turns out to be zero. Provision comes first. Giving comes second. Everything else comes after that.

Pick a number you can keep

Jesus affirmed tithing in Matthew 23:23. He told the Pharisees they'd neglected justice and mercy and faithfulness, and that they should have practiced those without leaving the tithe undone. A tenth is the benchmark most evangelical churches teach, and it's a sound one.

Christians do argue over whether the tenth is a binding command on believers today or a starting point for generosity. Paul never hands the Corinthians a percentage. He says to set something aside "as God has prospered him" (1 Corinthians 16:2). Either way, a tenth is where you're headed.

But a benchmark isn't a starting line for everyone.

If ten percent is out of reach this month, start with one. On $3,200 that's $32. It sounds small, almost embarrassing. Do it anyway. Then raise it one point at a time: after a raise, after the car's paid off, after a year of steady work, whichever comes first. A man who gives one percent and means it's further along than a man who plans to give ten someday.

Paul says it directly in 2 Corinthians 8:12: "If the readiness is there, it is acceptable according to what a person has, not according to what he does not have."

That's the verse to put on the refrigerator. God doesn't audit you against a budget you don't have.

Decide before payday

The whole fight is won or lost on the day the money lands.

If you wait until the end of the month to see what's left, you've already decided. So make the call once, in advance. Set up an automatic transfer or write the check the day you're paid. Treat it like the electric bill, except you're glad to pay it.

Paul describes the same habit in 2 Corinthians 9:7: "Each one must give as he has decided in his heart, not reluctantly or under compulsion." The word is decided. It's a choice made in a calm moment, not a reaction in a tight one.

One firm rule: don't give on a credit card. Don't borrow to be generous. Debt makes you the servant of the lender (Proverbs 22:7), and a gift you're still paying interest on in March isn't much of a gift.

What the widow did and didn't do

You know the story in Mark 12. Jesus sits across from the temple treasury, watches rich people put in large sums, then sees a widow drop in two small copper coins. He calls his disciples over and says she's given more than all of them.

People use that passage to guilt the poor. That's a misreading. Jesus isn't telling her to give more. He's pointing at her heart and saying it was seen.

And look at what Paul says about the Macedonian churches in 2 Corinthians 8:2. In a severe test of affliction, their abundance of joy and their extreme poverty overflowed in a wealth of generosity. They begged to give. Hard times didn't turn them into hoarders. They gave because they trusted what they couldn't see on the balance sheet.

One caution, and we'll say it plainly because we believe it. You don't give to get. God isn't a slot machine, and a hundred-dollar offering isn't a down payment on a raise. Preachers who sell that deal are selling a counterfeit. Scripture promises that God supplies what you need and that He sees what you give. It doesn't promise a refund with interest.

When the number really is zero

Some months it is. A layoff, a medical bill, a car that died on the interstate.

In those months, there are still ways to give.

  • Time. Show up early and stay to stack the chairs. Run the sound board. Drive an older member to service. Nursery duty is worth real money to a young family.
  • Skill. If you can fix a gutter, change brakes or file a tax form, there's a widow or a single mom in your church who needs exactly that.
  • Honesty. Tell your pastor or a trusted older man in the church what's going on. Many churches have a fund for just this, and asking isn't weakness. It's what the body is for.

For anything specific to your finances, like what to cut or how to handle debt, sit down with a financial counselor your church trusts, or a professional you pay for the hour. This is general education, not a plan for your household.

Do it together

If you're married, this belongs to both of you. A husband who quietly raises the number, or a wife who quietly lowers it, is building something that cracks later. Sit down, look at the actual take-home pay, and agree on a number out loud. If you disagree, go lower for now and revisit in three months. A smaller number you both own beats a bigger one only one of you does.

And your kids should see it. Let them watch you write the check. Let them put something in the plate, even a dollar from their own pocket. They won't remember a sermon on stewardship. They'll remember Dad doing it when money was tight.

The line that matters

Matthew 6:21 says where your treasure is, there your heart will be also. Most of us read that backwards. We think the heart goes first and the money follows.

It works the other way around. Move a little of the treasure on purpose, and the heart comes along behind it.

So skip the grand plan. Open your banking app tonight, find the day your next check lands, and set up the first thirty-two dollars.

Cal Brennan

Fitness

Strength coach. Trains fathers, tradesmen and desk workers, which means programs that survive a bad week.

Watch

Worth an hour of your evening

More from Christian Bro.

From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.

    Desiring GodNov 20

    The Promise Beneath Every Promise

    Turning Point USADec 4

    Charlie Kirk on Why Morality Is Always Non-Negotiable

    Desiring GodNov 19

    Are My Prayers Selfish?

    Desiring GodNov 19

    Home with the Lord of Glory

    Turning Point USAJun 10

    It's All For God's Glory | Allie Stuckey YWLS

    Ear to HearOct 27

    The Book of Revelation Timeline (how the world ends)