Skip to content
BRO TakeEvergreen guide

The man asking questions in the meeting is running it

The guy with an answer for everything is defending a position. The guy with the right question is deciding where the room goes next.

By Marcus Vale · Editor-in-Chief5 min read
The man asking questions in the meeting is running it

Quick answer: The answer man commits early and spends the meeting defending it. The question man learns what the room knows, finds the hole in the plan, and gets credit for the fix. Ask one real question per meeting, and mean it.

This is commentary, and it comes from watching how rooms actually work.

Picture a Tuesday budget review. Eight people, one slide, a vendor contract up for renewal. One man speaks in the first ninety seconds. He's confident and he's fast, and he lands on renew-as-is. For the next forty minutes, everything anyone says is either support for his answer or an attack on it.

Now picture the man across the table who says almost nothing until minute twelve. Then: "What happens to the install schedule if they slip two weeks?"

Silence. Somebody pulls up a spreadsheet. The meeting just changed hands, and the man who changed it didn't raise his voice.

Why the answer man loses slowly

He doesn't lose today. That's why the habit survives. He's right often enough to keep getting rewarded, and each win teaches him to speak first and speak sure.

But the moment he states his answer, he's committed. Every new fact now threatens him personally. A fact that should be useful becomes an insult, so he argues with it. He stops learning right when the room has the most to teach him.

And there's a quieter cost. An answer shows people what you already know. A question shows them how you think. Senior people have heard a thousand answers. They'll remember the person who made the plan better.

What a question does that an answer can't

It's cheap to be wrong with a question. If you float an answer and it's wrong, you own the error. If you ask and the premise is wrong, you've helped everyone find it.

It also shows you listened. "You said the second quarter slips if we hire late. How late?" That sentence tells the speaker you were paying attention, which is rarer than it should be.

And it moves the room without a fight. You don't have to tell a man his plan has a flaw in front of his boss. You ask where the plan breaks, and he finds it himself. Most men will thank you for that later. The ones who won't were never going to take the correction anyway.

This is the same pull behind the promotion going to the guy people already follow. People follow whoever makes them think more clearly. Nobody follows the man who just talks more.

Four questions worth carrying in your pocket

"What would have to be true for this to work?" It turns a pitch into a list of assumptions. Then the room can check them.

"What does it cost us if we're wrong?" Some decisions are cheap to reverse and some aren't. Most meetings treat them all the same. This sorts them.

"Who has to live with this on Monday?" The people doing the work are almost never in the room. Asking about them makes you sound like an owner, and it's usually where the plan is weakest.

"What are we assuming that nobody's checked?" Every plan has one. Find it before the invoice does.

Write them on a card if you have to. Pick one before you walk in. You don't need a performance. You need one good question asked at the right moment.

Where this goes wrong

Questions can be abused, and some men abuse them.

The gotcha question is a trap with a question mark on it. If you already know the answer and you're asking to embarrass someone, you're not curious. You're showing off, and people can tell. Ask only what you actually want to know.

The speech question runs ninety seconds and ends in "right?" That's an answer wearing a costume.

The ambush is worse. If you've spotted a serious hole in a colleague's work, don't spring it on him in front of the VP. Walk to his desk the day before. Say, "I think the timeline has a problem, can I show you?" He gets to fix it quietly, and you've made an ally instead of a man who dreads you. Putting a man down to look sharp is a poor trade. Serving your team first means the point is the work, not your reputation.

Then there's stalling. Questions can become a place to hide. If you ask for more data three meetings running, people notice you never land anywhere. At some point you owe the room a recommendation. Pair the two: "I'd go with option B. What am I missing?" That's a man with a spine who still wants to be corrected.

One more concession. Some rooms do reward the loud guy, at least for a while. If your boss only respects volume, you'll feel the pressure to match it. Don't. Add weight instead. Ask your question, then give your view in two plain sentences. Loud orders get managed around. Quiet ones get followed. It takes longer, but it lasts.

The three words that cost most men too much

"I don't know."

Say them when they're true. A man who bluffs a number in a meeting has to defend it, and then he's defending a lie by Thursday. That's how small dishonesty gets its start in an office. Nobody sets out to be crooked. They just can't bring themselves to admit a gap.

Finish the sentence right: "I don't know. I'll have it to you by Thursday." Then send it Wednesday night. Better yet, send the answer to the whole group, not just the man who asked. Leave the thread cleaner than you found it.

Do that for a year and something builds. When you finally say "I'm certain," people believe you, because they've heard you say you weren't.

It also matters for the stakes of staying clean in a building full of positioning. Staying out of office politics is how honest men lose, and the honest way to play is to be the man whose questions, and whose word, are both reliable.

Take it home

This isn't only an office skill. Ask your wife one real question at dinner, something with no fix attached, like "What was the hardest part of today?" Then stop talking. Ask your teenage son what he'd do about the problem before you tell him what you'd do.

You'll learn more in ten minutes than you'd get from an hour of advice. And they'll start to feel that you want to know them, not manage them.

The room remembers who made it smarter. Be that man at work, and be him at the table.

Marcus Vale

Editor-in-Chief

Twenty years in magazines, most of it deciding what to cut. Writes about work, discipline and the decisions that compound.

Watch

Worth an hour of your evening

More from Corporate Men.

From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.

    MIT Sloan School of ManagementDec 16

    Neal Hartman: The five keys to negotiating your salary

    Jennifer BrickNov 11

    5 Easy Rules to Play Office Politics and WIN

    Ginny ClarkeJan 20

    Office Politics: The Game You Must Learn to Play

    Leadership with MikeOct 10

    5 Office Politics Rules That Get Managers Promoted