Skip to content
GuideEvergreen guide

Ask any exchange who regulates it, then check yourself

A badge in the footer proves nothing. Ten minutes with a few public databases will tell you whether an exchange answers to anyone.

By Ray Okonkwo · Money & Business5 min read
Ask any exchange who regulates it, then check yourself

Quick answer: Never take an exchange's word for it. Find the legal entity's name in its terms of service, then look that name up in the government registries. If you can't find it, you have your answer.

"Regulated" is a claim until you ask two questions

Regulated by whom? And for what?

Those two questions sort most of the field. Every exchange has a page that says "licensed," "registered," or "compliant." Almost none say which agency, which license, or what that license lets them do. A vague answer isn't a technicality. It's the answer.

Take a footer that reads "Registered with FinCEN." That's true of a lot of exchanges, and it sounds like a seal of approval. It isn't. Registering as a money services business is a filing. It puts the company inside the anti-money-laundering rules. It doesn't mean anyone checked whether your coins are there, whether the books are honest, or whether the owners are people you'd trust with a twenty.

That's the first thing to understand. Registered and supervised are different things. Registered means the company filled out a form. Supervised means somebody with authority can walk in, look at the books, and shut the place down.

Find the real company name first

The brand on the website usually isn't the company that holds your money. Scroll to the bottom of the terms of service and find the sentence that begins "This agreement is between you and..." That's the legal entity. Write down the exact name, including the "LLC," "Ltd," or "Inc."

Now look for the part that trips people up. Some large exchanges run separate entities for separate countries, with different rules and different protections. The U.S. version isn't the same company as the international one with the same logo. If you're an American, make sure the entity you're signing up with is the one holding the license you're about to check.

If the terms don't name an entity at all, stop. A company that won't tell you who it is has told you plenty.

Check the registries yourself

Don't use any link on the exchange's own site for this. Go to the source.

In the United States:

  • FinCEN. The Money Services Business registrant search is public. A real exchange serving Americans should appear. Remember what this proves and what it doesn't.
  • NMLS Consumer Access. Most states license money transmitters, and this is where you look up whether an entity holds those licenses. An exchange operating nationally should show licenses in many states, not zero.
  • New York. New York has its own virtual currency license, the BitLicense, and the state's financial regulator publishes who holds one.
  • SEC and FINRA. If the platform says it's a broker-dealer or trades securities, check FINRA BrokerCheck.
  • NFA. If it offers futures or derivatives, look the firm up in the National Futures Association's BASIC database.

In Canada:

  • Check the registration list that your provincial securities commission and the Canadian Securities Administrators publish. Crypto trading platforms are expected to register with them.
  • Look the company up in FINTRAC's money services business registry as well.

One check takes about two minutes. Doing all of them for one exchange takes about ten. That's cheap insurance for money you'd hate to lose.

What a real answer looks like

A legitimate exchange can tell you, in plain words, who supervises it and for what. Something like: "We hold money transmitter licenses in these states, we're registered with FinCEN, and here's our entity name." You verify each piece. All of it matches.

A fake answer sounds different. Watch for these:

  • A foreign incorporation passed off as regulation. Setting up a company on a small island is paperwork. It isn't supervision.
  • A license number with no named agency. Real regulators have names, and their lists are searchable.
  • A regulator you can't find. If a quick search turns up only the exchange's own pages and a few affiliate blogs, be suspicious.
  • Pressure. A countdown timer, a "bonus" that expires tonight, or a rep who found you on social media. Real regulated firms don't need to rush you.
  • A lookalike address. Clone sites copy a real exchange's design and swap one letter in the web address. Type the address yourself or use a bookmark you made earlier. The crypto scams that catch careful people too are mostly built on this kind of copy.

Regulated doesn't mean safe

Concede the uncomfortable part. FTX collapsed in November 2022, and it had spent years presenting itself as the responsible, cooperative exchange. A license or a friendly relationship with officials is a floor. It isn't a guarantee.

Two more things people assume that aren't true.

Your crypto isn't covered by FDIC insurance. That coverage is for bank deposits. A dollar balance sitting at an exchange isn't automatically a bank account, and your coins certainly aren't one. Don't assume any other insurance fills the gap. Ask, and read the answer in writing.

Your coins may not be yours in a bankruptcy. Read the terms about custody and lending. In the 2022 Celsius bankruptcy, customers in the interest-earning accounts found themselves standing in line with other creditors. That's what happens when a company's terms give it the right to use what you deposited. If an exchange pays you a yield, somebody is doing something with your coins to make that money. Find out what.

A fair opinion on all this

This part is commentary.

We'd rather see Americans look after their own money than wait for Washington to protect them. Regulation has a place, and a fraud shouldn't be able to hang a fake license on the wall. But no agency is going to read the terms of service for you, and no agency has ever stopped every collapse. The better protection is a reader who checks the registry, keeps his own keys, and doesn't leave more on an exchange than he'd risk losing.

That's self-reliance. It also happens to work.

The routine

Before you deposit a dollar:

  1. Find the legal entity's name in the terms of service.
  2. Look it up in FinCEN, NMLS and the other registries that apply to what it offers.
  3. Confirm the web address by typing it yourself.
  4. Read the custody and bankruptcy language, and ask whether it lends out your coins.
  5. Start with an amount you could lose without it changing your year.
  6. Move what you're not actively trading off the exchange. The filing system piece covers how to do that without losing the keys yourself.

If you're new to all of this, start with Bitcoin, explained for somebody who skipped the last decade so you know what you're buying before you decide where.

Ten minutes in a government database is a small price. The exchanges that hold up under it won't mind you doing it.

Ray Okonkwo

Money & Business

Former commercial banker turned small-business owner. Covers salary, credit, margins and the arithmetic nobody does before signing.

Watch

Worth an hour of your evening

More from Crypto.

From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.

    Graham StephanNov 16

    What EVERYONE Needs To Do With Their Money ASAP

    Graham StephanNov 12

    NBA Player On Flying Private...

    Graham StephanNov 11

    How Is This Legal??

    More Crypto OnlineNov 17

    Can Ethereum Still Outperform Bitcoin?