Skip to content
GuideEvergreen guide

Before you punish the lie, find out what it was protecting

A lying kid is handing you information. Read it first, then hand out the consequence, and make sure the truth ends up cheaper than the cover story.

By Cal Brennan · Fitness5 min read
Before you punish the lie, find out what it was protecting

Quick answer: Lying is a symptom, and the cause decides the fix. Work out what kind of lie it was, punish the lie and the original offense separately, and make the truth cheaper than the cover story.

Your nine-year-old told you at dinner that his math was done. At 4:40 the next afternoon, you're holding an email from his teacher about three weeks of missing assignments. The voice you're about to use is already warmed up.

Hold it.

You're not going soft. The consequence will still be there tomorrow. But a punishment handed out before you understand the lie usually fixes the wrong thing, and you'll be back in the same spot in a month with a kid who's gotten better at hiding it.

Wait until you can ask a real question

Anger turns you into a prosecutor. A prosecutor wants a confession, and a kid under cross-examination will say whatever ends the cross-examination, which is often another lie.

Give it an hour. Take a walk, or go finish the thing you were doing in the garage. If you're running on fumes, read this first, because a depleted dad punishes harder and thinks less.

Waiting isn't mercy. It's what makes the conversation work.

Four kinds of lie, four different problems

Most lies from a school-age kid land in one of these.

The fear lie. This is the common one. The truth looked more expensive than the lie, so he picked the lie. Ask yourself honestly what happened the last time he admitted something. If the answer is a thirty-minute lecture and a lost weekend, he did the math correctly.

The shame lie. He's not scared of the punishment so much as of you seeing him as a kid who can't do it. The missing math is often this. He stopped understanding fractions in week one, felt stupid, and hid it. Punishing that one harder just teaches him to hide the next struggle better.

The want lie. He said the homework was done because he wanted his screen time. That's plain self-interest, and it deserves a plain, firm consequence. This is also where your screen rules either hold or don't. A lie that works once becomes a strategy.

The tall tale and the loyalty lie. A four-year-old who swears the dog ate the cookie isn't building a criminal record. He's narrating how he wishes things had gone. Correct it calmly and move on. The loyalty lie is different. An older boy covers for his brother or his buddy. The instinct underneath it is a good one, and you should say so. Then teach him the harder lesson: covering for someone doing wrong isn't loyalty.

How to ask

Don't set traps. If you already know the answer, never ask a question that lets him lie into it. That's entrapment, and he'll remember it.

Say what you know. "Mr. Alvarez emailed me. I'm not asking if it happened. I'm asking what happened." Then stop talking. The silence will feel long. Let it be long.

Two questions do most of the work:

  • What were you afraid would happen if you told me?
  • When did it start getting hard?

The answer to the first tells you what your house is teaching him. The answer to the second tells you if it's fear, shame or plain laziness. Believe what you hear until it proves false. You can verify afterward.

Punish both things, and keep them separate

Two things happened. He didn't do the work, and he lied about it. Each gets its own response.

The original offense gets its natural consequence. The missing math gets done, with you at the table, before anything fun happens.

The lie costs trust, and trust is paid back in increments. For two weeks, you check his planner every night. He doesn't get to decide when he's earned the checking to stop. You do, and you tell him that up front.

Then set the rule that does the most good. If he comes to you first, the consequence is smaller. Say it in advance, out loud, before anything has gone wrong. "If you break something and tell me, we fix it together. If I find out on my own, it costs you double."

Some dads say a kid who confesses should walk entirely. That's the pushover version. He still did the thing, and the thing still costs something. The discount isn't forgiveness. It's pricing. You're making the truth the cheaper option, and kids respond to prices.

And then keep your word. The first time he tests it, the discount has to be real. If he confesses and you blow up anyway, you've just taught him that honesty is a sucker's bet.

Check your own house

Kids learn to lie by watching, and they watch you more closely than you'd like.

"Tell him I'm not home." Telling the kid at the ticket window he's eleven so he gets in cheaper. The "I'm on my way" text sent from the driveway. None of it is a crime. All of it is a lesson, and he's a better student than you were. Your son is learning your work habits, not your work advice, and the same goes for your relationship with the truth.

Look at your temper, too. If every mistake draws an explosion, you haven't raised a liar. You've trained one. That's fixable, and you don't need to wallow in it. Tell him once, plainly, that you've been quicker to yell than to listen, and that you're changing it. Then change it. Guilt does nothing for him. A different Tuesday does.

The long game

You're not really managing a missing math assignment. You're deciding what happens when he's sixteen.

At 11:15 on a Saturday night, a sixteen-year-old is somewhere he shouldn't be, with a driver who shouldn't be driving. He has a phone in his hand and one decision to make: call his father, or figure it out alone.

He'll make that call based on what happened every time he told you something hard before. Whether he's honest with you at sixteen is settled by how you handled him at nine.

Be the dad he calls.

Cal Brennan

Fitness

Strength coach. Trains fathers, tradesmen and desk workers, which means programs that survive a bad week.

Watch

Worth an hour of your evening

More from Dads.

From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.

    Sanford HealthMay 10

    Baby Tips for a New Dad, from a Dad from Sanford Health

    MR. GREG'S HOW TODec 6

    HOW TO Braid Your Daughter’s Hair (for GIRL DADS!) - Super Beginner Tips & Tricks

    How to DADMay 31

    HAIR TUTORIAL FROM A DAD

    Dad Guide MediaJul 12

    HOW TO BRUSH GIRLS HAIR: 5 tips for dads