Skip to content
GuideEvergreen guide

The war movies where the hero had a day job

Seven films about farmers, teachers and deckhands who held the line under fire, with the content concerns named plainly so you know what you're pressing play on.

By Marcus Vale · Editor-in-Chief5 min read
The war movies where the hero had a day job

Quick answer: For a family with teenagers, start with Sergeant York (1941), Dunkirk (PG-13) and Greyhound (PG-13). For grown-ups, Saving Private Ryan, Hacksaw Ridge, 1917 and We Were Soldiers are the best of the hard ones. All four are rated R for battle violence, and every one of them earns it.

Captain John Miller teaches English and coaches baseball back in Pennsylvania. His hand shakes when he's under strain, and he hides it from his men. That's the lead of Saving Private Ryan, and it's why the movie works. Spielberg could have cast a killing machine. He cast a schoolteacher who happens to be the best man on the beach.

That's the test for this list. The films below don't run on invincible heroes. They run on men who had a trade, a family and a good reason to be somewhere else, and who did the job anyway. Fear is in the frame. So is duty.

Start with the farmer

Sergeant York came out in 1941, and Gary Cooper won Best Actor for it. It's the true story of Alvin York, a Tennessee farmer and a famously good shot. He's a hard-drinking brawler as a young man, and then he's drafted into a war his conscience tells him he can't fight.

The movie spends its first half in the hills of Tennessee, and that's the point. You need to know what he's leaving. In October 1918, in France's Argonne Forest, York ended up leading a handful of men against a German machine-gun position. By the time it was over, more than a hundred prisoners had been marched back. He came home with the Medal of Honor.

Content concerns: Black and white, unrated by today's system. Early scenes show drinking and a bar fight. The combat is restrained by modern standards, with men falling but nothing graphic. Good for ages ten and up with a parent nearby.

If your kids think old movies move slowly, this is the one to disprove it. It's also the right door into the classic movies worth showing before thirteen.

What to watch with teenagers

Dunkirk (2017, PG-13). In May and June of 1940, more than 330,000 British and Allied soldiers were pinned against the French coast with the German army closing in. Hundreds of small civilian boats crossed the Channel to pull them off. Christopher Nolan builds the film around that, and the best thread follows a man named Dawson, played by Mark Rylance, who simply takes his own boat and his teenage helper across.

There's almost no blood and very little profanity. What it has is dread. Sound and silence do the work, and some younger kids will find it intense. It runs about 106 minutes, and the dialog is sparse, so don't expect anyone to explain the plot to you.

Greyhound (2020, PG-13). Tom Hanks wrote this one himself, adapting C.S. Forester's novel The Good Shepherd. He plays a Navy commander on his first wartime command, escorting a convoy across the North Atlantic through a stretch where air cover can't reach and German U-boats hunt in packs. It's about 90 minutes, and the whole film is one man making decisions with no sleep and no room for a mistake.

The violence is distant and mostly ships and water. It's a quiet lesson in leadership, and it's the one to put on when you want a teenage son to watch how a man behaves when everyone else is looking at him. Check where it's streaming, since that changes. Our guide to what your streaming bill is actually buying you will help you avoid paying for a month just to watch one movie.

For grown-ups only

These four aren't family night. Watch them first, or watch them with older teens after you've done the homework.

Saving Private Ryan (1998, R). The opening twenty-odd minutes put you on Omaha Beach on D-Day, and it's the most realistic combat footage most people will ever see in a theater. It's graphic. Men are killed and maimed on screen, and the profanity runs through the whole film. If you only have a young man's attention for one war movie, though, this is the one that makes him understand what the generation before his grandfather paid.

Hacksaw Ridge (2016, R). Desmond Doss, a young man from Virginia, enlists in the Army as a medic and refuses to carry a rifle. His fellow soldiers hate him for it. His officers try to push him out. Then comes Okinawa and the Maeda Escarpment, where Doss goes back again and again for the wounded under fire. He later received the Medal of Honor, the first conscientious objector to do so.

The first hour is a love story, a family story and a boot-camp story, and it's clean. The second hour is some of the most graphic battle violence ever filmed, with bodies, wounds and fire. It's rated R for good reason. It's also the best argument I know that courage and gentleness can live in the same man.

1917 (2019, R). Two young British lance corporals get a message to carry across no man's land. If it doesn't arrive in time, 1,600 men walk into an ambush, and one of the two has a brother among them. The film is staged to look like one unbroken shot, which keeps you in the trench with them. Expect profanity, dead bodies and a few bad moments. There's no sexual content, and the story is as simple as it's gripping.

We Were Soldiers (2002, R). In November 1965 at the Ia Drang Valley, Lieutenant Colonel Hal Moore led about 400 American soldiers into the first major battle of the Vietnam War, outnumbered many times over. Mel Gibson plays him. The film divides its time between the field and the wives at Fort Benning, who are the ones receiving the telegrams. It's rated R for sustained, graphic battle violence and language, and it's the best movie I know about what a leader owes the men he brings in.

One rule for watching with a son

Don't fill the quiet. After Dunkirk or Hacksaw Ridge, a teenage boy usually wants to say something and has no idea how. Ask one question: "Which guy did you think you'd be?" Then stop talking.

You'll learn more about him in that answer than in a month of "how was school?"

And preview anything rated R before it goes near your kids. It takes eight minutes, and our piece on vetting a movie before family night walks through exactly how.

Most of the men on this list went home to a farm, a classroom or a front porch and never talked much about it. They'd have been fine with that. Put the movie on anyway.

Marcus Vale

Editor-in-Chief

Twenty years in magazines, most of it deciding what to cut. Writes about work, discipline and the decisions that compound.

Watch

Official trailers

The studios' own trailers and clips for the titles in this piece.

Official studio videos, matched through TMDB. Plays on YouTube.

Warner Bros. Classics

Trailer HD | Sergeant York | Warner Archive

Warner Bros.

Dunkirk - Trailer 1 [HD]

Sony Pictures Entertainment

GREYHOUND - Official Trailer (HD) | Apple TV+