Skip to content
GuideEvergreen guide

Your thin shots start before the club moves

Before you rebuild your swing to stop skulling irons, check your ball position, posture and balance. That's usually where the miss begins.

By Dean Shaw · Gear & Garage5 min read
Your thin shots start before the club moves

Quick answer: A thin shot is a low-point problem, and your setup decides where the low point falls. Check ball position, posture and balance at address before you change a thing in your swing.

You know the shot. The 7-iron leaves the face with the sound of a dropped spoon, skims across the fairway like a flat stone, and finishes somewhere behind the green. Your hands sting. Your playing partner says "nice try" in a tone that costs you a dollar a syllable.

The usual response is to blame the swing. Keep your head down. Stay down through it. Don't lift up. All of that is advice about what you did wrong during the swing, and almost none of it asks what you set up to do.

Read the mark before you guess

Put a strip of masking tape across the face of your 7-iron, or spray a little foot powder on it. Hit five balls. Look at where the marks land.

If they sit near the bottom grooves or along the leading edge, that's thin. If they're scattered toward the toe or heel, you have a different problem, and this piece won't fix it. Don't skip this step. Plenty of golfers swear they're hitting thin when they're actually hitting a mix of heavy and thin, and those two have different causes.

Ball position: the usual culprit

The bottom of your swing arc sits roughly under your breastbone. Put the ball ahead of that spot and the club is already rising when it meets the ball. It catches the equator or the top half. That's a thin shot with a perfectly decent swing behind it.

Here's where the ball should sit, for a right-hander. Lefties, mirror it.

  • Wedges and short irons: center of your stance.
  • Mid irons (6 and 7): about one ball width forward of center.
  • Long irons and hybrids: two ball widths forward of center.
  • Driver: off the inside of your lead heel.

The annoying part is drift. Most weekend players let the ball creep forward on every club because it feels like it'll help the ball get airborne. It does the opposite. An iron gets the ball up by itself, as long as you hit ball first.

Fix it with a routine you do the same way every time. Stand behind the ball and pick your target. Set the clubface behind the ball with your feet together. Then step your lead foot out, then your trail foot, so the ball ends up where it started relative to your stance. Feet together, club behind the ball, widen. It takes four seconds.

Posture: stand up and the club goes with you

Thin shots are often a standing-up problem. The club bottoms out early, so your body rises to find the ball, and the club rises with it.

Most of the time the cause is a bad address posture. If you stand tall with your arms stretched out toward the ball, you've got nowhere to go but up.

Set up like this:

  1. Hinge at the hips. Push your backside back as if reaching for a chair.
  2. Let a slight flex into the knees. Slight. You aren't doing a squat.
  3. Let your arms hang straight down from the shoulders. Then place the club in your hands without reaching.
  4. With a 7-iron, leave roughly a fist's width between the butt of the grip and your thigh.

If you're reaching for the ball, you're too far from it. If your hands are jammed against your thigh, you're too close. Either one gives you a reason to adjust halfway through the swing, and adjusting is how a thin shot gets made.

Balance: where your weight sits

Weight on your heels is a common thin setup. From there your body tends to straighten to stay on its feet, and the club rises with it. A forward lean onto the toes tends to go the other way and leads to the heavy shot. You're after the middle of the foot.

A quick test: at address, wiggle your toes. If you can't lift them at all, you're jammed forward. If lifting your heels feels impossible, you're back on them. You want a stance where either one could move. Think of the posture a shortstop takes before the pitch.

Film just the address

Set your phone on a bag or a cheap tripod behind you and film the setup only. Don't hit the ball. Do it again from face-on.

You'll probably see something you didn't know about. Maybe the ball is closer to your lead foot than you thought, or your back is rounded, or you're leaning on your heels. Pull up a still of a good player setting up with the same club and compare it to yours. It takes five minutes, and it's the cheapest lesson in golf.

Check the clubs, too

A hand-me-down set can be too long for you. A club that's too long pushes you to stand taller than you want to, and standing tall invites a thin shot. Clubs that don't match your build also pull on your lie angle, which affects how the sole meets the turf.

A fitting session can check your length and lie angle in one visit. Even if you buy used, ask a fitter or a pro shop to look at the set. It's cheaper than a new set, and often cheaper than the balls you'll lose.

Do the work off the clock

Run your setup checks at the range, not on the first tee with a group waiting behind you. On the course, go through the routine while the others are hitting so you're ready when it's your turn. We covered pace, silence and pitch marks for exactly this reason.

The same low-point logic applies around the green. If a thin chip is your habit, read the chunk and the skull are the same bad chip. The ball position and weight fixes carry over.

When the setup is clean and you're still thin

Hit twenty balls with the tape on and a setup you've checked. If the marks still sit low, the problem is in the swing. Now it's worth a lesson, and a good teacher will check your address first anyway. You'll have saved yourself a long afternoon of trying to fix the wrong thing.

If you're working toward a lower number, the five changes that get you under 100 is where to go next.

Next time you skull one across the fairway, don't look up to see where it went. Look down at your feet. The answer is usually there.

Dean Shaw

Gear & Garage

Reads the warranty, the parts list and the long-term owner reviews before anything else. Trucks, tools, watches, and the cheap version that costs more.

Watch

Worth an hour of your evening

More from Golf.

From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.

    TitleistOct 20

    Wedge Drills to Improve Your Short Game | Titleist Tips

    Jerome RufinJan 19

    This World #1 Golf Coach Finally Fixes My Chipping with 2 Simple Shots

    GolfweekMar 9

    Lee Trevino Short game alignment

    The Golfer's JournalMar 31

    Short Game Chef teaches the stock pitch every golfer should have | The Index Experiment