Skip to content
BRO TakeEvergreen guide

Your Kids Hate Your Jokes Right Up Until They Steal Them

The eye-roll isn't a review. It's a toll, and the proof arrives the first time you overhear your own punchline coming out of somebody else's kid.

By Marcus Vale · Editor-in-Chief5 min read
humor section

Quick answer: They aren't embarrassed by the joke. They're embarrassed that you're the one who gets to enjoy it. Keep telling it, keep your face boring, and wait about two weeks.

Tuesday, 6:40 p.m. You deliver the scarecrow one. Why did he win the award? Outstanding in his field. Your fourteen-year-old shuts her eyes like she's been handed a parking ticket. "Dad. Stop."

Two Fridays later you're standing at the edge of the soccer field with a coffee, and you hear it. Her voice, three friends in a half circle, a little pause before "field" that you have never once managed to pull off. They laugh. A boy you've never met says, "Okay, that's actually good."

She doesn't see you. She also doesn't say where she got it.

You've been robbed, and you should be thrilled.

The eye-roll is a toll, not a review

A kid can't laugh at your joke at your table. Laughing is a concession, and concessions to a parent cost something at that age. So the groan comes first. It's the toll you pay at the gate to get the joke into the country.

Watch closely and you'll notice the groan arrives faster than the joke could possibly have been processed. She didn't evaluate it. She ruled on the source.

Out in the world, the joke has no source. It's just a good line she happens to have. Nobody at that lunch table knows it came from the man who also says "I'm not lost, I'm exploring" at every wrong turn. Without you attached, the joke gets judged on merit, and short clean jokes with a good turn have plenty of merit.

What survives the trip

Not everything you say makes it to the cafeteria. The jokes that get stolen have the same features every time.

  • They're short. Nobody under twenty will sit through a story with a setup about your cousin's boat.
  • They turn on one word. "I used to hate facial hair, but then it grew on me." The whole engine is the last two words.
  • They can be said in front of a teacher and a grandmother, which is why they get repeated in front of both.
  • They don't need your voice. If the joke only works with your specific rasp and your specific eyebrow, it stays home.

That last one is useful to know. When a joke you love never gets stolen, it was never a joke. It was a performance. Nothing wrong with those, but they don't travel. If you want a stocked shelf of the kind that do, the grandpa jokes that refuse to die are a good place to restock, and the fifty best dad jokes, ranked by groan will tell you which ones have the highest groan-to-laugh conversion.

They return it sharper than they borrowed it

Here's the part that stings a little. The version at the soccer field was better than yours.

She cut your windup. Your version has "So get this, I was reading about scarecrows." Hers starts at "Why'd the scarecrow win an award?" and gets there in nine words. She also found the pause you've been rushing past for years. Everything you said aloud over the mashed potatoes was an unedited draft, and she's been quietly doing the revision.

This is the old rule about a borrowed tool: bring it back cleaner and sharper than you found it. Your kids follow it without being told, as long as the tool is a punchline. If you want to understand what she improved, read the pause is doing more work than your punchline. She learned that lesson by watching you ignore it.

The rules for the victim

You've got a role in this, and it takes more discipline than it looks.

Don't ask for credit. The moment you say "That's my joke," the supply ends. You've turned a gift into a lawsuit.

Keep your face boring. If you overhear it, you heard nothing. Sip the coffee. Admire the clouds. A grin gives away that you were listening, and she'll move her act indoors.

Keep the test lab at home. Here's the line between a joke that gets stolen and a joke that gets you banned from the driveway at pickup. Try it on the family first, in private, where the stakes are one groan. Don't debut material in front of her friends. When you hand them a joke before she has, it's her embarrassment. When she hands them one herself, it's her comedy.

Don't stop. This is the one that takes a spine. "Dad, stop" is not a rule. It's an opening bid. A father who quits at the first complaint has been trained by a child, and you'll spend ten years going quiet in a house you pay for. Serve the family a joke every night. Just don't make it at anybody's expense, and certainly not hers. The groan should always be about the pun, never about her.

Keep it clean. Her friend's mom may be standing right there. Anything you wouldn't say to your own mother-in-law stays in the garage.

Let a dead joke die. When one lands flat, don't explain it. Explaining a dud is how a dud becomes a memory. Say "Tough room," pass the rolls, and try a different one Thursday.

The long game

Count the evidence over a few months. A friend's dad says, "I hear you're the one with the scarecrow joke." A teacher repeats it. Your son tells it to his grandfather, who already knew it, because you got it from him. You'll start to see the whole line, three generations of the same bad joke improving a little with every hand it passes through.

That's how a family develops a house style. Nobody votes on it, nobody writes it down. A joke gets groaned at, then stolen, then sharpened, then passed down again with no credit to anyone. It's the closest thing most families have to a recipe.

Some night, probably when she's seventeen and has a friend over for dinner, she'll look at you across the table and say, "Dad, do the scarecrow one."

Don't make a speech. Just do it, and hit the pause where she taught you.

Marcus Vale

Editor-in-Chief

Twenty years in magazines, most of it deciding what to cut. Writes about work, discipline and the decisions that compound.

Watch

Worth an hour of your evening

More from Humor.

From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.

    Greg Dean's Stand-Up Comedy ClassesJan 23

    🎤3 Types of Joke Setups - How to Write Jokes - Greg Dean Stand Up Comedy Classes #comedians #joke

    Jerry Corley aka The Joke DoctorSep 20

    How to Tell a Joke [ SECRET ]

    Craig ValentineFeb 8

    Use Humor in Speaking without Telling Jokes | 1 Powerful Public Speaking Technique

    Darren LaCroixDec 1

    How to deliver a funny speech: Funny Speech