Consolidation lowers your payment. Does it lower your cost?
The pitch sells you a smaller monthly number. The only number that matters is the total you'll have paid when the debt is gone.

Quick answer: Consolidation saves money when the new rate is clearly lower, the fees are small, and you keep paying roughly what you paid before. It costs you money when the lender stretches the term to make the payment look small. Judge the offer by the total you'll pay, never the monthly figure.
This is general education, not personal advice. Your numbers are your own, so run them past a nonprofit credit counselor or a fee-only financial planner before you sign anything.
What the pitch leaves out
The pitch has three parts. Roll your cards and other debts into one loan. Get one payment instead of five. Pay less each month.
The first two are true. The third is true almost every time, and it's also the trap. A lower payment can come from a lower rate. It can also come from a longer term. The ad doesn't say which, because the second one is far more profitable for the lender.
So do the arithmetic yourself. It takes ten minutes and a calculator.
Total cost = monthly payment × number of months + any fees.
Subtract what you borrowed. What's left is the price of the debt. Do it for what you're paying now and for the offer, then compare the two prices.
A case where it wins
These numbers are illustrations, not quotes. Say you owe $15,000 across several cards at an average of 24% APR, and you're paying $450 a month. At that pace it takes about 56 months to clear, and you'll hand over roughly $10,000 in interest. That's two-thirds of the original balance, paid for the privilege of waiting.
A lender offers $15,000 at 12% fixed.
Take it over 60 months and the payment drops to about $334. Total interest is about $5,000. You've cut the cost in half and freed $116 a month. That's a good deal.
Now take the same loan and keep paying $450. It's gone in about 41 months. Interest is roughly $3,300. You're debt-free more than a year earlier and about $6,600 better off than if you'd done nothing.
That's the winning pattern. Take the lower rate, then keep the old payment. The loan's required payment becomes a floor, and the extra goes straight to principal.
Check for an origination fee, though. Some lenders take a percentage off the top. At 5% on $15,000, that's $750 gone before you've paid a dime. It doesn't ruin the deal above, but it does shrink it. A loan that looks great at 12% can look average once you add the fee.
A case where it loses
Different situation. You owe $9,000 on a card at 16% and you're paying $300 a month. That clears in about 39 months. Interest runs roughly $2,570.
The pitch arrives: one payment of about $169. That's $131 a month back in your pocket.
The loan is 14% over 84 months. Seven years. Total paid is about $14,170, so interest is about $5,170, double what you were on track to pay. And that's before any fee.
The rate was lower, and you still lose. The term did the damage. You'd feel richer every month for seven years while paying thousands more than you needed to.
The fix is the same as before. If you take a loan like that and keep paying $300, it's done in about 38 months, and now the lower rate is working for you. But if you were going to pay $300 anyway, ask whether you needed the loan at all. Sometimes the answer is to call the card company, ask for a lower rate, and keep attacking the balance. It costs nothing to ask.
Check the offer before you fall for it
Run every offer through these questions. If any answer is bad, walk.
- What's the APR, not just the rate? APR includes fees. It's the number built for comparing.
- Is it fixed? A variable rate on a long loan is a bet against yourself.
- What's the term? Multiply payment by months. Write the total down.
- What's the fee? Ask for it in dollars.
- Is there a prepayment penalty? You want to be able to pay it off early without being charged for it.
- What happens to the old cards? This one matters most, and it's next.
The part no calculator catches
Consolidation pays off your cards. It does nothing about why they were full.
You now have five cards at zero and a loan in their place. That's a clean slate, and a clean slate is the most dangerous moment in the whole process. If the spending that built the balance hasn't changed, the cards fill back up. Now you owe the loan and the cards. You've doubled the problem and paid fees for the privilege.
Be honest with yourself. If you ran the balances up on groceries and gas because the paycheck didn't stretch, the loan won't fix that. A budget will, along with an emergency cushion so the next car repair doesn't go on plastic. Our piece on why your emergency fund is insurance, not savings covers how big that cushion should be.
If the debt came from a one-time hit, like a medical bill or a layoff, and your spending has been steady since, consolidation is a much safer bet.
Other versions of the pitch
Balance transfer cards. A 0% introductory rate can beat any loan, but there's usually a transfer fee of a few percent, and the 0% ends. Divide your balance by the number of promo months. If you can't clear it before the rate resets, you've bought time, not savings.
Home equity loans. The rate is often lower because the lender can take your house if you stop paying. You've turned unsecured debt into debt secured by the roof over your family. For most people, that's a bad trade. Cards can hurt your credit. A home loan can cost you the house.
Companies that "settle" or "relieve" debt. Be wary of any outfit that wants money before it has done anything, or tells you to stop paying your creditors and wait. Missed payments can bring late fees, penalty rates and collection calls. A nonprofit credit counselor can often set up a repayment plan with your creditors for a modest fee, which is a better place to start.
Which debt first
If you have several debts, a consolidation loan is only one tool. Sometimes the right move is to pay them off in the order the arithmetic dictates, highest rate first. We walk through that in paying off debt in the order the arithmetic says. And if you're tempted to treat any monthly payment as the price of something, the car payment isn't the price makes the same point from the other side of the lot.
The test
Before you sign, write two numbers on a piece of paper. First, what you'll pay in total if you change nothing. Second, what you'll pay in total on the offer, including every fee. If the second number isn't clearly smaller, you're being sold a smaller payment, not a better deal.
And if it is smaller, make one promise before the check clears. Keep paying what you were paying. The old payment was never the problem. The balance was.
Ray Okonkwo
Money & Business
Former commercial banker turned small-business owner. Covers salary, credit, margins and the arithmetic nobody does before signing.
Watch
Worth an hour of your evening
More from Money.
From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.
Read next
