The real price tag on retiring one year early
It's not one paycheck. It's the paycheck, the match, the benefit calculation, the insurance and a year of withdrawals, all at once.

Quick answer: Retiring a year early costs far more than a year of salary. You lose the paycheck, the contributions and employer match, a year of growth on a bigger balance, and possibly your employer's health plan. You also add a year of withdrawals. The total usually runs several times what you'd guess, and you can work it out in an afternoon.
The number everybody checks, and the one they skip
Most people compare a year of pay to a year of freedom. That's the wrong ledger.
The right question: where will my portfolio stand on my 64th birthday if I quit now, versus if I stay? The gap between those two numbers is the real cost. It has four parts.
A worked example (illustrative only)
These figures are made up to show the arithmetic. They aren't a forecast, and they aren't yours. Swap in your own.
Say you're 63 with a $1,500,000 portfolio. You earn $90,000 and put $12,000 into your 401(k), and your employer adds $4,500. You'd spend $60,000 a year in retirement, drawn entirely from savings because you haven't claimed Social Security yet. That's a 4 percent withdrawal.
Retire now. You withdraw $60,000 over the year. Ignoring market growth to keep it clean, you're at $1,440,000 at 64.
Work one more year. You withdraw nothing and add $16,500. You're at $1,516,500 at 64.
The difference is $76,500. That's the cost of the year, and it's already close to the whole $90,000 salary before taxes are considered, because you've swapped a contribution for a withdrawal.
Now add the parts that don't show up on a pay stub.
The health insurance gap
Medicare generally starts at 65. Retire at 63 and you need coverage for two years. Retire at 64 and you need it for one. That extra bridge year is the most expensive year of the whole stretch.
Say your employer plan costs you $250 a month, and your bridge option (COBRA or a marketplace plan) runs $1,100 a month. In this example, the extra cost is $850 a month, or $10,200 for the year. Add that to the gap and the early year costs about $86,700 so far.
Your real numbers will differ, sometimes by a lot. Get an actual quote before you decide. COBRA generally runs up to 18 months, and losing employer coverage typically opens a special enrollment window on the marketplace. Check Healthcare.gov for the current rules and Medicare.gov for your enrollment dates. Miss your Medicare window without qualifying coverage and a late penalty can follow you for life.
What it does to Social Security
Your benefit is built from your highest 35 years of earnings, adjusted for wage growth. If you have fewer than 35 years, zeros fill the gaps.
So one more year of work helps if it replaces a low or zero year in your record. It helps little if you already have 35 strong years. You can't guess this one. Log in to your account at SSA.gov and read your earnings record. Check that every year is there and correct, then see what the estimator says with and without the extra year.
If you're thinking about claiming at 62 to fill the bridge, read the reduction first. Claiming before full retirement age permanently shrinks the check, and delaying past it grows it. The ages and percentages are on SSA.gov. Rules change, so read the current page, not a remembered number.
The pension and the match
Two quiet items hide in your HR portal.
- A pension formula. Many are based on years of service and final pay, and some reduce the benefit sharply for leaving before a set age. One more year can raise the check for life, or it can do nothing. Ask for a written estimate at both dates.
- Your last year of match. That $4,500 is a raise you either claim or leave on the table. I covered how to treat it in Your 401(k) match is a raise you have to go claim.
What the early year can still win
A fair accounting runs both ways.
If your health is poor, or your spouse has already stopped working, or the job is wearing you down in ways money won't fix, the year may be worth every dollar. The arithmetic tells you the price. It doesn't tell you the value. Some men pay $86,700 for the last year they'll have the energy to build a deck with their grandkids, and that can be a sound trade.
There's also a tax angle. A low-income bridge year can open planning room that a full-salary year closes. Which accounts you draw from in that window matters a good deal, and Which Retirement Account To Spend From First walks through the logic. Bring the specifics to a CPA. Limits and brackets change, so IRS.gov is the place to confirm anything current.
Also check one more drain on the budget. If you still owe on the house, the monthly payment is a fixed claim on your savings every year of the bridge. When To Pay Off The Mortgage Before You Retire lays out when clearing it first makes sense.
Do the math this week
Pull these numbers together before you give notice:
- Your portfolio balance and your planned annual spending.
- A written benefit estimate from SSA.gov.
- A pension estimate at both retirement dates, if you have one.
- A real quote for health coverage until Medicare.
- The dollar value of your employer match for one more year.
Run the two columns side by side, one for leaving now and one for leaving in twelve months. If the gap is small and the year is worth more to you than the money, go. If the gap is large, decide that with your eyes open.
And don't leave the day itself empty. A year bought with savings is wasted if Tuesday morning has no shape. What to do with Tuesday morning when you retire is worth reading before you sign off on the plan.
This is general education, not individual financial, tax or legal advice. Before you act, run your numbers past a fee-only fiduciary adviser and a CPA, and confirm every age, limit and threshold at SSA.gov, Medicare.gov and IRS.gov.
A man who has counted the cost of the extra year can retire without wondering. That's worth more than the paycheck.
Ray Okonkwo
Money & Business
Former commercial banker turned small-business owner. Covers salary, credit, margins and the arithmetic nobody does before signing.
Watch
Worth an hour of your evening
More from Retirement.
From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.
Read next
