Ask for the thing that costs your boss the least
A raise is the hardest yes a boss can give. Start with what's easier, and walk in with a specific number and three months of proof.

Quick answer: Wait until you've got about three months of solid work behind you. Pick one ask (money, hours, or different work), write down what you've earned it with, and book fifteen minutes in private. Say the number, then stop talking.
Why the raise is the hardest yes
Say you're nineteen, working at a tire shop for $14 an hour. You want $16. Your boss may not have the power to say yes. The pay scale might come from the owner. Giving you a raise might mean giving one to the guy who's been there four years. It comes out of a pot that was set months ago.
Compare that to "Can I learn to do alignments?" or "Can I swap my Thursday for a Saturday?" Your boss can usually answer those on his own, on a Tuesday, without asking anyone.
That's no rule. Some bosses own the place and can hand you a dollar an hour on the spot. But when you're choosing what to ask for, ask yourself what it costs him, not just what it gets you. Often the cheap yes now is the road to the expensive one later. A guy who can run the alignment rack is worth more per hour, and he's got a reason to say so.
Pick one ask
There are three kinds: money, hours, work. Choose one for this meeting.
Walking in with all three sounds like a list of complaints. One clear request sounds like a man who's thought it through. If you want more money and different work, ask for the work first. Then ask about pay once you're doing it.
If you're not sure which work is worth asking for, the trades that can't find people shows where skills turn into real pay.
Build the file
Before you say a word to anyone, spend an evening with a notebook. You're writing one page. It should have:
- Things you do that weren't in the job description
- Shifts you covered when somebody called out
- Problems you fixed, and mistakes you caught before a customer did
- Anything a customer or coworker said about your work
- What other local places post for the same job
Only real entries count. If the page is nearly empty, you've learned something useful: you're not ready yet. Go earn the page, then come back. And if you started six weeks ago, wait. Nobody's impressed by a request from a man who hasn't been around long enough to be missed.
The last bullet matters most for the number. "I'd like $16" is a wish. "Shops around here are posting $15 to $17 for this work" is a reason. Look at actual listings, and don't guess.
Set the meeting properly
Don't ambush him at the register in the middle of a rush. Don't catch him on a Friday at closing, either. Ask for the meeting like this:
"Do you have fifteen minutes this week? I'd like to talk about my role."
That's it. You're not hinting at anything dramatic. Early in the week is better. Right after you've done something well is better still. Make sure it happens somewhere private, even if that's just the back office with the door closed.
Say it out loud
Practice this in the truck until it stops sounding strange. Then say it plainly:
"I've been here five months. I'm running the tire machine without supervision, I've been opening three days a week, and I covered four shifts when we were short. I'd like to move to $16 an hour. What would it take to get there?"
Then stop talking.
This is the hardest part. The silence will feel like a minute, and it'll be about six seconds. Don't fill it. Don't apologize. Don't say "if that's okay" or "I totally understand if not." The next voice should be his.
Three things to leave out:
- Your bills. The truck payment is a real problem, but it's yours. Your value is the argument, not your expenses.
- Other people's pay. "Dylan makes more than me" starts a fight you can't win.
- A threat to quit. Say that only if you mean it and you've got another job lined up. A bluff gets called, and then you're stuck.
Hours and different work
When you're asking for a schedule change, solve his problem in the same breath. "I'd like Wednesday afternoons off for a class. I can take Saturdays, which I know are hard to cover." Now he isn't losing coverage, he's trading it.
When you're asking for different work, offer a trial. "Let me shadow Ray on alignments for a month, on top of my regular work, and we'll see how I do." That makes the yes small and reversible, which is what makes it easy to give.
When the answer is no
Sometimes it's no. You can still walk out of the room ahead if you ask three things:
- Is it the number, the timing, or something about my work?
- What would a yes look like?
- When can we talk again?
Write down the date he gives you. That afternoon, send a short thank-you message that repeats what he said. "Thanks for the time today. Sounds like we'll revisit in March, and I'll keep working on the alignment training." Now there's a record, and you've left the conversation cleaner than you found it.
Then do the work. Don't coast, and don't sulk. If March comes and the answer is a vague no with no reason attached, that's information too. Start looking quietly, on your own time, and keep giving the job a full day's work until you've got somewhere better to be. You leave a place the same way you'd return a borrowed truck: washed and full of gas, even if it came to you empty.
For more on what bosses are actually watching in those months, read the habits at your first job that get you the second one. And if the raise does come, the first twelve months of earning, month by month will help you figure out where it goes.
Don't be a pushover, don't be a pest
Serve your team first. Cover the shift, stay late to finish the job, help the new guy. That's what earns you the standing to ask.
But serving doesn't mean silence. A man who never asks for anything teaches everyone around him that he doesn't need anything. Ask once, well, and with proof. That beats hinting for a year.
The worst version of this meeting is a polite no and a date on the calendar. It still beats the one you spent two years not having.
Sam Ortiz
Dads & Family
Father of three. Writes about presence, discipline and the long game, without pretending any of it's tidy.
Watch
Worth an hour of your evening
More from Young Men.
From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.
Read next
