Skip to content
StoryEvergreen guide

Gideon Was Afraid the Whole Way, and God Kept Sending Him

God called a man hiding in a winepress a mighty warrior, then put up with every question he asked. What that means when you're handed a job bigger than you.

By Josh Halloran · Christian Bro6 min read
Gideon Was Afraid the Whole Way, and God Kept Sending Him

Quick answer: God didn't wait for Gideon to feel ready. He sent him while he was afraid and answered him each time he asked. When you're handed something you can't do, obey the next clear thing, even if you have to do it at night.

The man in the winepress

Israel had been under Midian's thumb for seven years. Raiders stripped the crops every harvest, and the people lived in mountain dens and caves. That's the setting for one of the strangest introductions in Scripture.

Gideon is threshing wheat in a winepress, which is a bad place to thresh wheat. He's doing it there on purpose, to keep the grain out of sight. Then the angel of the LORD sits down under a tree nearby and says, "The LORD is with you, O mighty man of valor" (Judges 6:12, ESV).

Picture how that lands on a man crouched in a pit with a sack of grain. Gideon doesn't say thank you. He argues. If the LORD is with us, where are the wonders our fathers told us about, and why are we in this mess?

God doesn't correct him. He gives him the assignment: "Go in this might of yours and save Israel from the hand of Midian; do not I send you?" (6:14, ESV).

Gideon's second objection is the one every unqualified person has ready: "my clan is the weakest in Manasseh, and I am the least in my father's house" (6:15, ESV). Notice what God doesn't do. He doesn't flatter him or tell him he's stronger than he thinks. He says, "But I will be with you" (6:16, ESV).

That's the whole answer. The qualification isn't Gideon. It's the One who sends him.

He obeyed at night

The first job is a hard one. Gideon's own father has an altar to Baal at home. God tells Gideon to tear it down and build a proper altar to the LORD in its place.

Gideon does it. Then Scripture adds a detail I'm glad it didn't leave out: "because he was too afraid of his family and the men of the town to do it by day, he did it by night" (6:27, ESV).

Nobody would put that on a recruiting poster. But he did it. Ten servants, a bull, the whole job, in the dark and scared. By morning the town wanted him dead, and his father, of all people, stood between Gideon and the mob.

Feeling brave was never the requirement. Doing what God said was. A husband who finally has the hard talk with his son, a woman who tells her board the numbers don't add up, a young man who quits the crew that's pulling him down: most of them do it with a dry mouth. That counts. Gideon's night shift is in the Bible, and it's not there as an embarrassment.

The fleece, and where good Christians differ

Then comes the part everybody knows. The Midianite armies gather, and Gideon asks for a sign. He lays out a wool fleece on the threshing floor. If dew is on the fleece only and the ground is dry, he'll know God will save Israel by his hand. In the morning the fleece is so wet he wrings out a bowlful of water. Then he asks again, the other way around, and apologizes for asking: "Let not your anger burn against me; let me speak just once more" (6:39, ESV).

God does it both times.

Believers read this two ways, and both are held in good faith. Some see a man of weak faith whom God graciously indulged. Others see a legitimate request for confirmation, answered without rebuke.

Either way, one point holds. Gideon wasn't asking God what to do. God had already told him plainly. He was asking God to confirm what he'd already said. That's a long way from putting out a fleece to decide which job to take or whom to marry, where Scripture hasn't spoken to the specific choice. For those, the church's long-standing pattern is Scripture, prayer, wise counsel, and an honest look at your circumstances. Don't treat the fleece as a method. Treat it as a picture of a patient God and a nervous man.

God makes the army smaller

You'd expect that after the fleece, God would send reinforcements. He does the opposite.

Gideon's force is 32,000. God says that's too many: "lest Israel boast over me, saying, 'My own hand has saved me'" (7:2, ESV). Those who are afraid are told to go home, and 22,000 leave. Another 9,700 get cut at the water, leaving 300 men.

Three hundred against a host that scripture says covered the valley. That isn't a leadership strategy. It's God taking the numbers off the table so nobody can mistake who won.

Then, the night before, comes the kindest moment in the story. God knows Gideon is still afraid. So he says, if you're afraid to go down, take your servant Purah and go listen at the enemy camp. What Gideon hears there, a Midianite soldier telling a friend about a dream of a barley loaf flattening a tent, is enough. Gideon worships and goes back and wakes the camp.

God didn't scold his fear. He handed him a way through it, and a companion.

For the other side of this, read Ruth, Esther and Deborah Did Not Wait to Feel Brave. The pattern repeats. And if the battle details in Judges trouble you, Reading the Old Testament Wars Without Flinching will help.

Weakness was the plan

Hebrews 11:32 puts Gideon in the great list of the faithful. Among the things the writer says of such people: they "were made strong out of weakness" (Hebrews 11:34, ESV). Paul heard the same thing from the Lord himself: "My grace is sufficient for you, for my power is made perfect in weakness" (2 Corinthians 12:9, ESV).

That's not a consolation prize. It's how God works. He picks the least in the weakest clan so that nobody walks away from the story admiring the wrong man.

What Gideon did with the win

Be honest about the ending. After the victory, the people want Gideon to rule them, and he gives the right answer: "the LORD will rule over you" (8:23, ESV). Good. Then he asks them for gold earrings and makes an ephod, a priestly garment, and sets it up in his hometown. Judges 8:27 says it became "a snare to Gideon and to his family" (ESV).

The man who was too scared to tear down an idol by day left one behind. Fear is one test of a leader. Success is the other, and it's usually the harder one.

If you're the one in the seat

You're a new father. Or a new manager, a new deacon, a woman who just inherited the family business. You feel like the least in your father's house. A few things from Gideon:

  • Do the clearest next thing. Not the whole plan. The thing in front of you.
  • Ask for confirmation of what you've been told, not an exit. Gideon asked twice, and God answered. Just don't mistake a delay tactic for prayer.
  • Take a Purah. Don't lead alone. Find the one person who'll walk into the dark with you.
  • Do it at night if you have to. A scared obedience beats a brave refusal.
  • Give the win away. Don't build an ephod.

If you'd like to have some of this in your pocket before the hard day arrives, start with Thirty Verses Worth Memorizing Before the Hard Day Arrives.

God called Gideon a mighty man while he was still in the winepress. He's not waiting for you to feel it either.

Josh Halloran

Christian Bro

Leads a mid-week mens group and has done for eleven years. Writes about faith as a practice rather than a position.

Watch

Worth an hour of your evening

More from Bible.

From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.

    BibleProjectAug 10

    You Can Understand the Old Testament (2 Simple Ideas Help!)

    Matthew EverhardJul 24

    My Ultimate Bible Study System : Updated 2026!

    Carmen Joy ImesApr 24

    Top Two Books on Old Testament Violence

    Phil RobertsonJun 29

    The Best Way to Start Reading the Bible | Phil Robertson