Skip to content
GuideEvergreen guide

Small-town novels where everybody knows who showed up

Four novels and one short play about places where your word is your credit score. Each comes with a note on who it suits and what to watch for.

By Marcus Vale · Editor-in-Chief6 min read
Small-town novels where everybody knows who showed up

Quick answer: Start with Kent Haruf's Plainsong if you want quiet and strong. Pick Richard Russo's Nobody's Fool if you want to laugh. Read Wendell Berry's Jayber Crow slowly, and give To Kill a Mockingbird another go if you last touched it in tenth grade. Mature content is flagged on each.

What the town knows

A small-town novel isn't about scenery. It's about a ledger.

Everybody in the town keeps one. Who pays what they owe. Who shows up when the barn burns. Whose word holds, and whose doesn't, and has been known not to since the spring of '88. In a city, you can start over by changing neighborhoods. In these books you can't, and the novelists know exactly what that costs and what it's worth.

That's the angle worth reading them for. The weak ones in this genre are postcards, all porch lights and pie. The good ones are accounting. They show a place where people are held to something, and they're honest that being held is both a gift and a weight.

Plainsong, by Kent Haruf

Holt, Colorado. Two old bachelor cattlemen, the McPheron brothers, who've said maybe a thousand words to each other in forty years. A seventeen-year-old girl, pregnant, thrown out of her mother's house. A schoolteacher named Maggie Jones who knows exactly which door to knock on.

The brothers take her in. That's the plot, more or less, and Haruf lets it be enough. His sentences are short and flat, with no quotation marks around the dialogue, and he never tells you how to feel about a man pulling a calf or a woman peeling potatoes. You feel it anyway.

Suits: Anyone who's ever done a hard thing without being thanked. Excellent for a man who says he doesn't read novels, because the chapters are short and the prose never shows off.

Flag: Some coarse language and a few frank moments, including a cruel scene involving a teenage boy. A teen pregnancy drives the story, and it's handled with respect for everyone in it. It's an adult book. Not for a young teenager.

If Haruf's plain prose hits the spot, the westerns worth reading when it gets dark at five are the next shelf over.

Nobody's Fool, by Richard Russo

North Bath, in upstate New York, in winter. Sully is sixty, with a bad knee, a worse landlord's lawsuit, a part-time construction crew, and a son he failed. He's also the most reliable unreliable man in town. Everybody knows he's a mess. Everybody also knows he'll be there at three in the morning if you need a hand.

That's the real discovery of the book. The town has Sully filed correctly. It doesn't care about his résumé. It cares about what he does when it counts, and Russo is very funny about the gap between those two things. There's a landlady, Miss Beryl, who taught half the town in school and still corrects their grammar. There's a lifelong rivalry over a stolen snowblower. You'll read passages aloud to whoever's in the room.

Suits: Fathers and sons, especially the ones who aren't speaking. Anyone who wants a book with real warmth and real laughs and no preaching in it.

Flag: More profanity than the others on this list, plus some adult references and a lot of drinking. Moderate, not graphic, but know what you're picking up.

Jayber Crow, by Wendell Berry

Port William, Kentucky. Jayber is an orphan who goes off to be educated, comes back, and becomes the town barber for the rest of his life. He watches everyone. He cuts their hair, hears everything, and says very little. He also loves a woman who married someone else, and he spends decades keeping that love honest and out of the way.

This is the slowest book here. It's also the one most likely to rearrange something in you. Berry writes about a town as a body of people bound by obligation, with the dead and the unborn counted in. A man belongs to a place and the place belongs to him, and that isn't sentiment. It's duty.

Suits: Readers who like to underline. Men who feel they've made a life that looks small from the outside and want a book that takes it seriously. Not a first novel for someone out of the habit.

Flag: It deals with love for a married woman and with the town's failings, but it's restrained and never graphic. The book has religious threads running through it, since the characters live them, but it's a novel, not a sermon.

To Kill a Mockingbird, by Harper Lee

You read it at fifteen for a grade. Read it again at forty, with a family of your own, and you'll find a different book. It's less about a trial and more about a father. Atticus Finch isn't brave in the way the movies make him. He's brave in the way a man is brave who knows he'll lose and takes the case anyway because his children are watching.

Maycomb, Alabama, is as much a character as anyone. The town knows precisely what it thinks of the Finches, the Ewells, the Radleys, and every other family on the block. Some of what it knows is wisdom. Some of it is poison. Lee shows both without telegraphing which is which, and that's why the book has lasted.

Suits: Fathers especially. A strong pick for reading alongside a teenager.

Flag: The story turns on a false accusation of rape, and the book contains racial slurs, as the period and place require. It's serious, not gratuitous. Know that before you hand it to a younger reader, and read it first.

The short one: Our Town

Thornton Wilder's play is a play, not a novel, but it's about an hour of reading and it belongs here. Grover's Corners, New Hampshire. Ordinary days, ordinary people, one long look at what we miss while we're living it. Clean, short, and a fine thing to read aloud on a Sunday afternoon.

What to skip

Not every small-town book is a fit for this shelf. Larry McMurtry's The Last Picture Show is a respected novel about a dying Texas town, and it's also frank about sex in a way that doesn't belong beside your wife or your kids. Peyton Place has the same problem and less art. Skipping them costs you nothing.

Making it stick

These books want a slow pace, and that's the point. Don't try to finish Jayber Crow in a weekend.

  • Read one chapter a night, in a chair, with the phone in another room.
  • Start with Plainsong or Nobody's Fool. They pull you along.
  • Check your library before you buy anything. The library card guide covers how to get more out of it, and all five of these are the kind of books a decent branch has on the shelf.
  • Keep one on the nightstand and one in the truck.
  • If you're building a longer list, Twenty Books Every Man Should Read Before Forty is the place to go next.

Pick one this week. Then the next time somebody in your own town brings a casserole, shovels a driveway, or quietly pays for something nobody asked them to, you'll know what you're looking at. And you'll know it's worth being that person.

Marcus Vale

Editor-in-Chief

Twenty years in magazines, most of it deciding what to cut. Writes about work, discipline and the decisions that compound.

Watch

Worth an hour of your evening

More from Books.

From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.

    Dial In MinistriesJul 8

    13 Life-Changing Books Every Christian Should Read with Jonny Ardavanis

    Faith WomackApr 14

    MUST-read Christian books that I think about all the time...

    The Counsel of TrentMay 26

    10 Classic Novels Every Christian Should Read

    OdysseasDec 24

    My Favourite Tip to Read History Books With Ease