Skip to content
GuideEvergreen guide

What your $17-an-hour hire really costs you

A worked example with real arithmetic, a 30-day mistake log, and what to do once you see the number.

By Ray Okonkwo · Money & Business5 min read
What your $17-an-hour hire really costs you

Quick answer: Price every mistake for 30 days: materials, redo time, the lead's checking time, and credits to customers. Add it to the hourly wage. The cheap hire often costs more than the good one, and the biggest line item is usually your own time.

Two candidates, one open spot in a six-person sign and print shop. One asks for $17 an hour. The other asks for $24. You hire the $17 and tell yourself you saved $7 an hour.

You saved $280 a week in wages. Now let's see what it cost.

The math nobody runs

Every number below is an illustration, not a benchmark. Swap in your own. I'm using a 20 percent burden for payroll taxes and insurance. Ask your accountant for your real figure, because it varies by state and trade.

The $17 hire, 40 hours: $680 in wages, $816 loaded.

The $24 hire, 40 hours: $960 in wages, $1,152 loaded.

The gap is $336 a week. That's the number that won you over.

Now the mistakes. Say the $17 hire ruins two jobs a week. Each one costs:

  • $85 in materials you can't reuse
  • 90 minutes of redo labor, about $30
  • 30 minutes of your lead's time checking the second attempt, about $20

That's $135 a mistake and $270 a week. Add a $150 credit to an unhappy customer once a month, roughly $35 a week. Then add the part nobody counts. Your lead has started checking everything this person touches. Three hours a week at $40 loaded is $120.

Hidden cost: $425 a week. The $17 hire now costs you $1,241.

Say the $24 hire botches one job a month. That's about $34 a week. Total: $1,186.

The cheap hire costs more. Not by a mile, but the gap flipped, and that's before a single customer decided not to come back. That customer never shows up in any column, which is why this mistake survives so long.

The line item that hides

Look at the $120 again. Checking someone's work is a real cost with a real name on it, and it comes out of the person you can least afford to spend it on. Your best people are the ones who catch errors. Every hour they spend catching someone else's is an hour they didn't spend selling, building, or training.

It also leaks in a quieter way. Good employees notice when they're quietly cleaning up after a teammate who earns less and gets the same grace. They don't always complain. Some just start looking around. If you've lost a strong person in the last year and the weak link is still on the schedule, run the numbers again.

Run the 30-day log

Don't trust the example. Build your own. It takes five minutes a day and one shared sheet.

  1. Pick the person. One at a time. Don't announce a campaign.
  2. Log every error. Date, what went wrong, and who caught it.
  3. Price it. Materials lost, hours to redo, hours someone spent checking, any credit or refund.
  4. Log the checking itself. Even when there's no error, note how long a lead spent reviewing.
  5. Add it to loaded wages. Compare against what a stronger hire would cost, including their mistakes.

Tape the monthly total to the same page as your weekly numbers. If you already run a page like that, the weekly numbers that keep a small business out of trouble is a good place to see where it fits.

Before you blame the person

Here's where the cheap-hire argument gets abused. A high error count doesn't automatically mean a bad employee. Check three things first.

Did you train them or just point? If the job lives in your head and your lead's head, the new hire is guessing. Write the five steps that cause the most errors. A one-page checklist at the station costs nothing.

Are they in the wrong seat? Some people are sloppy on the press and sharp at the counter. Fifteen minutes of watching tells you more than a performance review.

Is the process broken? If three different people have made the same mistake, it isn't three bad employees. The same goes for late invoices, which are almost always a system problem. This piece on that makes the case well.

If the log shows errors falling after training, you found a good hire who was underserved. Keep them. Pay them more once they've earned it.

When the number says no

Sometimes the log doesn't improve. You trained, you moved them, you fixed the process, and the total stays ugly. Then the kind thing and the right thing are the same thing: have the conversation early and plainly.

Show them the log. Say what has to change and by when. Thirty days is fair. Be warm about it. Most people who struggle know it, and nobody enjoys being bad at their job. But don't let kindness turn into a subsidy that your best employees pay for. You owe your team a shop where good work isn't punished by extra work.

If it still doesn't turn, you let them go with notice, a straight explanation, and no ambush. The way to do that without wrecking them or the people who stay is covered in how to fire someone without wrecking them or your team.

The mistake runs the other direction too

Don't overcorrect and conclude the expensive hire is always the safe one. A $24 hire with a bad attitude can cost you more than a $17 hire who's eager and teachable. Wages are a poor predictor of care. Check references on how they handle being wrong. The person who owns an error on Tuesday and fixes it by Wednesday is worth more than the one who never makes one and never mentions the ones they do.

And look at your own P&L once a month with this lens. Reprints, credits, overtime to fix last week's work: they're usually buried in materials and labor lines. Reading your own profit and loss in ten minutes a month shows you where to look.

What to do this week

Pick the one person you've been quietly worried about. Start the log tomorrow. Price the first mistake while it's fresh, down to the minutes your lead spent on it.

Thirty days from now you'll have a number instead of a feeling. A feeling is easy to argue with. A number gets decided on.

Ray Okonkwo

Money & Business

Former commercial banker turned small-business owner. Covers salary, credit, margins and the arithmetic nobody does before signing.

Watch

Worth an hour of your evening

More from Business.

From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.

    Alex HormoziNov 19

    Pick a goal that's big enough it's worth suffering for.

    Alex HormoziNov 18

    You don't need a subscription to get customers to buy again.

    Alex HormoziNov 18

    Dear younger me:

    TEDJul 23

    How to Claim Your Leadership Power | Michael Timms | TED