Skip to content
GuideEvergreen guide

The cheaper supplier is costing you more than the invoice says

You switched to save money last year. Before you renew, add up what the savings cost you in rework, rush orders and your own hours.

By Ray Okonkwo · Money & Business5 min read
The cheaper supplier is costing you more than the invoice says

Quick answer: The price gap between suppliers is one number on a page. The cost of switching is spread across a hundred small moments, and nobody adds them up. Pull twelve months of records, price every problem, and compare the total to what you saved. Then split the year in half and see if the problems are shrinking.

The scene

Picture a shop that builds custom cabinets. The owner switches hardware and sheet goods suppliers because the new one quotes lower on nearly everything. On paper, the savings are obvious. He feels good about it for a month.

Then the small stuff starts. The new catalog sells hinges by the box of ten, where the old one sold them by the pair. Two orders show up wrong. One pallet arrives a day late, so a crew stands around on a Thursday. The edge banding is close to the old color, not quite the same, and a customer notices. His office manager spends forty minutes on hold sorting out a credit.

None of it shows up on the invoice. All of it shows up in his week.

Where the money actually goes

Here are the costs the quote never mentions.

Your hours and your people's hours. Setting up an account, learning a new ordering system, relearning part numbers, chasing a missing shipment. Count them at what an hour of that person actually costs you, wages plus the payroll load on top. The owner's hours count too. Especially the owner's.

Ordering errors. New units of measure, new naming, new minimums. The first few months are full of "we ordered the wrong one." Each wrong order costs the item, the return freight, and the delay.

Quality drift. Same spec on paper, slightly different in the shop. Rework, scrap, a comeback visit to a customer. Comebacks are the most expensive line in any service business, because you pay twice and you also spend goodwill.

Lead time you can't trust. If the old supplier delivered in two days every time and the new one delivers in two to five, you'll start stocking a buffer. That buffer is cash sitting on a shelf. It's also space, and sometimes it's shrink.

Terms. Net 30 against net 15 matters more than most people think. So do freight minimums, restocking fees and fuel surcharges that live in the fine print.

The goodwill you burned. This one is quiet. Your old supplier knew you. They'd hold a part, take a late order at 4:15 on a Friday, extend you a few days when a customer paid slow. Years of that don't transfer. A new supplier owes you nothing yet, and you won't see the cost until the day you need the favor.

Run the audit

Set aside two hours. You need the data from the last twelve months, or since the switch.

  1. Pull the savings number. Old price minus new price, multiplied by the volume you actually bought. Use real purchases, not the quote.
  2. Pull every credit memo, return and rush fee tied to the new supplier.
  3. Make a problem list. Go through your email, your team and your job notes. Every late delivery, wrong item and quality complaint goes on one sheet, with a date and a rough time cost.
  4. Price the hours. Multiply the time by the loaded hourly cost of whoever lost it. Add overtime you paid to catch up.
  5. Add the carrying cost of any extra inventory you started keeping as a buffer.
  6. Subtract. Savings minus the total from steps two through five.

Don't dress it up. A rough number you trust beats a precise one you made up. If you're guessing at an hour here and there, guess low. The point is direction, not decimals.

Read the result honestly

If the savings still win clearly, good. You made the right call, and now you know it instead of hoping it.

If it's close or negative, split your problem list into the first six months and the last six. This is the question that matters.

Problems shrinking? You're still climbing the learning curve. That cost is real but it ends. Give it another quarter and measure again.

Problems flat or growing? That's the supplier, not the transition. A learning curve slopes down. A bad supplier just stays bad at a lower price.

A reasonable owner could argue the other way. Sometimes the old supplier was already failing you, with slow deliveries, rising prices, and a rep who stopped returning calls. Then the switch was a rescue, and some turbulence was the price of it. The audit still helps. It tells you whether the rescue worked.

What to do with what you find

You have three moves.

Stay and fix it. Take your problem list to the new supplier's rep. Specific dates and specific order numbers get a different reception than "you've been unreliable." A good supplier wants that list. Ask for a named contact, a corrected catalog, a better delivery window. If they won't work with it, you've learned something for free.

Split the business. Keep the new supplier on the products where they perform and move the sensitive ones back. Two suppliers also protect you the next time one has a bad month.

Go back. Call the old supplier yourself. Don't hide behind email. Tell them plainly what happened: you chased a lower price, it cost more than it saved, and you'd like to talk. Expect new terms. You may not get the old ones back, and you'll have earned that. If you left a balance, or left on a sour note, settle it before you ask for anything. Pay what you owe before they ask, and leave the account cleaner than you found it.

Before you switch again

You will switch again. Every operator does. Next time, do this first.

  • Write down the expected total cost, including a line for the learning curve. If you can't estimate it, your estimate is zero, and that's wrong.
  • Pilot one product line, not the whole account. Run it for ninety days.
  • Keep the old supplier alive with a small standing order during the trial. The goodwill is worth more than the minimum.
  • Set a review date six months out with the questions already written: errors, lead time, quality, hours lost. Put it on the calendar, because nobody remembers to review a decision that already feels finished.
  • Tell your team what you're measuring. The person who takes the delivery sees the problems before you do.

Put the review numbers on the same page as everything else you track. If you already keep a weekly page of numbers, add a line for supplier errors and late deliveries. It takes thirty seconds a week. And when you read your profit and loss each month, check whether cost of goods dropped the way the quote promised. If it didn't, the savings never made it past the invoice.

The quote told you what the supplier charges. Your own records tell you what they cost.

Ray Okonkwo

Money & Business

Former commercial banker turned small-business owner. Covers salary, credit, margins and the arithmetic nobody does before signing.

Watch

Worth an hour of your evening

More from Business.

From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.

    Alex HormoziNov 19

    Pick a goal that's big enough it's worth suffering for.

    Alex HormoziNov 18

    You don't need a subscription to get customers to buy again.

    Alex HormoziNov 18

    Dear younger me:

    TEDJul 23

    How to Claim Your Leadership Power | Michael Timms | TED