Skip to content
GuideEvergreen guide

A dress shirt that fits your shoulders and still lets you reach

Most guys fix a tight shirt by buying a bigger one. That's how you end up with sleeves that sag and a collar that gapes.

By Tobias Reed · Style & Grooming5 min read
A dress shirt that fits your shoulders and still lets you reach

Quick answer: Buy the shirt that fits your shoulders, then judge it by the armhole, not the chest. A higher, slimmer armhole and a little room across the back let you move. Extra fabric in the body doesn't.

The fitting room test

Put the shirt on, button it, and stand in front of a mirror. Look at the seam where the sleeve meets the body. It should land right where your shoulder turns the corner into your arm. Inside that point and the shirt is pinching you. Past it and the seam hangs down your bicep like a coat on a hook.

Now do three things.

  • Reach both arms straight out in front of you, like you're driving.
  • Raise one arm to shoulder height, like you're taking a book off a shelf.
  • Cross your arms over your chest.

Watch what the shirt does. If the back strains and the buttons pull at your chest, the shirt is tight across the back. If the whole shirt lifts out of your waistband when you raise your arm, the armhole is cut too low. If the cuff rides halfway up your forearm when you reach forward, the sleeve is too short or the back is too tight and dragging it up.

Each one is a different problem. Most guys treat all three as "too small."

Why the bigger size is the wrong fix

Say you try a shirt and it feels tight when you reach. The obvious move is the next size up. It works for about a week.

The shoulder seam now sits an inch off your shoulder. The collar opens up. The sleeves are fatter and longer, so they bunch at the cuff. And the armhole, which is the actual cause, usually sits just as low as before. You can move your arms better because there's a tent around you, but you look like a man wearing his older brother's shirt.

Shoulders are the one part of a shirt that's hard to change. A tailor can shorten sleeves, take in the sides and fix the length without much drama. Rebuilding a shoulder means taking the shirt apart, and nobody is doing that on a work shirt. I'd treat the shoulder as settled when you buy it. Everything else is negotiable. If you want the full rundown of what a tailor will and won't do, what tailoring actually costs and what's worth paying for covers it.

The armhole is doing the work

Look at the shirt on the hanger, not on you. Find the hole where your arm goes in and ask how far down it drops under the arm.

A high armhole sits close to the underarm. When you lift your arm, the sleeve moves and the body of the shirt stays put. A low armhole hangs fabric under your arm, so lifting it drags the whole shirt up with it. That's the tail pulling out of your pants while you reach for the top shelf.

The sleeve works the same way. A narrow sleeve with a high armhole moves better than a wide sleeve with a low one. It looks counterintuitive. It's also true. Generous fabric under the arm isn't freedom. It's slack that has to go somewhere when you move.

So when you shop, ignore the label that says "relaxed" or "classic" and check the construction. Hold the shirt up. If the armhole looks like a dinner plate, put it back.

What to look for in the back

Mobility when you reach forward comes from the back, and most shoppers never check it.

  • A box pleat or two side pleats below the yoke. That's the fold of fabric in the center or at each shoulder blade. It opens when you reach, and you get a few inches of give you can't see standing still.
  • A split yoke or a yoke that's cut properly. The yoke is the panel across the shoulders. If it's flat and stiff, it fights you.
  • Enough width between the shoulder blades. Cross your arms over your chest. If you feel the shirt grab you from behind, the back is cut too narrow for you, whatever size the tag says.

A shirt with a clean front and a pleated back can fit you close and still move. A shirt that's slim all the way around with nothing in the back is the one that rips at the seam the first time you carry a box.

Fabric helps, with limits

A little stretch in the weave takes care of a lot. Twill and oxford cloth also have more give than a crisp poplin. If you work at a desk and move around, a stretch blend is a reasonable choice. If you live in your shirt, it's worth the extra.

But stretch won't rescue a bad cut. A stretch shirt with a low armhole still pulls out of your pants. And some stretch fabrics wrinkle less and breathe worse, which you'll feel at 3 p.m. in August. For an interview or a wedding, go with plain cotton and get the cut right instead.

If you're built differently from the rack

Broad through the back, thick through the arms, big chest and a narrow waist: you're the guy these shirts were never cut for. Three routes.

  1. Try a different brand's slim fit before a bigger size. Cuts vary a lot. One maker's slim fit has a roomy armhole. Another's regular fit is tight under the arm.
  2. Pay for the sides and sleeves. If the shoulders fit and the body billows, taking in the sides is a routine alteration. Do that instead of buying a shirt that fits your waist and chokes your arms.
  3. Go made-to-measure once you've found your size. It costs more, but you can specify a roomier back and armhole, and you'll wear the result for years. Treat it like the suit: a single good suit beats three that almost fit, and the same goes for shirts.

The rule for next time

Fit the shoulder first and don't move on until it's right. Then reach, raise and cross your arms before you pay. Thirty seconds in the fitting room beats a year of tugging at your cuffs.

If your office never tells you what it expects, a shirt like this is the safest thing you can own. It works with a jacket, without one, and with your sleeves rolled to the elbow when the day gets long. More on that in dressing for an office that never tells you what to wear.

A good shirt doesn't make you think about it. You reach for the top shelf, the shirt comes along, and nobody notices a thing. That's the point.

Tobias Reed

Style & Grooming

Spent a decade in menswear retail watching men buy the wrong size. Believes fit is ninety per cent of it and says so weekly.

Watch

Worth an hour of your evening

More from City Style.

From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.

    Gentleman's GazetteNov 17

    The Most Important Fabrics in Menswear, Part 5

    Gentleman's GazetteNov 16

    Live: Lets Chat! (About Trousers and More!) #AskGG

    Gentleman's GazetteNov 15

    Small Talk Sucks! 10 Tips To Avoid Small Talk Tragedy

    Rock Your FashionAug 3

    7 BRILLIANT Ways To Style SNEAKERS Over 50 And Still Look ELEGANT & Chic