Skip to content
GuideEvergreen guide

The dress shoe that softens up instead of wearing you down

Breaking in a shoe should take a couple of weeks and a little tenderness. If it takes a season and a box of bandages, the problem was never the leather.

By Tobias Reed · Style & Grooming5 min read
The dress shoe that softens up instead of wearing you down

Quick answer: Buy a welted calfskin shoe in plain black or dark brown, on a last that fits your foot, and try it on in the afternoon. Then wear it a few hours at a time for two weeks. Leather gives. The shape of the shoe doesn't.

The lie about breaking in

Most men are told that dress shoes are supposed to punish you at first. Wear them until they hurt, then wear them through it, and one day they'll feel like slippers.

Half of that is true. Leather does soften, and the footbed does mold. But leather stretches across the width and the flex points, a little, in the right places. It will not grow a quarter inch longer, and it will not fix a heel that doesn't hold you or a toe box that pinches your pinky toe.

So here's the test. If a shoe is tight, stiff or a bit snug on day one, that's normal. If it's pressing on a bone, rubbing the same spot raw, or your toes are jammed against the front, send it back. That isn't breaking in. That's a wrong shoe you're paying to wear.

What's actually under the leather

A shoe that breaks in well has three things going for it.

Real leather uppers. Full-grain calfskin is the standard answer. It creases, it softens and it takes polish. Cheaper "genuine leather" and corrected-grain uppers are often coated with a plastic-like finish. They stay stiff, crack across the toe instead of creasing, and never settle around your foot.

A welted sole. In a Goodyear-welted shoe, the upper is stitched to a strip of leather, and the sole is stitched to that strip. Between them sits a layer of cork. Wear the shoe for a few weeks and the cork compresses to your foot. It's a custom footbed you didn't have to order. Blake-stitched shoes are sleeker and more flexible out of the box, and they're fine, but they don't mold quite the same way and they're harder to resole.

A last that suits your foot. The last is the form the shoe is built around. Two shoes in the same size can feel completely different because the last is different: narrower at the heel, rounder at the toe, higher across the instep. This is the one that matters most. You can't judge it online by size alone.

Cemented shoes, where the sole is simply glued on, can be decent. But when the sole wears out, that's usually the end of the shoe. A welted pair can be resoled more than once.

How to try them on

Go in the afternoon. Feet swell over the course of a day, and a shoe that feels perfect at 8 a.m. can be tight by dinner. Wear the type of socks you'll wear with them, which means thin dress socks and not your gym pair.

Stand on both feet and check these:

  • Length: About a thumb's width between your longest toe and the end of the shoe. Your toes should lie flat.
  • Width: Snug across the ball of the foot, not squeezed. If the leather bulges over the sole's edge, it's too narrow.
  • Heel: A little slip is okay in a stiff new leather-soled shoe. The heel should lift a quarter inch at most when you walk. If it pops out with every step, it won't improve much.
  • Instep: The laces should close with the eyelets still a bit apart. If they're touching, the shoe is too small through the middle. If the gap is wide, too big.

Walk on a hard floor, not just the carpet. Do it for a few minutes. Most sensible shoe stores will let you.

And measure both feet. One is almost always bigger. Fit the bigger one.

The two-week break-in that works

Don't wear them to a wedding, an interview or a flight. Wear them around the house first, on a hard floor, for an hour at a time. The goal is to find the hot spots before the rest of the world does.

Then start taking them out for a half day. A short commute, a lunch, an evening out. Put cedar shoe trees in the moment you take them off. The wood pulls out moisture and holds the shape while the leather settles.

Then rest them. Give a pair a full day off between wears, and two if you can. Leather holds sweat, and a shoe that never dries out breaks down faster. This is the real reason men with three decent pairs outlast men with one expensive pair.

If you feel a spot starting to rub, don't tough it out. Put a piece of moleskin on your heel or toe before it becomes a blister, not after. A shoe that's only rubbing in one place can sometimes be fixed. A cobbler can stretch the leather a little at a pressure point, and it usually costs less than you'd think. He can widen. He can't lengthen.

What to buy, what to skip

Buy:

  • A plain cap-toe oxford or a derby in black or dark brown. It goes with a suit, with chinos and with good dark denim. If you own one pair of dress shoes, this is it.
  • A leather sole with a rubber heel, or a thin rubber half-sole added later. Pure leather soles are slippery on wet tile and slick in the rain.
  • A round or slightly almond toe. Chisel toes and long pointed ones look dated fast and cramp the toes.

Skip:

  • Anything with a visible plastic shine to the leather.
  • Shoes with a sole that feels like cardboard when you press it, or that bends in half with no resistance.
  • Thick, decorative stitching on a cheap shoe. It's there to look expensive.
  • Buying a size smaller because you "like a snug fit." You'll like it for an hour.

If you're still working out what the shoes need to go with, start with one suit to buy when you own none and what to wear when the invitation says smart casual. The shoes are the part of the outfit people notice last and judge most.

Keeping them going

A shoe that fits and is cared for lasts for years. Care takes ten minutes.

Wipe off the dust after you wear them. Every few wears, use a bit of conditioner, and polish when they start to look dull. A brush costs a few dollars, and it does more than any fancy cream. Let wet shoes dry on their own, away from the heater, with the trees in. Heat cracks leather.

Resole them when the sole gets thin, not when it's gone through. A cobbler can usually tell you if there's enough shoe left. If you wait for a hole, the welt can get damaged, and then you're paying for repairs that could've been avoided. For more on what repairs and fitting work are worth the money, see what tailoring actually costs and what's worth paying for.

Pick a shoe that fits on day one, give it two weeks, and it'll be the pair you reach for at 6:45 on a Monday without thinking.

Tobias Reed

Style & Grooming

Spent a decade in menswear retail watching men buy the wrong size. Believes fit is ninety per cent of it and says so weekly.

Watch

Worth an hour of your evening

More from City Style.

From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.

    Gentleman's GazetteNov 22

    23 Luxury Things Worth Buying (Some Will Outlive You)

    Gentleman's GazetteNov 20

    You're (Definitely) Putting Your Pants On Wrong

    Gentleman's GazetteNov 19

    Live: Lets Chat! (About Trousers and More!) #AskGG

    Ellena HueNov 19

    6 Winter Knitwear Essentials That Make You Look Slimmer & More Elegant