Skip to content
GuideEvergreen guide

Your exchange is solvent until the Tuesday it isn't

You can't audit an exchange from your couch, but four checks and one small monthly habit will tell you most of what you need to know.

By Ray Okonkwo · Money & Business5 min read
Your exchange is solvent until the Tuesday it isn't

Quick answer: Nobody outside the building can prove an exchange is solvent. You can check who holds your coins, whether the platform pays you to leave them there, whether an outside auditor has looked at what it owes as well as what it holds, and whether a small withdrawal still clears. Then keep on the exchange only what you're willing to lose.

Solvent means one boring thing

An exchange is solvent if it holds at least as much as it owes its customers. That's the whole definition.

The screen won't show you the difference. Your balance on FTX read exactly what it was supposed to read right up until November 2022, when the company filed for bankruptcy and customers learned their balances were numbers, not coins. The assets had been moved, lent and spent elsewhere. A login page is not an audit.

Mt. Gox did the same thing in 2014. The names change. The shape of the failure doesn't.

Proof of reserves proves half

After FTX, a lot of exchanges started publishing "proof of reserves." Good. An exchange that refuses to is telling you something.

But read what it actually covers. A proper one has two halves.

Assets: the exchange shows it controls certain wallets, usually by signing a message from them. That proves control on one day. It doesn't prove the coins weren't borrowed for the snapshot and returned the next morning.

Liabilities: the exchange shows the total it owes customers, often using a Merkle tree, which lets you check that your own balance is included in that total. Many reports skip this half, and without it the assets number means nothing. A pile of $5 billion is fine if you owe $4 billion and a disaster if you owe $9 billion.

When one lands, check four things:

  • The date, and how stale it is.
  • Who signed it. An outside accounting firm, or the exchange grading its own homework?
  • Whether it covers liabilities, not just wallets.
  • Whether you can verify your own balance inside it.

If it clears all four, that's a real signal. It still isn't a guarantee. It's a photograph, not a film.

Follow the yield

Your account pays 5% on coins sitting there doing nothing. Fine. Where's the 5% coming from?

Somebody is borrowing your coins and paying interest, and the exchange keeps a slice. That means your coins aren't in a vault. They're out working, and they're only as safe as the borrower. Celsius froze withdrawals in June 2022 after exactly this arrangement went bad.

The rule is simple. If the product pays you a return and doesn't tell you plainly who's borrowing your money and what backs the loan, you're the one providing the risk. Treat it that way.

Read the terms nobody reads

Open the terms of service and look for one thing: what happens to your assets if the company fails?

The honest ones say it out loud. Coinbase's 2022 annual report warned that in a bankruptcy, crypto held in custody might be treated as part of the company's estate, which would put customers in line as unsecured creditors. Nobody enjoyed reading that. It's still the kind of plain disclosure you want, because it tells you what you're really holding.

If the document is vague about whether your coins are segregated from the company's own, assume they aren't.

A publicly traded exchange also files audited financials with the SEC. Those are worth an evening, and Read the filings before you buy the ticker walks through how. Look at what the company holds against what it owes, and whether the numbers lean on anything it printed itself.

Watch for the house token

This one is the quiet killer. Reporting in November 2022 showed that a large share of Alameda's balance sheet, the trading firm tied to FTX, was FTT, a token FTX itself had created. That's not an asset in any useful sense. It's a promise the company made to itself, valued by the same market it was propping up.

If an exchange's strength depends on its own coin staying high, you don't have collateral. You have a mirror.

The ten-minute test that beats any report

Here's the habit that's worth more than all the reading above. Once a month, withdraw a small amount to a wallet you control. Say fifty dollars' worth. Write down how long it took.

That's it. If it arrives in the usual window, the exchange is paying its debts that day. If it takes longer, or you hit a new limit, or support answers in cheerful, empty sentences, or "maintenance" lasts three days, you've found smoke. Don't wait for somebody on social media to confirm the fire. By the time the headline says withdrawals are paused, the line is already around the block and you're at the back of it.

One caution. Panic is when scammers work. Rumors of an exchange failing bring out fake "emergency withdrawal portals" and impersonators in your messages. Only use the exchange's address you typed or bookmarked yourself, and read The crypto scams that catch careful people too before you need it.

Commentary: the answer isn't a better regulator

After every collapse, the cry goes up for somebody in Washington to make it safe. Some oversight is fair, and fraud is a crime that ought to be prosecuted. But plenty of regulated, audited institutions have failed too, and the people who lost money were always the ones who assumed somebody else was watching.

That's the case for self-reliance. It's your money. You hold the responsibility, and with crypto you can actually hold the keys. "Not your keys, not your coins" isn't a slogan for hobbyists. It's the description of what an exchange balance is: an IOU.

What to do with all this

Decide, in advance and in writing, how much sits on any exchange. A workable rule is the amount you're actively trading plus nothing. Everything else goes to your own custody, and the unglamorous part of that, where the seed phrase lives and who can find it, is covered in The biggest threat to your crypto is your own filing system.

Spreading coins across two exchanges is a fair trade-off if you trade a lot, though it doubles your homework. Self-custody has its own risk. Lose the keys and nobody can help you. Neither choice is free.

None of this is personal financial advice. For how crypto fits your taxes, your retirement and your family's finances, sit down with a licensed financial planner and a CPA who knows the area.

The exchange will look solvent every day but one. Your job is to be mostly gone before that day, with your coins in your own hands and a fifty-dollar test that already told you.

Ray Okonkwo

Money & Business

Former commercial banker turned small-business owner. Covers salary, credit, margins and the arithmetic nobody does before signing.

Watch

Worth an hour of your evening

More from Crypto.

From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.

    Graham StephanNov 16

    What EVERYONE Needs To Do With Their Money ASAP

    Graham StephanNov 12

    NBA Player On Flying Private...

    Graham StephanNov 11

    How Is This Legal??

    The Wall Street JournalMar 30

    Stablecoins: Why This Hot Cryptocurrency Faces Challenges | WSJ