Skip to content
GuideEvergreen guide

The TV heroes who had to pay for doing right

Fifties and sixties dramas put decent men in a corner and made the right choice cost them. Five worth finding, with the content concerns named up front.

By Marcus Vale · Editor-in-Chief5 min read
The TV heroes who had to pay for doing right

Quick answer: Start with The Rifleman for the whole family, Have Gun – Will Travel for a grown man's Western, and two Twilight Zone episodes, "The Obsolete Man" and "The Shelter," for a conversation afterward. Add the 1959 Playhouse 90 version of Judgment at Nuremberg for adults only.

Richard Boone's Paladin took the job, took the money, and then found out who he was really working for. Some weeks that meant he walked away from the client. Some weeks it meant he turned his gun on him.

That's the whole appeal of these shows. A man knows what's right in the first ten minutes. The other forty are about whether he'll pay for it.

The standard was never in doubt

Modern prestige drama loves a man who's wrong for sixty hours while we're asked to understand him. That's commentary, and it's my read, not a ruling. The better television of 1955 to 1965 worked the other way. The hero had a code. The story tested whether he'd keep it when it cost him money, safety, or a friend.

That's harder to write than a moody antihero. Nobody gets to hide behind "it's complicated." The writers had to invent a price, and then make the man pay it with the camera on his face.

It's also a better model for a boy. He learns that knowing the right thing isn't the hard part.

Have Gun – Will Travel: the professional with a line

Paladin lives in a San Francisco hotel, reads poetry, dresses in black, and hires out as a gunman for a steep fee. The series ran on CBS from 1957 to 1963.

The twist is the conscience. When a client turns out to be a bully, a liar, or worse, Paladin doesn't finish the job to protect his reputation. He changes sides, usually at his own expense. A man who sells his skill and still refuses to sell his judgment is a rare thing on screen.

Boone plays him with a dry, almost bored courtesy that never reads as weakness. Watch how he talks to people who are about to regret something.

Content concerns: Gunfights and killings every week, though little blood by today's standards. Some episodes of that era treat other cultures in ways that haven't aged well. Preview before you put it in front of kids. For more in this vein, see The Westerns Every Man Should Watch At Least Once.

The Rifleman: the father who'd rather not

Lucas McCain is a widowed rancher in New Mexico Territory, raising his son Mark on his own. Chuck Connors played him on ABC from 1958 to 1963. Yes, he's famous for the modified Winchester. But the show is about the parenting.

Over and over, Lucas has to decide what to teach the boy when the easy answer is revenge, silence, or a lie that smooths things over. He admits his own mistakes to Mark. He holds a line with neighbors who'd rather he didn't. He's very good with a rifle and plainly doesn't want to use it. That's the point of him.

This is the one I'd hand to a father and son together. The half-hour length does a lot of the work. Nobody has time to preach, so the choice lands in a look across a kitchen table.

Content concerns: Gunfights every episode, some mean villains, and the occasional episode with a child in danger. Mostly clean. Younger kids may need you in the room for the tense ones.

Two Twilight Zone episodes that ask what you'd do

Rod Serling jumped out of airplanes for the Army in the Pacific before he wrote television. You can feel it. His best episodes treat moral failure as a real danger, not a talking point.

"The Obsolete Man" (1961). A mild librarian, played by Burgess Meredith, is sentenced by a totalitarian state for the crime of being useless to it. He's given a choice of how to die and uses it to expose the man who condemned him. Meredith doesn't raise his voice once. The scene where the state's confidence cracks is worth the whole episode.

"The Shelter" (1961). A neighborhood learns that an attack may be coming, and the one family with a fallout shelter becomes the target of everyone who didn't plan ahead. Good men get ugly in ten minutes. It's a hard watch, and it should be. It says something true about what a panicked crowd does to its own neighbors.

Content concerns: Neither has gore. "The Obsolete Man" involves a state execution and a tense ending. "The Shelter" has mob menace, a scuffle, and a bleak view of ordinary people. Kids under twelve should skip both. Teens will have plenty to say afterward.

Playhouse 90 and a judge

Before the 1961 film, Judgment at Nuremberg was a live-era television drama on Playhouse 90 in April 1959. Abby Mann wrote it. Maximilian Schell played the German defense lawyer, then played him again in the movie and won an Oscar for it.

The question at the center is a hard one. What is "I followed the law" worth, when the law itself was the crime? An American judge has to answer that. The case against the defendants isn't a cartoon, and the defense isn't either, which is why it holds up.

Content concerns: The subject is the Holocaust and Nazi crimes. It's serious, grim, and adult. I'd keep it for older teens and up, and watch it with them.

Before you press play

Old doesn't mean cleared. Spend a few minutes on it, the same way you would for a new release. Vet a Movie in Eight Minutes Before Family Night works fine for a 1959 episode.

  • Watch the first ten minutes alone if the kids are young. You'll know quickly whether it fits your house.
  • Pick the episode, not the series. Quality varies widely inside a long-running show.
  • Expect period blind spots. Some portrayals of women and other cultures reflect their time. Name them to your kids rather than skipping the show.
  • Pause at the choice. When the hero stands at the fork, stop the screen and ask what he should do. Then see what he does.

Where to find them

You don't need another subscription. Many of these sit on DVD and Blu-ray at the library, and the money you save is worth tracking. What Your Streaming Bill Is Actually Buying You breaks that down. Classic Twilight Zone sets are easy to find, and The Rifleman and Have Gun – Will Travel have been released in complete sets.

Start with one episode this week. Skip the explanation, and when it ends, ask your son what he'd have done in that kitchen. Don't answer first.

Marcus Vale

Editor-in-Chief

Twenty years in magazines, most of it deciding what to cut. Writes about work, discipline and the decisions that compound.

Watch

Worth an hour of your evening

More from Movies & TV.

From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.

    Vanity FairAug 18

    Magician Reviews Sleight of Hand and Visual Tricks In Movies & TV | Vanity Fair

    Sony Pictures ClassicsOct 8

    NUREMBERG | Official Trailer #1 (2025)

    WatchMojo.comApr 27

    Top 20 Movies Loved by 90s Kids

    WatchMojo.comDec 26

    Top 10 Best Live Action Movies For Families