Turn crossplay off and keep your kid's lobby small
Crossplay widens the pool of strangers your kid can meet. Shrink it to cousins, classmates and neighbors, and the game gets better too.

Quick answer: Switch crossplay off in the game's settings and in the console's family controls. Set voice and text chat to friends only. Then build a small circle of people your kid has actually met, using private lobbies or an invite-only server you control.
The pool is the problem
Your son's old arcade had a front door. You knew the owner, you knew roughly who was in there, and the kid who got out of hand got walked out.
Crossplay took the front door off. Once it's on, matchmaking pulls from every console, every PC and every phone running that game. That's millions of strangers, and most of them are other kids, which is fine. But some are twenty-six-year-olds who think a twelve-year-old is a fair target for a rant, or worse, a friendly voice that asks where he lives.
Most of it is harmless noise. The part that isn't doesn't announce itself.
The honest trade-off
Turning crossplay off has a cost. Queues get longer in some games. In a few, it also cuts your kid off from a cousin on a different console, because the toggle blocks everyone outside his platform, friends included.
That's a real loss, and you should decide it on purpose. Two ways to handle it:
- Leave crossplay off for public matchmaking, and let the cousin join through a private lobby or party if the game allows it.
- If the game doesn't separate the two, ask which matters more. A shorter wait, or a smaller crowd.
For a kid under fourteen, we'd pick the smaller crowd every time. A three-minute queue has never hurt anybody.
Do it in three places
One toggle won't hold. Settings live in layers, and a kid with a free afternoon will find the layer you missed.
1. Inside the game. Most big shooters and battle royales have a crossplay switch in the settings menu, usually under Game, Account or Network. Turn it off. Then look for chat settings and set voice to friends only, or off.
2. On the console or platform. Xbox, PlayStation and Nintendo each have a family control app or web page. Use it to limit who can message your child, who can join his games, and who can send friend requests. Menu names change with updates, so don't trust a screenshot from last year. Open the current one and read each line.
3. On the account. Your kid should be on a child account tied to yours, with a birth date that's true. Lying about age to unlock chat is how kids end up with adult settings by default. Make the account correct, then lock the settings with your own password.
Set a reminder to check all three again after any big update. Updates have a habit of resetting things quietly.
Who counts as a friend
Here's a rule that fits on a sticky note: if you can't name his parent or point to his house, he's a stranger.
That includes the player who's "so good" and "really nice." It includes the kid who's been on his friends list for six months. Time spent shooting together isn't the same as knowing someone, and a good teammate is still a stranger.
So friend requests get approved by you, and the approval rule is simple. He's met this person face to face, or you've met the family. School friends, cousins, kids from the neighborhood, the son of the guy you work with. Everyone else stays off the list, however polite.
Tell your kid why, and say it plainly. Not "the internet is scary," which he'll tune out. Try: "Anybody can type anything. You can't see who's on the other end, so the list stays people we know."
Build the small server
This is the part that turns a restriction into something your kid might actually like.
Most games that matter to kids let you run a closed space:
- Minecraft lets you host an invite-only world, either a paid Realm or a server you run yourself with a whitelist, so only approved names can join.
- Custom games and private lobbies in most shooters and sports titles let you fill every slot with people you've chosen.
- A standing night. Saturday at seven, four boys, one living room's worth of cousins and neighbors, headsets on.
If you're a dad who can follow a YouTube walkthrough, you can run a small server. It takes a Saturday afternoon and a spare computer. The payoff is a place where the rules are yours: no strangers, no chat you can't see, and a world your son built with kids he'll still know in ten years.
There's a bonus nobody mentions. Small groups of known players are kinder. Kids don't trash-talk the boy whose mother they'll see at the grocery store. The toxic lobby is mostly an anonymity problem.
Sit in the room, then sit in the game
Controls do about eighty percent of the job. The rest is you.
Keep the console or PC in a shared room. Not forever, but through the age where he doesn't yet have the judgment to say no to a smooth talker. A kid in a closed bedroom with a headset is alone with whoever's on the line.
And drop in. Our piece on being player two instead of the referee covers how. Pick up a controller. Get beaten badly. Ask who's on the team and listen to how he talks about them. You'll learn more in one match than in a month of checking the settings.
If you haven't set time boundaries yet, gaming limits that survive contact with a real household is the place to start, and counting sessions instead of minutes takes most of the fight out of it.
What to do if something goes wrong
It might. A stranger gets through, or asks for a real name, a school, a photo, or wants to move the conversation to a different app.
Teach your kid the response before it happens. He stops answering, leaves the game, and tells you. That's it. No punishment for telling, ever, or he'll stop telling.
Then you act. Screenshot the profile and the messages. Block and report the account inside the game. If the person asked for personal information or pictures, or made threats, take the screenshots to your local police. Don't confront the stranger yourself.
Make sure your son knows one more thing. He can come to you or another adult he trusts, like a grandparent, an uncle or a coach, with anything that felt off, and the first thing he'll hear is "thanks for telling me."
The rule you'll be glad you set
A closed circle isn't a cage. It's a fence around a yard, and kids play harder in a yard than in a parking lot.
Turn the toggle off tonight. Spend Saturday setting up a server with his cousins' names on the list. He'll complain for about a week.
After that he'll be too busy winning to remember what he was complaining about.
Dean Shaw
Gear & Garage
Reads the warranty, the parts list and the long-term owner reviews before anything else. Trucks, tools, watches, and the cheap version that costs more.
Watch
Worth an hour of your evening
More from Gaming.
From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.
Read next
