Skip to content
GuideEvergreen guide

A ladder rarely breaks. It slides, tips, or gets overloaded.

The rungs almost never fail. The feet, the locks, the ground and your own weight do. Here's how to buy one that holds and when the cheap one is fine.

By Wes Dunbar · Country & Skills5 min read
A ladder rarely breaks. It slides, tips, or gets overloaded.

Quick answer: Buy a Type IA (300 lb) fiberglass ladder for anything you'll climb above the first floor. Buy a cheap Type III stepladder for light bulbs and smoke detectors. Check the feet and locks before every climb, because that's where ladders actually fail.

The sticker is the whole sales pitch

Walk the ladder aisle and you'll see a label on the side rail with a duty rating. It's the most useful thing on the ladder and most people never read it.

  • Type III: 200 lb
  • Type II: 225 lb
  • Type I: 250 lb
  • Type IA: 300 lb
  • Type IAA: 375 lb

That number isn't your body weight. It's you plus your tool belt plus the bucket plus whatever you're carrying up. A 190-pound man hauling a 30-pound box of shingles is already past a Type III before he's off the ground. Add a gust of wind and a little bounce, and you're asking a light-duty ladder to do heavy-duty work.

The cheap ladder doesn't announce itself by snapping. It flexes, twists a little, and feels loose at the top. Most people read that as "that's how ladders feel." It isn't. A good one feels like a staircase.

What actually fails

Rails seldom break. These are the usual culprits.

The feet. Rubber pads wear smooth or crack, and the ladder skates on concrete or a wet deck. Replacement feet are cheap and a good ladder is built so you can swap them. That's the whole point of buying things you can repair.

The locks. On an extension ladder, the rung locks are what keep the top section from sliding down on you. On a hinged multi-position ladder, the hinge locks do the same job, and they're the first thing a cheap one skimps on. If a lock needs a kick or a wiggle to engage, it's done.

The ground. Soft dirt, a sloped driveway, mulch over a buried sprinkler line. The ladder was fine and the surface wasn't. Level the base or don't climb.

The angle. Set an extension ladder with the base one foot out for every four feet of height. A 16-foot reach puts the feet four feet from the wall. Too steep and it tips backward. Too flat and the bottom kicks out. And when you're climbing to a roof, the ladder should stick up three feet past the edge so you have something to grab when you step off.

The reach. You lean for the last gutter bolt instead of climbing down and moving the ladder. Keep your belt buckle between the rails. Every time.

When the cheap one is right

Not every ladder deserves a hundred and fifty dollars of your attention.

A four-foot Type III stepladder is the right tool for changing a smoke detector battery, swapping a ceiling bulb, grabbing the roasting pan off the top shelf. You're standing low, the floor is flat, you're carrying almost nothing. Buy the inexpensive one, keep it in the pantry closet, and don't feel bad about it.

A cheap ladder is also fine when it's the right height for a job you'll do twice a year indoors. The trouble starts when that same ladder gets promoted. It's in the garage, it's tall enough, and it's November and the gutters are full. The ladder didn't change. The job did.

Rule of thumb: if you'd be hurt badly by a fall from where you're going, don't use the ladder you bought for convenience.

What I'd buy

For the house, one real ladder. A 6-foot fiberglass stepladder rated Type IA covers most indoor and low outdoor work: painting trim, hanging lights, working under a ceiling. Werner and Louisville both make solid ones in that class. Pick the one with a wide, flat top cap and rails that don't flex when you push on them in the store.

For gutters, siding and the roof edge, an extension ladder. Get a Type IA fiberglass in the length that reaches your highest working point with three feet to spare. Figure your eave height, add the overlap, and buy the size that gives you real margin rather than a ladder stretched to its last foot. Add leg levelers if your yard isn't flat.

For tight spots and variety, a hinged multi-position ladder. It's handy, and it turns into scaffold, stepladder or extension. It's also heavy and has more parts that can wear. Buy a heavy-duty rated one and inspect the hinges on every use.

Fiberglass over aluminum for most homeowners. It's heavier, but it doesn't conduct electricity the way aluminum does, and it doesn't dent into a weak spot. It isn't a license to work near a power line, though. Keep at least ten feet away from overhead wires, and if the job is near the service drop, call the utility or an electrician.

What I'd skip

  • A wooden ladder that's been painted. Paint hides cracks.
  • Anything with a bent or twisted rail. Don't try to straighten it. It's finished.
  • Garage-sale aluminum with no label. If the duty rating is gone, so is your information. Treat it as unrated.
  • The ladder that's lived outside. Sun chalks fiberglass. If the surface feels rough or splintery, it's been out too long.
  • A Type III for roof work. Cheap as it is, it's not a bargain.

The longer argument is over in Buy the cheap pry bar. Never buy the cheap ladder. Short version: a pry bar that fails costs you a knuckle. A ladder that fails costs you a lot more.

The sixty-second check

Do this every time, not once a year.

  1. Sight down each rail like you're checking a board. It should be straight.
  2. Shake every rung. Nothing should move.
  3. Look at the feet. Smooth, cracked or missing means replace them.
  4. Work the locks. They should snap in on their own.
  5. Read the label. If you can't, the ladder is unrated.
  6. Set it on level ground and push on it before you climb.

Three points of contact on the way up. Two hands and a foot, or two feet and a hand. If you need both hands for the job, you need a platform, not a ladder.

Stay off the top rungs. On a stepladder that means the top step and the cap. On an extension it's the top three rungs. They're not extra reach. They're where the ladder stops being stable.

Lend it back better

You'll get asked to borrow one, or you'll ask. Do what the old code says: return it cleaner than it left, wipe the mud off the feet, and if a lock was sticky, spray it and say so. A neighbor who gets his ladder back in better shape lends it again.

And before you hand yours over, run the sixty seconds. The worst way to find a bad ladder is to watch somebody else's weight find it for you.

Wes Dunbar

Country & Skills

Grew up on an acreage and never quite left. Covers trucks, trades, land, and how to do the thing yourself.

Watch

Worth an hour of your evening

More from Gear.

From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.

    Marques BrownleeNov 11

    Macbook PROLED Review: It's Not About That

    Marques BrownleeNov 6

    Meta VR Glasses: What Vision Pro 2 COULD Have Been!

    Marques BrownleeNov 3

    OLED iPad Mini is The Most Apple Product They've Ever Appled

    Outdoor EmpireSep 12

    Amazon vs Walmart Camping Gear: What's Actually Worth Buying?