Skip to content
StoryEvergreen guide

The Brisket Gets Bigger Every Time You Tell It

On Memorial Day it was a small flare-up. By Labor Day the fire department was nearly involved. A field guide to the summer barbecue story.

By Marcus Vale · Editor-in-Chief5 min read
humor section

Memorial Day, a little after one in the afternoon. I lift the lid on the grill, a rack of ribs drips onto the burners, and a flame jumps up about a foot. I step back. I say "whoa." My eyebrows stay exactly where I left them.

That's the whole event. It lasted maybe four seconds. My brother-in-law handed me the tongs I'd dropped and asked if the ribs were still good. They were.

By the Fourth of July, the flame was "up to the eaves."

By Labor Day, I'd "had to have a quiet word with the grill," and a neighbor had "his phone out, ready to dial." Nobody had a phone out. I checked with the neighbor. He said he'd been looking at a cooler.

The edit is happening whether you like it or not

Nobody sits down and decides to inflate a story. It happens the way a gutter fills with leaves. A little at a time, while you're doing something else.

Here's the mechanism. The first time you tell the flare-up story, you tell it accurately, and it gets a polite chuckle. The accurate version includes the part where you spent ten minutes looking for the tongs, the part where the ribs needed another forty minutes anyway, and the part where somebody asked about the potato salad. The chuckle was polite because those parts are boring.

So the second time, you leave out the tongs. Nobody misses them.

The third time, the laugh lands a beat late, and you can feel it wanting a little more. You give it a bigger flame. The laugh arrives on time. Now you know what the audience wants, and a man who knows what the audience wants is a man in trouble.

You're not lying. You're editing for pace. It's the same job a film editor does, except yours is done over a plate of corn on the cob and nobody's paying you.

The summer ledger

Every barbecue story I've ever heard follows the same schedule. Check yours against it.

Memorial Day. The event itself. Accurate, rushed, a little confused. Somebody says "wait, what happened?" and you explain it badly.

Fourth of July. The first polish. The flame grows, the timeline tightens, and you acquire a line of dialogue you're fairly sure you said. You didn't say it. You thought of it in the shower on June 9.

Late July. The brisket stage. By now the cook time has grown. A brisket that took nine hours "took eleven." The weight goes up a couple of pounds. A story about a thirteen-pound brisket that went wrong is a good story. A fifteen-pounder is a saga.

Labor Day. Legend. Supporting characters appear who weren't there. The weather turns dramatic. The dog, who slept through the entire event, "never took his eyes off me."

That's the arc. Four stops, and the ribs never changed.

Why it's not really lying

A tall tale and a lie look similar from across the yard, but they're different animals.

A lie is meant to make you believe something false. A tall tale is a gift. Everybody at the table knows the flame wasn't six feet tall, and the telling works because they know. You and the audience are in on it together. Your audience is doing math in real time, subtracting a foot or two, and enjoying the subtraction. That's half the fun.

That's why the inside joke is load-bearing. The embellished barbecue story is the same structure. Once everybody knows the true size and the told size, the gap between them is the joke, and the whole table holds it up together.

Rules for a clean embellishment

Years of cookouts have taught me a few. Break them and the story goes sour.

One inch per telling. Fishermen know this. A fish that grows a foot overnight is a fish nobody believes. A flame that grows a little each retelling is a flame that makes it to Labor Day. Pace yourself.

Make yourself the fool, never the hero. This is the big one. The best-aged barbecue stories get worse for the teller. The flame gets higher because you panicked harder. The brisket takes longer because you were certain you knew better than the recipe. The moment you start embellishing toward your own bravery, the table stops laughing and starts waiting for you to finish. Nobody has ever asked for a second helping of a man being impressive.

Leave the other guy's dignity alone. Your brother-in-law can be in the story. He can hold the tongs. He cannot be made to look foolish unless he's already laughing in the telling. If you're not sure, ask him.

Keep the frame true. The day, the grill, and the food stay fixed. The ribs were ribs. You can paint the fence however you like, but you don't move the fence.

Your wife is the fact-checker

She was standing right there, so you will have to deal with her.

Mine has a particular look. She doesn't interrupt. She waits for the exact right moment, usually when I've just reached the part about the flames touching the awning, and says, "It was about this high," holding her hand at her waist.

This is useful. A good fact-checker tells you how far you've drifted, and you can decide what to do with that. Sometimes you correct course. Sometimes you say, "Fine, it was waist high," and the table roars, because now she's part of the bit. Let her be part of the bit. A story with a witness who can interrupt it is stronger than one without, the same way a joke is better with a well-placed pause than a rushed finish.

If she'd rather not play, honor that. Some couples run this as a double act and some don't. You'll know which you are by the third cookout.

What happens to the stories that last

A few of them don't stop at Labor Day. They survive the winter. They show up at Thanksgiving, then the next Memorial Day, now with their own title. "The Flare-Up of '24." Your kids tell it. Your kids tell it wrong, and they're telling it to their friends, with a flame twice as tall as yours ever got.

That's how a family keeps its folklore. It's the same engine as the grandpa jokes that refuse to die. Somebody tells it, somebody improves it, and one day somebody's grandchild is telling it at a cookout with a straight face.

The only honest ending

Last weekend, my daughter was telling a friend about the day Dad set the grill on fire.

I said, "It was a flare-up."

She said, "It was a fire, Dad. It went all the way up to the roof."

I looked at my wife. She held her hand at her waist.

I let it go. The story's in good hands now.

Marcus Vale

Editor-in-Chief

Twenty years in magazines, most of it deciding what to cut. Writes about work, discipline and the decisions that compound.

Watch

Worth an hour of your evening

More from Humor.

From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.

    Greg Dean's Stand-Up Comedy ClassesJan 23

    🎤3 Types of Joke Setups - How to Write Jokes - Greg Dean Stand Up Comedy Classes #comedians #joke

    Jerry Corley aka The Joke DoctorSep 20

    How to Tell a Joke [ SECRET ]

    Craig ValentineFeb 8

    Use Humor in Speaking without Telling Jokes | 1 Powerful Public Speaking Technique

    Darren LaCroixDec 1

    How to deliver a funny speech: Funny Speech