Cut out the moldy caulk and redo your shower seam yourself
Scrubbing black spots off old caulk is a losing fight. Cutting it out and replacing it takes one Saturday morning and a tube that costs less than a pizza.

Quick answer: Black or pink spots that come back after you scrub mean the caulk has failed. Don't clean it. Cut it out, wipe the seam clean and bone dry, run a new bead of 100% silicone labeled for kitchen and bath, and stay out of the shower for the full cure time on the tube, usually 24 hours.
Ask first. It's your parents' house, and a teenager who shows up and says "I noticed the caulk is shot, I want to redo it this weekend" gets a very different reaction from one who starts digging at the tub with a knife.
Why scrubbing doesn't work
The line where your tub meets the tile moves. Hot water expands everything, cool air shrinks it, and you add a few pounds of weight every time you step in. Caulk is the flexible seal that lets that seam move without opening up.
After a few years it shrinks, cracks, or peels away from one edge. Water gets behind it. Now mold has a dark, damp spot to live in, and the black stuff you see on the surface is just the part that's showing.
You can hit it with a bathroom spray and it'll look fine for a week. Then it's back, because the problem isn't on the surface. Old caulk has done its job and retired.
The quick test: press a fingernail along the bead. If it's loose, peeling, cracked, or the spots are dug into the material instead of sitting on top of it, it's coming out.
One limit. If you pull the old caulk and find soft, dark, crumbling wall behind it, or tile that moves when you push it, stop. That's a bigger repair than a Saturday job, so tell your dad or mom and let them call a contractor.
What you need
- 100% silicone caulk, kitchen and bath, mildew-resistant, in a color that matches the tub or grout
- A caulk gun, if the tube isn't a squeeze type
- A utility knife with a fresh blade, or a plastic caulk-removal tool
- Rubbing alcohol and a few rags
- Painter's tape
- A cheap plastic spoon, or just your finger and a bowl of soapy water
- Paper towels, a trash bag, and a pair of disposable gloves
Read the tube. Silicone smells strong while it's wet, so open the bathroom window and run the fan. And don't mix cleaning products. Pick the alcohol and stick with it.
Step by step
1. Cut it out. Run the utility knife along the top edge of the old bead, then along the bottom edge, angling the blade away from your hand and away from the tub surface so you don't scratch it. Always cut away from your body. Grab one end and peel. Good caulk comes out in long strips. Old caulk comes out in crumbs and takes patience, which is why people hate this step.
2. Get every bit of residue. Thin smears of old silicone will keep new silicone from sticking. Scrape what you can with the plastic tool, then wipe the seam with alcohol on a rag until it feels smooth and clean, not tacky.
3. Let it dry completely. This is where most first-timers blow it. Caulk over a damp seam and it won't bond, and you'll be doing this again in six months. Give it an hour with the fan on, or run a hair dryer along the seam for a few minutes.
4. Tape both sides. Lay painter's tape along the tile and along the tub, leaving a gap about a quarter inch wide between them. That gap is your finished line. Press the tape down hard so nothing slips under.
5. Fill the tub with water. Skip this if you're doing a walk-in shower with no tub. For a tub, add a few inches of water first. The weight pulls the tub down to its lowest point, so the gap is at its widest when the caulk sets. When the water drains later, the caulk won't be stretched past its limit and split.
6. Cut the tip small. Snip the nozzle at a 45-degree angle with a very small opening. You can always make it bigger. You can't make it smaller. Puncture the inner seal with a nail or the wire on the caulk gun.
7. Run one steady bead. Push the nozzle into the seam at an angle and move in one slow, continuous line. Don't stop halfway and restart if you can help it. The most common mistake is too much caulk. You're filling a quarter-inch gap, not decorating it.
8. Smooth it right away. Dip your gloved finger in soapy water, or use the back of the plastic spoon, and run along the bead with light, even pressure. You're pressing it into the gap and scraping the extra off. Wipe your finger often.
9. Pull the tape while it's wet. Peel it back slowly at an angle, away from the bead, not straight up. This is what makes the line look professional. If you wait until it dries, the tape tears the caulk with it.
10. Leave it alone. Check the tube for cure time and respect it. Silicone feels dry in an hour and still isn't ready to get hit with water. Tell everyone in the house the shower is closed until Sunday. Put a sign on the door if you have to.
Where this goes wrong
- Caulking grout lines. Don't. Caulk goes where two different surfaces meet, like tub and tile or the inside corners where walls join. Flat grout lines between tiles stay grout.
- Using the wrong product. Painter's acrylic caulk looks fine for a month. In a shower it won't last, so read the label for 100% silicone.
- Doing it right before a big event. Don't start this at 6 p.m. the night before something important. Get it done on a Friday evening or early Saturday so the cure doesn't wreck anyone's schedule.
You will make the first bead a little wavy. That's normal. Slow down on the second tub.
Keep it from coming back
New caulk lasts years if the room stays dry. Run the fan during every shower and for about twenty minutes afterward. Wipe down the walls and the tub edge with a towel or a squeegee, which takes ninety seconds. Leave the shower curtain spread out so it dries instead of bunching up damp.
That's it. The mold wasn't mysterious. It was moisture sitting where nobody was looking.
Finish like somebody can be trusted
Wipe the tub and the floor, put the knife back where you found it, take the trash out yourself, and tell your parents it's done and which day the shower opens again. That last part is what they'll remember. Reliable men are built at fifteen, not at thirty, and it mostly happens like this, in the house you already live in, on a job nobody asked you to do. Same idea as reliability being built in the house you already live in. If the free Saturday morning is a problem, here's how to fit gaming, school and sleep into the same week so the job actually happens.
The best result of a good seal is a bathroom where nobody ever has to ask.
Cal Brennan
Fitness
Strength coach. Trains fathers, tradesmen and desk workers, which means programs that survive a bad week.
Read next
