Skip to content
GuideEvergreen guide

Nobody on the board knows you. Write like it.

Your evaluation gets read in under a minute by a stranger. Here's how to write the part you control so it works for you for years.

By Ade Fisher · Young Men5 min read
Nobody on the board knows you. Write like it.

Quick answer: Keep a running log all year. Write every line as action, then number, then result. Never hand your rater a list of duties.

It's Sunday night. The evaluation is due Tuesday. You're staring at a blank input form and trying to remember what you did in March. You can't. So you write "Responsible for training and welfare of Soldiers," or "Sailors," or "Airmen," or "Marines," and you move on.

That sentence has been in a thousand files. It tells the reader your job title and nothing else.

The person reading it doesn't know you

A promotion board, a selection panel or a detailer is working through a stack of files. They have never stood next to you in a motor pool or a shop or a ward room. They don't know you're the guy who fixes things before anyone asks. They know what the page says, and they'll give it less time than you gave your lunch.

Whatever your service calls it, whether that's an NCOER or OER, an EPR or OPR, an EVAL or FITREP, the form is the same kind of document. Someone writes down what you did. Someone senior signs it. After that it's permanent, and it follows you into every board you meet.

In most services you get a say in what goes on it. Some ask you to submit accomplishments to your rater. Others expect you to hand over a list. Even where you don't write a word, a supervisor with a full plate will happily use what you give them. The ones who give nothing get adjectives.

Start in January, not in the last week

The fix isn't a better writing session. It's a file.

Open a note on your phone or a plain document. Every Friday, add two lines: what you did that week that mattered, and what changed because of it. Write the date. Write the numbers while you still remember them: how many people, how many dollars, how many days, how many hours saved.

Nobody keeps this up perfectly. If you miss a month, rebuild it from your calendar, your emails and your own after-action notes. Do that while it's still fresh.

By evaluation time you'll have thirty or forty raw entries. Your job then is picking the five best, not trying to recall anything.

Action, number, result

Most services teach some version of the same bullet formula. The Air Force calls it Action, Impact, Result. Use it no matter what branch you're in.

  • Action: what you did, with a strong verb. "Led," "built," "rewrote," "caught," "trained."
  • Number: how big. People, equipment, dollars, hours, miles.
  • Result: what got better, and for whom.

Here's a weak line and a strong one. The numbers below are made up for illustration. Use your own.

Weak: "Responsible for maintenance of the section's vehicles and mentored junior personnel."

Strong: "Led six mechanics through 14 vehicle services in nine days. Fleet readiness rose from 71 to 93 percent, the best in the battalion."

Same job. Same person. The second one shows what happened.

The test is simple. Cover your name and read the line. Could a stranger tell what changed because you were in the room? If not, rewrite it.

Own your piece without stealing anyone's

The military runs on teams, and the reader knows it. That creates two ways to mess up.

The first is hiding in "we." "Our section completed the inspection with zero discrepancies" might be true, but nobody can tell what you did. Say what you did inside the team's win: "Built the checklist and trained the section on it. The section passed with zero discrepancies."

The second is inflating. Don't claim the whole result when you carried part of it. Seniors know the real story, and a line that gets challenged costs you more than a modest one ever would. Your name is the only asset you carry between commands. Keep the numbers true and keep them checkable.

If someone else did the heavy lifting, say so in your own words and credit them. Being the one who gives credit reads well and costs you nothing.

Point it toward the next job

A good evaluation does two things. It describes the past year, and it makes the next job look like an obvious fit.

Look at where you want to go. A leadership slot, a school, a special duty, a commission, a civilian career. Then check whether your lines show the skill that job asks for.

If you want to lead, show people you trained and developed, with names or counts. If you're after a technical track, show the system you fixed or the process you cut from days to hours. If you're heading out of uniform, write lines a civilian could follow, because they're the raw material for your resume. Doing this early pays off, and it fits the plan in What to Do in the 18 Months Before You Take Off the Uniform.

Use the process, not just the form

A few moves cost nothing and help a lot.

  1. Ask at the start of the period. Sit down with your rater and ask what a top-performing person in your slot looks like this year. Then you're aiming at something real.
  2. Hand over finished bullets. A busy supervisor will tighten them or use them as written. Writing them for him is respect for his time, not a shortcut.
  3. Read the final before it's filed. Check names, dates, duty titles and numbers. Typos and wrong duty descriptions do get through.
  4. Check your official record later. Make sure the evaluation actually posted. Some people find a gap years afterward, when fixing it is slow.
  5. Learn your service's rules. The current regulation or instruction is the final word on formats, deadlines, what you may submit and how to challenge a mistake. Your S1, admin shop or personnel office can point you to the current version and the right system. Don't trust a buddy's memory of how it worked two years ago.

When it comes back lower than you earned

It happens. A rater has a bad year, a quota forces a squeeze, or somebody just doesn't write well.

Don't fire off an angry email that night. Ask for a counseling session. Go in with your log and ask plainly where the gap was. If something in it is factually wrong, raise it through your chain and use whatever correction or comment process your service provides. If it's a matter of opinion, you may not win, but you've now documented your work for the next one.

Then do what always works. Keep the log. Write the next year better.

Fifteen minutes on a Friday

Nobody ever got passed over for writing too clearly about work they really did. The ones who go far aren't always the hardest workers in the building. They're usually the ones whose files make it easy for a stranger to say yes.

Open that note tonight. Write two lines. Do it again Friday.

Ade Fisher

Young Men

Teaches the trades intake at a community college. Writes the manual he wishes his students arrived with.

Watch

Worth an hour of your evening

More from Military & Vets.

From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.

    JodywithaWhyNov 26

    What to EXPECT on an Air Force Deployment

    Turning Point USAMay 18

    China & Saudi Arabia Are Not Our Friends

    Christopher ChaosAug 16

    5 things you cant do on a combat deployment

    Here’s The DrillOct 12

    Here's The Drill - Tips for Deployment

    Turning Point USAMay 22

    Are We Doing ENOUGH to Keep America Safe From the Cartel? 🇺🇸🤔

    Christopher ChaosDec 17

    Military Deployment Checklist: 8 Financial Tips