Read your benefits summary like a bill you haven't received yet
Two plans, one worst-case number, and a break-even point you can work out on the back of the enrollment packet before the deadline hits.

Quick answer: For each plan, add twelve months of premiums to the out-of-pocket maximum. That's your worst-case year. Then work out how much care you'd realistically use, and price both plans at that number. This is general education, not advice for your situation.
The page most people skip
Every employer plan has to give you a Summary of Benefits and Coverage, usually called the SBC. It's a standardized, plain-English document, and it looks the same from plan to plan so you can compare. Most people glance at the monthly cost, pick the cheaper one or the one they had last year, and go back to work.
That's how a household ends up with a $7,000 surprise in March.
The SBC has one omission worth knowing about up front: it doesn't show your premium. That number lives on the rate sheet in your enrollment packet or benefits portal. You need both pages, side by side.
Six numbers, in the order they matter
Premium. What comes out of your paycheck whether you see a doctor or not. Multiply the per-paycheck figure by the number of paychecks in a year. A $115 deduction every two weeks is $2,990 a year, not "about a hundred."
Deductible. What you pay for covered care before the plan starts sharing the cost. Some services, like preventive visits and certain prescriptions, are covered before you hit it. The SBC marks which ones.
Coinsurance. After the deductible, the percentage you still pay. At 20 percent, a $10,000 bill costs you $2,000 until you reach the next number.
Out-of-pocket maximum. The ceiling on what you pay for covered, in-network care in a year. Deductible, copays and coinsurance count toward it. Premiums don't. Neither do out-of-network bills the plan won't recognize or services it excludes.
Copays. Flat fees for office visits and prescriptions. They're easy to compare and they're rarely what decides the matter.
Network. The list of doctors and hospitals the plan has negotiated rates with. Step outside it and the numbers above can stop applying.
Do the arithmetic on two plans
These figures are made up to show the method. Swap in your own.
- Plan A: $250 a month in premiums ($3,000 a year), $1,000 deductible, 20 percent coinsurance, $4,000 out-of-pocket max.
- Plan B: $150 a month ($1,800 a year), $3,500 deductible, 20 percent coinsurance, $5,000 out-of-pocket max.
First, the worst year. Plan A: $3,000 plus $4,000 is $7,000. Plan B: $1,800 plus $5,000 is $6,800. Write that number at the top of each plan. It's the most you can lose on covered, in-network care, and you should be able to say whether your savings can absorb it. If they can't, that's a job for your emergency fund, and it's worth knowing before the year starts.
Now three realistic years, counting premiums plus what you pay for care:
- Quiet year, $600 of care. Plan A costs $3,600. Plan B costs $2,400. The cheap plan wins by $1,200.
- Middle year, $8,000 of care. Plan A costs $5,400 ($3,000 premiums, $1,000 deductible, $1,400 coinsurance). Plan B costs $6,200 ($1,800, $3,500, $900). The richer plan wins by $800.
- Bad year, $40,000 of care. Both plans hit their caps. Plan A costs $7,000. Plan B costs $6,800.
Here's the part nobody mentions. The cheaper plan wins if you use under about $2,500 of care. The richer plan wins from there up to about $15,000. Past $15,000, the cheap plan wins again, because it caps out at a lower total.
So the question isn't "which plan is better." It's "where in that range does my family's year probably land?"
How to estimate your year
Use what already happened. Pull last year's explanation-of-benefits statements or your insurer's portal history and add up what the plan was billed. Then add what you know is coming: a planned surgery, a baby, physical therapy, a child who gets braces or a new prescription.
A few cautions:
- A routine year for one healthy adult is very different from a family with a pregnancy or a kid with asthma. The SBC includes "coverage examples" for having a baby and managing type 2 diabetes. They show what the plan pays and what you pay. Use them as a rough yardstick.
- Be honest about what you'd skip. People with a $3,500 deductible often delay care. That isn't savings, it's a bigger bill later.
- Your income and your cash cushion matter as much as the odds. Someone with $15,000 in the bank can take a high deductible. Someone living paycheck to paycheck probably can't, even if the math says they should.
The traps in the fine print
Family deductibles. Some plans have an "embedded" individual deductible inside the family one, so one person can get coverage after reaching their own number. Others make the whole family hit the full figure. The SBC and plan documents will say which. For a household with kids, this can decide the whole comparison.
HSA eligibility. A health savings account is available only with a qualifying high-deductible plan. Contributions go in pre-tax, the money rolls over year to year, and it's yours if you change jobs. Some employers add a deposit, which shrinks the real gap between plans. Annual contribution limits are set by the IRS and change, so check the current figure rather than trusting last year's memory. This is how your payslip can show a smaller tax bite from the same paycheck. A tax professional can tell you how it fits your return.
Prescriptions. Look up your actual medications in the plan's drug list and find out which tier each one lands on. A cheap plan can make a $15 prescription cost $90.
Network, by name. Don't ask whether your doctor is "covered." Get the exact practice and physician name, then check the plan's directory and call the office to confirm they take that specific plan. Directories go out of date. Also check the hospital you'd go to in an emergency.
Spouse and dependents. Some employers charge more to cover a spouse who has access to their own employer's plan. Compare both employers' plans for the whole family, not just yours.
Before the deadline
Open enrollment windows are short, often two to three weeks. Spend one evening with the rate sheet, the SBC for each plan and a calculator. Write down the worst-case total, the break-even range and your best estimate for the year.
Then ask your HR department or plan administrator anything the documents leave unclear. If your situation involves a chronic condition, a pregnancy or a complicated tax picture, a licensed benefits advisor or tax professional is worth the call.
The best plan is the one you've actually priced. Last year's choice, made in five minutes, is a guess with a payroll deduction attached.
Ray Okonkwo
Money & Business
Former commercial banker turned small-business owner. Covers salary, credit, margins and the arithmetic nobody does before signing.
Watch
Worth an hour of your evening
More from Money.
From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.
Read next
