Skip to content
GuideEvergreen guide

Make yourself the most interesting thing in the field

A dog that stays at your knee across open ground isn't obeying. It's choosing. Here's how to build that choice, one boring session at a time.

By Wes Dunbar · Country & Skills5 min read
Make yourself the most interesting thing in the field

Quick answer: Stop giving orders and start paying for position. Reward the dog every time it's near your left or right knee, change direction constantly so it has to keep track of you, and add distance and distraction a little at a time. Use a 30-foot long line until the dog proves it doesn't need one.

Why commands aren't the answer

"Heel" is a drill. It works in a parking lot and falls apart at the edge of a cornfield, where a thousand scents are shouting louder than you are. Say the word forty times on a two-mile walk and you've trained the dog to tune you out.

A dog walking beside you in open country is doing something different. It's checking in. It watches where you're headed and keeps itself in range, the way a good hunting partner does.

You can't order that. You build it by making the spot beside you the best place on the property.

What you need

  • A 30-foot long line, cotton or biothane, with no knots. Skip the retractable kind. It teaches the dog that pulling extends the leash.
  • A pouch of small, soft treats. Pea-sized. Use part of the dog's daily food so you're not overfeeding.
  • A flat collar or a well-fitted harness.
  • Ten minutes. Not an hour. Short sessions beat long ones every time.

Start somewhere dull: a backyard, an empty ball field, a gravel lot after hours. Boring is the point. You're building the habit before you test it.

Step one: pay for being close

Walk. Don't talk. The moment the dog's shoulder is near your knee, drop a treat right at your leg, so the dog has to come to that spot to get it. Then keep walking and do it again.

You're not asking for anything. You're just showing the dog where the money is.

After a dozen repetitions you'll see it. The dog starts drifting back toward your leg on its own, checking whether you've got something for it. That's the habit starting. Keep paying, and keep the treats coming faster than seems necessary for the first few sessions.

If you've fought a dog that hauls you down the trail, the boring fix for a dog that pulls covers the groundwork. Stopping the pull comes first. Everything here rests on it.

Step two: turn without warning

This is the part most people skip, and it does most of the work.

Every ten or fifteen steps, change direction. Left, right, a full about-face. Don't call the dog. Don't tug the line. Just turn and walk.

A dog that's drifting ahead gets to the end of the slack and finds you going the other way. It has to hurry and catch up. When it does, pay it at your knee. After a week, the dog stops wandering off because it has learned that you're unpredictable and the interesting events are all happening around you.

Be dull about it. No scolding when the dog gets it wrong. Wrong just means no treat and another turn.

Step three: make the field harder

Move to open ground with real distractions. A mowed hayfield is plenty. A fence line with rabbit scent is the final exam.

Raise one thing at a time:

  • Distance first. Let the line drag and give the dog ten feet, then twenty.
  • Then scent. Walk past a spot where you know something's been through.
  • Then movement. Birds flushing, a squirrel crossing, a neighbor's truck.

When the dog breaks position, don't yank. Stop, turn, and walk away in the other direction. The dog follows, comes back into range, and gets paid. If it's too far gone to notice, you've set the bar too high. Back up a level for a few sessions. Nothing's lost.

Step four: thin the treats, keep the surprise

Once the dog hugs your knee reliably, stop paying every time. Pay every third step, then every tenth, then at random. Random is stronger than steady, which is why slot machines work and why your dog will keep checking in even when your pocket is empty.

Also pay in other currencies: a tennis ball, a quick game of tug, permission to go sniff a stump. Let the dog earn a few minutes of freedom by staying close first. "Go sniff" becomes the reward for good walking, not the thing that competes with it.

Step five: drop the line

Only after the dog has walked beside you through three or four boring, distracted sessions with the line slack the whole time. Let it drag. Then, in a fenced or truly secluded area, unclip it.

Don't announce the moment. Keep walking, keep turning, keep paying. Most dogs don't notice, which is the sign you did the earlier work right.

Don't test it near a road, a highway, or anywhere that leash laws apply. Know your local rules, and respect a neighbor's land as you'd want yours respected. A dog that's reliable at your knee in a field still has a nose, and noses have opinions.

Where this falls apart

You'll get a good dog and a bad day. A deer breaks cover and eighty pounds of Labrador becomes a rumor. That's not failure. That's a dog.

Which brings up the honest concession. "Without commands" is the goal for ordinary walking, but you'll still want one emergency recall, a whistle or a single word you've never used for anything else and always pay for with something spectacular. Sit, stay and come in fifteen minutes a day is the place to build it. Keep it for emergencies and don't wear it out.

If you hunt, add the gun slowly. Introduce distant, muffled sound while the dog's eating or playing, and get a qualified gun-dog trainer involved before you fire near a dog you've only just taught to stay close. Gun-shy is far easier to cause than to cure.

Look after the body that's doing the walking

Long field days are work. A young dog's joints are still growing, so ask your veterinarian how much sustained distance is appropriate for its age and breed before you build up to miles. Check for ticks and burrs after every outing. Foxtails and grass seeds can work into ears, paws and noses, and that's a vet visit, not a home project. Carry water, and read what heat and cold actually do to dogs before you take a dog out in either extreme.

The test

Walk the perimeter of your own field with nothing in your hands. No line, no leash, no treats showing. The dog's ten feet off, nose down, then flicks an ear, looks back, and falls in at your knee without being asked.

You didn't say a word. That's what you were building the whole time.

Wes Dunbar

Country & Skills

Grew up on an acreage and never quite left. Covers trucks, trades, land, and how to do the thing yourself.

Watch

Worth an hour of your evening

More from Dogs & Pets.

From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.

    Simpawtico Dog TrainingApr 19

    5 Big Tips When Bringing Home a New Dog

    NParksSGSep 16

    Basic Pet Care: Dogs

    Cesar MillanOct 20

    MY BEST ADVICE FOR BEGINNER DOG OWNERS | DOG TIPS

    Doctor MikeFeb 18

    OWNING A DOG | Things to Know Before Getting a Puppy! | Doctor Mike