Skip to content
GuideEvergreen guide

Before you roll that 401(k), check the company stock

Rolling everything into an IRA is the default move. If you hold your employer's stock, it can quietly cost you a tax break worth real money.

By Ray Okonkwo · Money & Business6 min read
retirement section

Quick answer: If your 401(k) holds shares of your employer's stock that have grown a lot, you may be able to move them to a regular brokerage account instead of an IRA. You pay ordinary income tax only on what the plan originally paid for them. The growth gets taxed at lower long-term capital gains rates when you sell. Roll those shares into an IRA and the option is gone for good.

The mistake that's easy to make

You leave the company. HR hands you a rollover packet. The brokerage rep calls to "simplify" things. Everything goes into an IRA, the stock included, and it feels responsible.

For most holdings, it is. Money in an IRA grows tax-deferred, and you pay ordinary income tax on every dollar you withdraw. That's fine for index funds and bond funds.

Employer stock is the exception, because of a rule with an unromantic name: net unrealized appreciation, or NUA. Roll the shares over and a rule that could have saved you thousands never gets a vote.

How the rule works

Say you worked for a company for twenty-five years and bought its stock in your 401(k) along the way. The plan paid, on average, a certain amount per share. That's your cost basis. The shares are now worth far more. The difference is the net unrealized appreciation.

Ordinarily, anything that comes out of a traditional 401(k) is taxed as ordinary income, growth included. NUA treatment splits the shares in two:

  • The basis is taxed as ordinary income in the year the shares leave the plan.
  • The NUA isn't taxed then. When you sell the shares, that growth is taxed as a long-term capital gain, no matter how briefly you held them after they left the plan.

Any growth after the shares land in your brokerage account is taxed based on how long you hold them from that point. Hold them over a year and it's long-term. Sell sooner and it's short-term.

A worked example (illustrative numbers only)

These are made-up round numbers to show the mechanics. They aren't a forecast and they aren't your situation.

Suppose your plan bought shares for a total basis of $100,000. They're worth $400,000 today. The NUA is $300,000.

Path one, NUA: You take the shares in kind to a brokerage account. You report $100,000 as ordinary income that year. When you sell, the $300,000 of growth is taxed at long-term capital gains rates, which are currently 0, 15 or 20 percent depending on your income.

Path two, rollover: The full $400,000 goes into an IRA. Every dollar is taxed as ordinary income as you withdraw it.

Pretend your ordinary rate on that slice would be 24 percent and the capital gains rate would be 15 percent. On the $300,000, that's $72,000 versus $45,000. A gap of $27,000 for picking the right door.

Real life is messier. Ordinary income at that size can push you into higher brackets, and so can a big sale. Your rates won't match my example. That's the point of running the numbers with a professional before you move anything.

The rules that trip people up

NUA has conditions, and missing one can sink the whole thing.

  • You need a lump-sum distribution. That means the entire balance of that plan, taken out within a single calendar year. Not a slice of it.
  • You need a triggering event. Leaving the company, reaching age 59½, disability or death. The lump sum has to happen in a calendar year after the trigger.
  • The shares must go in kind. You move the actual stock to a taxable brokerage account. Selling inside the plan and sending cash out doesn't count.
  • The rest of the plan can still be rolled over. The usual approach is to send the stock to the brokerage account and roll the other investments into an IRA, so the lump sum still counts as complete.
  • Required minimum distributions come first. If you're old enough to owe one, that amount can't be part of the NUA move.

Your plan has to permit in-kind distributions, and not all do. Ask the plan administrator in writing before you assume anything.

The costs nobody puts in the brochure

You owe tax on the basis right away. That bill comes due in the year the shares leave the plan, and you'll want cash from somewhere other than the shares to cover it. Sell some stock to pay it and you've changed the math.

If you're under 59½, the 10 percent early withdrawal penalty can apply to the basis. There's an exception for people who leave the job in or after the year they turn 55, but it depends on the details. Check IRS.gov.

The shares also bring concentration risk. A 401(k) is supposed to be spread around. Holding most of your nest egg in one company, the one that used to sign your paychecks, is the oldest mistake in the book. Plenty of people have watched a favorite stock slide and learned that loyalty and diversification are different things. NUA treatment doesn't require you to hold the stock. You can sell soon after and still get the capital gains treatment on the NUA.

Then there are your heirs. Shares in an IRA are taxed as ordinary income to whoever inherits them. NUA shares in a brokerage account get a partial step-up in basis at death, but the NUA portion generally doesn't. Beneficiary rules are their own tangle, and your will doesn't control most of this money. The beneficiary form does.

When NUA probably isn't worth it

It's not for everyone, and chasing it can cost more than it saves.

  • Your basis is high compared to the value. The NUA is small, so there's little to save.
  • You're in a very low bracket anyway. The gap between ordinary and capital gains rates shrinks.
  • You can't cover the up-front tax without selling shares or raiding other money.
  • You'd rather keep everything deferred. Some people want the IRA's simplicity and don't need the cash flow.

Where the NUA is large compared to the basis, though, it deserves a serious look. That's most often a long-tenured employee whose stock has multiplied.

How to handle it

Do these in order:

  1. Find your basis. Your plan statement or administrator can tell you the average cost per share. Get it in writing.
  2. Check the calendar. You need a qualifying trigger, and the whole plan has to come out in one tax year.
  3. Map the tax bill. A CPA can model the ordinary income on the basis, the future capital gain and what it does to your brackets. Ask them to compare it against the IRA rollover.
  4. Plan the cash. Know where the tax payment comes from before you pull the trigger.
  5. Decide what you'll do with the stock. Keep it, sell it over time or sell it at once. Don't let sentiment make that call.

Limits, ages and tax rates change, so check the current rules at IRS.gov and with your plan administrator. This article is general education, not individual financial, legal or tax advice. Before you act, sit down with a fee-only fiduciary adviser, a CPA, or an estate attorney if heirs are part of the picture. If you're also working out which account to spend from first, bring that question to the same meeting, since NUA changes the order.

The rollover packet will still be there next week. The window on this one closes the day the stock goes into the IRA.

Ray Okonkwo

Money & Business

Former commercial banker turned small-business owner. Covers salary, credit, margins and the arithmetic nobody does before signing.

Watch

Worth an hour of your evening

More from Retirement.

From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.

    Eric at The PeakFPOct 18

    The Hidden Social Security Math Nobody Shows Retirees

    Dr. Ed Weir, PhD, Former Social Security ManagerJul 18

    Social Security 62 vs 70: Everyone Is WRONG About the Math

    Rachael Camp CFP®Feb 27

    The Most Accurate Social Security Strategy You’ve Never Been Taught

    Uncle John Financial Jun 18

    401(k), Social Security or Pension: How Claiming Order Affects Tax