Why your big overtime check looks robbed, and what to do in winter
Overtime isn't taxed at a higher rate, but seasonal work makes withholding behave strangely. Here's how the pay rules and the tax math really work.

Quick answer: Federal law pays nonexempt workers time and a half after 40 hours in a workweek, and some states add daily overtime on top. Your big overtime check feels over-taxed because payroll treats it as a year-round income, and the real trouble usually shows up in the off-season.
What a 50-hour week actually pays
Say you're a roofer at $35 an hour and it's June. You work 50 hours.
Forty hours at $35 is $1,400. Ten overtime hours at $52.50 is $525. Gross for the week: $1,925.
Now look at the stub and notice the tax line. It's bigger than you expected. That's where the grumbling starts, and where a lot of guys decide overtime isn't worth it. It is worth it. The reason the check looks wrong is below.
The overtime rules you should know cold
The federal rule is simple. A nonexempt employee gets one and a half times the regular rate for every hour over 40 in a workweek. The workweek is a fixed, recurring seven-day period. Your boss can't average a 60-hour week with a 20-hour week and call it even.
Some things trip people up:
- Salary doesn't make you exempt. Exemption depends on a salary level and on what your job duties are. A journeyman swinging a hammer on a salary is generally still owed overtime. A day rate doesn't change that either.
- The regular rate isn't always your base wage. Non-discretionary bonuses, like a production or completion bonus, generally get folded in when overtime is figured.
- Private employers can't hand you time off instead of overtime pay. "Take Friday off next week" doesn't satisfy the law.
- Paid time includes more than swinging the tool. Loading the truck at the shop, driving between job sites, and required meetings can count as hours worked. The details depend on the facts.
- Daily overtime exists in some states. California requires it after eight hours in a day. Alaska has a version too. Most states follow the federal weekly rule only. It varies by state, so look up your state labor department's page before you assume anything.
Prevailing-wage jobs and union agreements can raise the bar. Many union contracts spell out double time on weekends or after long days. If you're weighing that, our piece on union versus non-union trade work covers the trade-offs.
Cash "straight time" for your extra hours, off the books, is a trap. It's illegal for your employer, and it leaves you with no wage record, no unemployment claim and no Social Security credit for that pay.
Why the check looks robbed
Overtime isn't taxed at a special higher rate. It's ordinary wages.
But your employer's payroll system doesn't know it's June and the work will dry up in November. It takes your gross for the pay period and multiplies it up to a full year. That $1,925 week looks like a $100,100 annual salary to the withholding tables. It withholds as if you'll earn that all year.
You won't. Work 30 strong weeks at that pace and you've earned about $57,750. The system withheld for a much richer man than you are.
The reconciliation happens when you file. Your real income, standard deduction and credits get applied, and the overpayment comes back as a refund. Nothing was stolen. You just lent the Treasury money for a few months at zero interest, right when you could've used it.
If that bugs you, the IRS Tax Withholding Estimator on irs.gov walks you through adjusting your W-4. A tax preparer can do it in one sitting.
The off-season is where people get hurt
Here's the flip side. Winter layoff comes, and you file for unemployment.
Unemployment benefits are taxable federal income. You can have 10 percent withheld by asking for it (it's done on a form called W-4V, or through your state agency's process). Skip that and you can owe a surprise in April, even though you had a refund-sized year.
Whether seasonal workers qualify at all depends on the state. Some states have special rules for seasonal employment and base-period earnings. Check your state agency's rules before you count on that income.
If you take a winter side job, tell that payroll department about your other income. The W-4 has a step for multiple jobs. Skipping it is how two modest paychecks add up to an underpaid year.
If you're on a 1099, everything changes
Some contractors really are in business for themselves. Plenty of others are issued a 1099 because it's cheaper for the company. Misclassification is a real problem in the trades, and a truly independent contractor doesn't get overtime protection at all.
As a true 1099 worker, you owe self-employment tax of 15.3 percent on net earnings (Social Security and Medicare), plus income tax, and nobody withholds either. You make quarterly estimated payments, due in mid-April, mid-June, mid-September and mid-January.
A common safe harbor: pay in at least 90 percent of this year's tax, or 100 percent of last year's total tax (110 percent if your income was high enough). A seasonal worker with a big summer can blow past the safe harbor by August. Set aside a fixed share of every payment in a separate account, the day it clears. The IRS and your state each have rules here, so a CPA or enrolled agent earns the fee.
If you think you're misclassified, ask the Department of Labor or your state labor agency. Don't just stew about it.
A new overtime tax break
A 2025 federal law signed by President Trump created a deduction for qualified overtime pay: the extra half of time and a half that the federal wage law requires. It runs for tax years 2025 through 2028, has a yearly dollar cap, and phases out at higher incomes. It's taken on the return. It doesn't shrink your paycheck withholding automatically.
It's a real break for people who work the hours, and it rewards the exact thing tradespeople do. The fine print is long and the reporting rules are still settling in. Keep every pay stub showing your overtime hours and pay, and have a preparer confirm the figures.
What to do before the season starts
- Find your workweek. Ask payroll which day it begins.
- Check your stub. Hours at regular rate, hours at overtime rate, and any bonus lines. If the math is off, ask in writing.
- Run the Withholding Estimator with your real seasonal income, not your peak pace.
- Plan the winter. Decide on unemployment, side work and the 10 percent withholding before the layoff, not after.
- Keep records. Mileage, tool purchases and pay stubs in one folder.
If overtime is how you're making your numbers, watch what it does to your body, too. Your knees are sending bills you can't see yet, and the lineman paycheck is the clearest case of big money with a big price attached.
Get paid for every hour, keep your own records, and treat April as a date you planned for in June.
Ade Fisher
Young Men
Teaches the trades intake at a community college. Writes the manual he wishes his students arrived with.
Watch
Worth an hour of your evening
More from Trades.
From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.
Read next
