Your truck is not a hundred percent business expense
The vehicle deduction is where small-business owners get burned. Here's what the IRS actually wants on paper, and what the letter looks like when you don't have it.

Quick answer: If you deduct vehicle costs, you need a log showing date, miles, destination and business purpose for each trip, plus total miles for the year. "I use it for work" isn't evidence. Start the log today, and ask a CPA or enrolled agent how your situation works.
The deduction everybody gets wrong
Picture a roofer. Good one, six years in, truck paid off. He's got a crew of two and a pile of invoices. At tax time he hands his preparer a number for fuel, insurance, repairs and tires. Every dollar of it, because the truck is "the business."
The truck also takes his kids to church and hauls the boat in July.
That's the mistake. Not the truck. The hundred percent. When a vehicle does double duty, only the business share is deductible, and you have to be able to show how you got that share. Most people just guess high.
And guessing high is the habit that turns into a letter.
What the IRS wants to see
Vehicles are one of the few areas where the law asks for more than a reasonable estimate. For cars and trucks, the tax code requires adequate records or sufficient evidence backing up your own statement. That means, for each business trip:
- The date
- The miles driven
- Where you went
- Why you went
Plus the total miles on the vehicle for the year, business and personal combined. That total is what lets anyone calculate your business percentage.
A calendar with job names on it can help. Invoices that match the trips can help. A notes app on your phone works fine. A pile of gas receipts doesn't, because a receipt proves you bought fuel. It doesn't prove where you drove or why.
The part people miss is timing. A log kept as you go carries weight. A log built in March from memory looks like what it is. Auditors have seen a lot of logs where every entry has the same handwriting, the same pen and a suspiciously round number.
Two ways to deduct, and one catch
You generally choose between the standard mileage rate and actual expenses. The IRS publishes the standard rate each year on IRS.gov, so look it up there instead of trusting a number you heard at a job site. Actual expenses means tracking fuel, repairs, insurance, depreciation and the rest, then taking your business percentage.
Standard mileage is simpler. Actual expenses can pay more on a pricey truck with heavy costs. The catch is that your first-year choice can limit what you're allowed to do later, and heavier vehicles carry their own special rules. That's a conversation for your preparer before you buy, not after.
Either way, you need the same log. Both methods run on business miles.
Commuting is the trap inside the trap
The drive from your house to your regular shop or office is commuting, and commuting isn't deductible. Plenty of owners deduct it anyway because it feels like work. It isn't, as far as the IRS is concerned.
Trips from one job site to another, to meet a client, to pick up supplies for a job: those can count. If your home is your principal place of business, the rules on trips from home change, which is one more reason to ask a professional instead of guessing. Get that answer once, in writing, and keep it.
What the letter actually looks like
The IRS starts most of its contact by mail. It doesn't send agents to your door about a truck. A common version is a correspondence audit: a letter listing the items it's questioning, asking for documents, and giving you a deadline.
It's not a verdict. It's a request for proof.
If you have the log, you mail copies and wait. If you don't, you're in the position of having claimed a deduction you can't support. The IRS can disallow it and recalculate your tax. You owe the difference plus interest, and an accuracy-related penalty of 20 percent of the underpayment can apply when the error comes from negligence or a substantial understatement.
Worse, an audit of one year can lead the examiner to look at the neighboring years. If you made the same hundred-percent claim three years running, you have the same problem three times.
Let's keep this in proportion. For a bootstrapped service business, the audit isn't what usually kills you. Running out of cash does. But an unplanned bill for back taxes, interest and penalty lands on top of the cash problems you already had. That's how a decent year ends up as a bad one.
If the letter arrives
Don't ignore it and don't fire off an angry reply. The tax code is a mess, and you may even be right that it's unfair, but the deadline on the letter is real.
- Read it twice. Note which years and which items it names.
- Mark the response date on every calendar you own.
- Gather what you have, and send copies, never originals.
- Call the professional who prepared the return, or hire an enrolled agent, CPA or tax attorney now. Don't wait until the day before the deadline.
- If you need more time, ask for it in writing, before the deadline.
Answer exactly what was asked. Volunteering a stack of unrelated paperwork doesn't help you.
If you do find you got it wrong, a professional can walk you through amending and paying. Owning a mistake early generally costs less than defending it badly. General education only here, and your situation needs someone who has seen your return.
The fix takes two minutes a day
Use a mileage app, or a small notebook that lives in the truck door. Log the trip when you park. On the first of January, write down the odometer reading. On December 31, write it down again.
Then do the same with the rest of the stuff that sits on the line between business and personal.
- Phone: Deduct the business share, not the whole bill.
- Home office: It needs to be used regularly and exclusively for the business, and a kitchen table doesn't qualify. The test is narrower than most people think.
- Meals: Write the name of the person and the business reason on the receipt the same day.
- Tools and gear: Keep the receipt with the job it belonged to.
If you haven't already set the basics, the paperwork you can't skip in your first year covers what needs to be in place before any of this matters. And if the business is eating your evenings, how to run a one-man business that doesn't eat your family is worth the read before you add bookkeeping to the pile.
Leave the books cleaner than you found them
Old advice about borrowed tools applies to your own business: hand it back sharper than you got it. Do it for whoever buys your company someday, for the preparer who inherits your shoebox, and for the version of you who gets the envelope with the return address in Kansas City or Ogden.
Keep the log. It's the cheapest insurance you'll ever buy, and nobody has ever lost sleep over having too much of it.
Ray Okonkwo
Money & Business
Former commercial banker turned small-business owner. Covers salary, credit, margins and the arithmetic nobody does before signing.
Watch
Worth an hour of your evening
More from Startups.
From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.
Read next
