Skip to content
BRO TakeEvergreen guide

Go alone when the fish are spooky, bring friends when they're lost

Solitude catches more fish in clear, pressured, skinny water. A crew catches more everywhere else. Here's how to tell which trip you're on.

By Wes Dunbar · Country & Skills5 min read
Go alone when the fish are spooky, bring friends when they're lost

Quick answer: Fish alone when the water is clear, shallow, pressured or small, and the fish can see and hear you. Bring friends when you're searching big or unfamiliar water, when the bite is a pattern you have to crack, or when the trip carries real risk. Solitude wins on finesse. A crew wins on information.

What a third person does to a creek

Picture a small trout stream at first light. Water about knee deep, gin clear, a long run below a log jam. One angler eases in from downstream, stays low, and makes six casts before he takes a step.

Now add two buddies. One talks at normal volume because that's how people talk. One wades up the middle to "see what's up there." The third is a hundred feet behind, scuffing gravel and sending a faint mud line downstream. By the time anyone casts, the fish in that run have already decided it's a bad morning to eat.

Fish don't need to understand you. They only need to feel something wrong. Footfalls travel through the bank, shadows cross the water, and boots click on rocks. A rod tip waved against a bright sky gets noticed too. Every additional person multiplies the noise, and you can't shush a friend without it turning into a conversation.

This hits hardest with trout, pressured bass in clear lakes, carp on a flat, redfish in skinny water, and anything you're sight-fishing. If you're stalking fish you can see, go alone. Nobody else should be in the picture.

The pace you can't keep with company

Alone, you fish at the speed of the water. You can stand and watch a seam for ten minutes. You can skip the "good-looking" hole because something about the current looks off. You can go back and fish the same eddy three different ways, because nobody's waiting on you.

With friends, the group sets the pace, and the group pace is usually the average of everyone's patience. That's fine for a Saturday. It's a handicap when the bite depends on slowing way down.

The same goes for decisions. Alone, if the topwater isn't working at 7:15, you tie on something else at 7:16. A group takes ten minutes to agree, and by then the window's closed.

When the crew wins

Don't walk away thinking solo is always better. It isn't.

Unknown water. Three anglers on a big reservoir can try three depths, three lures and three banks in the first hour. Whoever hits fish tells the others. One guy covers a third of the water in the same time. If you've never fished the lake, a crew finds the pattern faster.

Schooling and moving fish. Fish that roam need to be located. More rods, more eyes on the birds, more hands working a shoreline.

Boats and big water. Running a boat, watching the weather and fishing at once is a lot for one person. A second set of eyes on the sky is worth more than a second rod.

Anything with risk. Offshore, fast rivers, ice, remote backcountry. This isn't about catching more. It's about getting home. More on that below.

And one more win for company, which has nothing to do with the count in the livewell. Some trips are about the people. Fish are the excuse. If you've got a grown son or an old friend who'd come out on a Saturday, go. The piece on taking your grown son fishing makes that case better than a limit of fish does.

A simple way to choose

Ask three questions before you pick the trip.

  • Can the fish see or hear me? Clear, shallow or small water says solo.
  • Do I already know where they are? If yes, solo. If you're hunting for them, bring help.
  • What happens if something goes wrong out there? The worse the answer, the more you want company.

If two of the three say solo, go alone. If you can't decide, split the difference. Drive up together, fish apart. Pick separate stretches, meet at the truck at noon, and compare notes over a sandwich. You get quiet water and shared information.

How to fish alone without being reckless

Solitude is a good way to fish and a bad way to be careless. A few habits make it sensible.

Tell someone your plan. Where you're going, which access point, when you'll be back. Make it a real time, and give the person a time after which they should check on you. Texting it works. Leaving a note on the kitchen table works too.

Wear the life jacket. Alone in a boat or kayak, it's not optional in any way that matters. If you go over, nobody's coming to pull you in. Rules on required gear differ by state and province, so check your local boating regulations. Plan on more than the minimum. The kayak piece covers how to stay dry in the first place.

Match the risk to the solo. Skip wading fast, cold or unfamiliar water by yourself. Skip night trips to remote spots unless you know them well. If you do fish at night alone, stay near your vehicle and carry a headlamp plus a spare.

Carry a basic kit. Water, a charged phone in a waterproof pouch, a small first aid kit, and a way to start a fire if you're far from the road. If you're hurt or in trouble, get medical help right away. Don't tough it out to finish the stretch.

Know your license rules. Every angler needs their own license, and requirements, seasons, size limits and bag limits vary by state and province. Look up your local regulations before you go. The piece on size and slot limits explains why those rules exist and how to read them.

The quiet bonus: you fish better when nobody's watching

Alone, there's no one to impress. You don't keep a fish just so the group sees a stringer. You don't release one early to look like a purist. You decide what's right for the fish, the water and your own table.

Whether you keep your limit for dinner or let everything go, it's a sound call. Both are honorable. If you're releasing, take your time and handle the fish right. The guide to releasing a fish so it lives is worth reading before your next solo morning, because nobody else will remind you to wet your hands.

A few of the best hours you'll ever spend with a rod will be the ones nobody else knows about. You'll remember the mist, the first rise, and the log you almost skipped. The fish will have been there the whole time. You were just quiet enough to find them.

Wes Dunbar

Country & Skills

Grew up on an acreage and never quite left. Covers trucks, trades, land, and how to do the thing yourself.

Watch

Worth an hour of your evening

More from Fishing.

From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.

    Bass Fishing TipsNov 17

    4 Crankbait Mistakes Costing You COLD Water Bass

    Steve Rogers OutdoorsApr 18

    SEE How Bass ATTACK Our Lures - Watch Underwater Footage for Key Differences

    BassFishingHQOct 29

    These NOVEMBER LURES Catch Bass EVERY TIME

    Juran AnglingApr 24

    15 Bass Fishing Mistakes RUINING your Chances (stop doing these!)