Skip to content
GuideEvergreen guide

Read the story from the bottom up

Headlines are written to be read. The facts that complicate them tend to sit near the end. Here's how to find them in under two minutes.

By Marcus Vale · Editor-in-Chief5 min read
Read the story from the bottom up

Quick answer: Don't stop at the headline and the first three paragraphs. Scroll to the bottom, then read upward. Hunt for five things: who's unnamed, what the number is a percentage of, the word "but," the response that didn't make the top, and the date.

The headline isn't the reporter's work

Headlines are often written by an editor, not the person who reported the story. The reporter may have filed forty paragraphs of careful, hedged material. Someone else then fit a verdict into about ten words.

That doesn't make anyone a liar. A headline has to be short, and short means something got left out. Your job is to find out what.

Newsrooms also build stories with the strongest material on top and the least essential at the bottom, so an editor can cut from the end when space runs short. That's a layout habit, not a conspiracy. But it means the qualifiers, the caveats and the other side's answer often land in the zone where an editor expects nobody to be reading.

Which is exactly where you should be reading.

Hunt 1: The unnamed

Count the sources. Count how many have names. Then look at what the unnamed ones are asked to carry.

An anonymous source confirming a small detail is one thing. An anonymous source supplying the whole accusation is another. There's a fuller breakdown in When an Anonymous Source Is Worth Believing, and When It Isn't, but the quick test is this: if you deleted every sentence that rests on "people familiar with the matter," how much story would be left?

Hunt 2: The number with no floor under it

Take any statistic in the piece and ask what it's a percentage of, compared to when, over how long.

A headline says something "doubled." Somewhere down the page you'll find out whether that's from two cases to four, or from two thousand to four thousand. Both are doublings. Only one is a story. Raw counts and rates are different animals too, and a city with more people will have bigger counts of nearly everything.

The same discipline applies to polls, and the details sit at the bottom almost by custom:

  • Sample size. A few hundred people is a thin slice.
  • Margin of error. It's larger for any subgroup, such as "voters under 30" or "rural men," than for the full sample.
  • Question wording. Change a few words and you can change the result.
  • Field dates. A poll taken before a big event is a photograph of a world that's gone.
  • Who was asked. Adults, registered voters and likely voters are three different crowds.

Say a headline reads "Poll: Majority Back ___." If the gap between the sides is smaller than the margin of error, the honest headline is "Poll: Country Split on ___." That's a boring headline. Boring is often what accurate looks like.

Hunt 3: The turn word

Search the article for "but," "however," "although," "despite" and "though." Sentences that start with those words are the story admitting something.

A piece might spend eleven paragraphs on an alarming finding, then write: "The researchers cautioned, however, that the sample was small and the results have not been replicated." That sentence is the whole reason to hold the finding loosely. It got paragraph twelve.

This cuts every direction. A story you'd love to be true will have its turn word too. Read it with the same suspicion, especially when it flatters your side.

Hunt 4: The missing answer

When a story accuses someone, look for their response. Where is it, and how much room does it get?

Watch for the stock phrases: "did not respond to a request for comment," "declined to comment," "could not be reached." Sometimes those are the plain truth. A reporter called, nobody picked up. But check when the request went out. A call at 5 p.m. for a story that ran at 5:30 isn't a real attempt to hear the other side.

Also notice when the response is present but buried. A denial in paragraph twenty-two, after twenty-one paragraphs of accusation, is technically fairness. It isn't practically fairness.

Right-leaning and left-leaning outlets both do this. Both hold the other side's rebuttal until the point where most readers have left. Pick an outlet you trust and an outlet you don't, and you'll find both do it.

Hunt 5: The date and the update

Check when the story was published, and check the very bottom for a line beginning "This article has been updated" or "Correction." A story can change materially after publication while the headline and the social post that sent you there stay frozen.

Outlets differ in how openly they handle this. How to Tell Which Outlets Actually Own Their Mistakes covers what a good correction looks like versus a quiet edit.

What this doesn't prove

Don't overshoot. A buried caveat isn't proof of bad faith. Sometimes it's buried because it's minor. Sometimes the reporter wanted it higher and lost an argument with an editor. And plenty of readers who go hunting for spin find it in every sentence, which is its own kind of error.

The point isn't to distrust everything. It's to know what the claim rests on. A claim resting on four named sources, a clear denominator and a prompt response from the other side can stand a lot of weight. A claim resting on one unnamed person and a number with no baseline can't, whatever the headline says.

For a fuller checklist on the editor's side of the desk, see The four questions an editor asks before a story runs.

Try it tonight

Pick one news event from this week. Find one story about it from an outlet that leans your way and one from an outlet that leans the other way. Read both from the bottom up. Write down, on a napkin if you like, what each one put in the last five paragraphs.

You'll probably find the same facts in both. They just sit at different heights. Nobody has to lie to steer you. They only have to choose what goes first.

Marcus Vale

Editor-in-Chief

Twenty years in magazines, most of it deciding what to cut. Writes about work, discipline and the decisions that compound.

Watch

Worth an hour of your evening

More from Media Literacy.

From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.

    MediaWiseJan 25

    Media literacy masterclass with MediaWise Campus Correspondents

    Decibel from Austin PBSMar 15

    How can you fact check the internet?

    FaktabaariMar 17

    Fact-checking and Digital Information Literacy

    EdutopiaMay 28

    A Media Literacy Tool to Assess News Credibility