Skip to content
GuideEvergreen guide

A tax deduction is a discount, not a free pass

The IRS draws a hard line between business and personal spending. Here's where it sits, what a deduction is actually worth, and what keeps you out of trouble.

By Ray Okonkwo · Money & Business6 min read
A tax deduction is a discount, not a free pass

Quick answer: If you're self-employed, you can deduct expenses that are ordinary and necessary for your trade. Personal, living and family expenses are off the table by default. A deduction only saves you a fraction of what you spent, and without records it's worth nothing. This is general education, not tax advice.

Start with a $60 dinner

Picture a self-employed electrician. He takes his wife out for her birthday, pays $60, and writes "client dinner" on the receipt because they talked about the shop for ten minutes over dessert.

That's not a deduction. That's a problem with a receipt stapled to it.

The tax code has two rules working against each other. Section 162 lets a business deduct expenses that are "ordinary and necessary" in carrying on the trade. Section 262 says personal, living and family expenses aren't deductible. Your wife is family. Dinner with her is living.

IRS Publication 535 defines the first rule plainly. An ordinary expense is common and accepted in your line of work. A necessary expense is helpful and appropriate for it. It doesn't have to be indispensable. A drill is ordinary and necessary for an electrician. A $400 espresso machine in his garage is a harder sell.

What a deduction is actually worth

Most people think of a deduction as money back. It isn't. It's a reduction in the income you're taxed on.

Take a $1,000 tool purchase. Say you're a sole proprietor in the 22 percent federal bracket. The deduction saves about $220 in income tax. You also owe self-employment tax of 15.3 percent, which applies to 92.35 percent of net profit, so the same deduction trims roughly $140 there. Call it $360 total, before state tax, and it's rougher than that because of how the half-of-SE-tax adjustment works.

You're still out about $640.

So never buy something because "it's deductible." If you don't need a $1,000 tool, you've spent $640 to save nothing. Buy what the work requires, then deduct it.

This is also why a lump sum or a good year needs a plan before December. What to do with a lump sum before it quietly disappears covers that side of it.

The gray zones, one by one

Home office. You need a space used regularly and exclusively for business, and it has to be your principal place of business. The kitchen table doesn't count. A spare room with a desk and nothing else in it can. The simplified method is $5 per square foot, up to 300 square feet, so $1,500 at most. The room has to be a real office, and it can't double as a guest room.

Vehicle. Commuting from home to your regular workplace is personal. Driving from the shop to a job site, or to a client, is business. The IRS sets a standard mileage rate each year, but it only works with a log: date, miles, and purpose, kept as you go. Reconstructing a year of driving from memory in March doesn't hold up. For the bigger picture on vehicle costs, see the car payment isn't the price.

Phone and internet. One phone used for both business and family gets deducted only for the business share. Figure out a reasonable percentage, write down how you got it, and stay consistent.

Meals. Generally 50 percent, and only when the meal has a real business purpose, such as a client, a prospect or a working trip. It can't be lavish. Entertainment, meaning tickets, golf and the like, has been nondeductible since 2018.

Clothing. Deductible only if the job requires it and it isn't suitable for everyday wear. Steel-toe boots, safety gear and a company-logo uniform qualify. A nice suit doesn't, even if you only wear it to meetings.

Gifts. The limit is $25 per person per year. Spend $200 on a client and you can write off $25.

Hobby or business

The IRS has a name for activities you pay for because you enjoy them: hobbies. Hobby income is still taxable. Hobby expenses generally aren't deductible against it.

The agency looks at the whole picture. Do you run it in a businesslike way, with separate books and a real attempt to make money? Do you put in the time? Do you have the expertise, or have you been learning it? Does it ever turn a profit? Is the main attraction personal enjoyment? A rule of thumb in the regulations presumes a profit motive if you're profitable in three of the last five years.

Rent a booth, build a customer list, and keep a ledger, and you're a business. Buy a bass boat and mention it to a guy once, and you're not.

If you work for an employer

Here's the annoying part. If you're a W-2 employee, you generally can't deduct your own unreimbursed work expenses on your federal return. That went away in 2018. Your home office, your tools, your mileage to a client site: not deductible unless your employer reimburses you, and then it isn't income to you at all.

There are narrow exceptions. Classroom teachers get a small deduction for supplies. Reservists and a few other categories have their own rules. Otherwise, if your job requires something, ask your employer to pay for it. Your payslip shows what's being withheld, and it's worth knowing which side of the line you're on before you buy anything.

Put the kids on payroll, if the work is real

One legitimate move for a family business: paying your own children for actual work. A teenager who sweeps the shop, answers phones or does filing can be a legitimate employee, and in a sole proprietorship, wages for a child under 18 are generally exempt from Social Security and Medicare taxes. It also teaches a kid what a paycheck is.

The work must be real, age-appropriate and documented, and the pay must be reasonable for the job. Paying a seven-year-old $20,000 to "model" is how a deduction becomes a letter. Have a tax professional set this up.

Records are the whole game

A deduction you can't prove isn't a deduction. The IRS generally wants you to keep records for at least three years from filing, and longer in some cases.

Do these things:

  • Open a separate checking account and card for the business. Commingling makes everything harder to defend.
  • Keep receipts, and write the business purpose on the back: who, what, why.
  • Log mileage as you drive.
  • Save invoices and contracts.
  • Set aside tax money weekly. A business that spends its tax money gets a very bad April. An emergency fund and a tax account are separate things.

An improper deduction can cost you the tax, interest, and a 20 percent accuracy-related penalty on the underpayment. That turns a $360 savings into a much larger bill.

The line to use

The test that actually works is this: would you have spent this money if the business didn't exist? If yes, it's probably personal. If you'd never have bought it except for the work, and you can show it, you're probably in good shape.

For anything in the middle, an hour with a CPA or enrolled agent costs less than one bad deduction. Take your receipts, your mileage log and your questions.

The IRS isn't the enemy here. It just wants you to be able to prove what you say you spent.

Ray Okonkwo

Money & Business

Former commercial banker turned small-business owner. Covers salary, credit, margins and the arithmetic nobody does before signing.

Watch

Worth an hour of your evening

More from Money.

From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.

    Graham StephanNov 16

    What EVERYONE Needs To Do With Their Money ASAP

    Turning Point USASep 28

    Debunking Left's Lies On Scandinavian Countries

    Graham StephanNov 12

    NBA Player On Flying Private...

    Graham StephanNov 11

    How Is This Legal??

    Turning Point USASep 8

    Socialism Is Slavery Of The People To Government

    Humphrey YangOct 11

    Switching Jobs Leads To 38% More Pay (Here's Why)