Insure the loss that would sink you, not the one that annoys you
Once a year, spend an hour with your policies. Most people overpay for small risks and ignore the one that could cost them the house.

Quick answer: Insurance exists for losses you couldn't absorb, not losses that merely sting. Once a year, raise deductibles to match your emergency fund, drop the gadget coverage, and check that liability, disability and life coverage are big enough to protect your family. This is general education, not advice for your situation.
Start with the paper, not the phone
Pick one date. Your birthday, the week after New Year's, the weekend the clocks change. Put it on the calendar and treat it like a service appointment on the truck.
Then collect every declarations page you have. That's the one-to-two-page summary at the front of each policy. It lists what's covered, the limits, the deductibles and the premium. Auto, home or renters, health, life, disability, any umbrella policy. Put them on the kitchen table next to a pad of paper.
Most people can't say what their deductible is without looking it up. That's the whole problem. You're paying every month for something you've never read.
The rule that sorts everything
Ask one question of each line: if this happened tomorrow, could I pay for it out of savings without wrecking the year?
If yes, you're probably overpaying to insure it. If no, that's where your premium dollars belong.
A dented fender is annoying. A lawsuit after a bad wreck, or a year without a paycheck after a back injury, ends households. The insurance industry would love you to treat those the same. Don't.
Where people overpay
Low deductibles. A $250 collision deductible feels safe. You pay for that feeling every six months. Here's an illustration with made-up numbers: say moving from $250 to $1,000 cuts your premium by $200 a year. You've taken on $750 more risk, so you break even after about four claim-free years. Most careful drivers beat that. Get real quotes from your insurer at both levels and do the division yourself.
The catch is real, though. A higher deductible only works if the cash is sitting there. If a $1,000 repair bill would go on a credit card, keep the lower deductible until your emergency fund catches up. Think of the fund and the deductible as one system.
Phone, appliance and gadget protection. The monthly fee on a phone plan, the warranty offered at the register, the cheap-looking add-on at checkout. Each is small. Together they run into real money over a few years, and you're insuring items you could replace. Do the math: total fees over the life of the device, compared against the likely repair cost and the deductible you'd still pay on a claim.
Duplicate coverage. Rental car coverage you buy at the counter when your auto policy or credit card already covers it. Travel insurance that overlaps with your card benefits. Read what you already have before you buy more. Also read the exclusions, because some card coverage is secondary and some has limits.
Credit and mortgage life insurance. The kind pitched with a loan. It pays off one debt and the payout shrinks as the balance does, while your premium usually doesn't. A regular term policy sized to your family's needs generally does the job better. Our piece on how much life insurance you need walks through the arithmetic.
Old premiums you never shopped. Insurers often reward new customers more than loyal ones. That doesn't mean switch every year. It means get two or three quotes for the same limits and deductibles, then call your current company with the numbers. Compare identical coverage only. A cheaper policy that quietly cuts the limits isn't cheaper.
Where people are underinsured
This is the part that costs the most, and the checkup exists for it.
Liability limits. State minimum auto liability is often far below what a serious accident costs. If you cause a wreck and the damages exceed your limit, the other side can go after your savings and future wages. Look at your limits. If you own a home, have savings or earn a good income, ask a licensed agent about higher limits and about an umbrella policy, which adds a layer of liability coverage across your auto and home. Umbrella coverage is typically inexpensive for the amount it provides, but get an actual quote.
Also check uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage. Plenty of drivers on the road carry too little or none, and this is the coverage that protects you from them.
Replacement cost on your home or rental. There are two ways a policy can pay out. Replacement cost pays what it takes to replace the item new. Actual cash value subtracts depreciation, which on a ten-year-old couch or roof is brutal. Check which one you have. Then check the dwelling limit against what it would cost to rebuild today, not what you paid in 2016. Building costs move.
Renters, this means you. Your landlord's policy covers the building, not your stuff. Renters insurance is usually cheap. Walk through your place with your phone, film every room and open the closets and drawers. Save the video somewhere that isn't in the house.
Disability. You're more likely to miss work for months than to lose the whole house. If your family runs on your paycheck, find out what disability coverage you have through work, how much of your pay it replaces, and for how long. One detail to ask about: whether the benefit is taxable, which can depend on who paid the premiums. A tax professional or the plan documents can answer that.
Life insurance for dependents. If anyone depends on your income, a term policy is the usual starting point. Check the amount against the debts and years of income you'd need to cover. And check that it didn't stay at a number you picked before the second kid.
The ten-minute cleanup nobody does
Open every policy that has a beneficiary. Life insurance, retirement accounts, the workplace plan. Make sure the names are current. A beneficiary form overrides a will, and an ex-spouse named in 2012 can still collect. Fix it while you're sitting there.
Then confirm the basics are right: correct address, correct vehicles, correct drivers, accurate annual mileage. Tell the company if you now work from home or drive less. Mistakes here can cost you at claim time.
Last, look at health coverage at open enrollment. Don't just compare monthly premiums. Compare the deductible, the out-of-pocket maximum and whether your doctors are in network. The out-of-pocket maximum is the number that matters in a bad year. If you're eligible for a health savings account, a tax professional can tell you whether it fits.
Do it like a man closing out the books
Write down each policy, the premium, the deductible and the main limit. Circle anything you'd struggle to pay out of pocket. Cross out anything you'd shrug off.
Then spend the savings on the circles. Put the premium money you freed up toward higher liability limits, or toward the emergency fund so the higher deductible is safe. And keep the page. Next year's checkup takes twenty minutes instead of an hour.
For decisions about specific coverage, talk with a licensed insurance agent, preferably an independent one who can quote several companies. For tax questions, ask a tax professional. Everything here is general education, not advice for your situation.
Insurance isn't a scam, and it isn't a safety blanket. It's a tool. Pay for the hits that would knock you down, and carry the ones that only bruise.
Ray Okonkwo
Money & Business
Former commercial banker turned small-business owner. Covers salary, credit, margins and the arithmetic nobody does before signing.
Watch
Worth an hour of your evening
More from Money.
From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.
Read next
