Skip to content
GuideEvergreen guide

Cash or a monthly check: find the break-even first

A pension buyout offer comes down to one number. Two minutes of arithmetic tells you what the lump sum has to earn to beat the monthly check.

By Ray Okonkwo · Money & Business6 min read
Cash or a monthly check: find the break-even first

Quick answer: Divide the lump sum by a year of payments to get the simple break-even. Then work out what return the lump sum would need to match the check for as long as you might live. That second number is the one that decides it.

All figures below are made-up worked examples. Your plan's numbers, the rules and the limits will differ, and they change. Check them against your plan documents and IRS.gov before you act.

The offer letter

Say you're 65 and your former employer's pension plan sends you two choices:

  • Option A: $2,400 a month for life, or $28,800 a year (example only).
  • Option B: $400,000 in cash, rolled into an IRA (example only).

Neither is wrong. They're two different products, and most people compare them by feel. A big number in a brokerage window beats a monthly check in the imagination every time. Run the math first.

Step one: the plain break-even

Divide $400,000 by $28,800. You get about 13.9 years.

So if you take the check, you've collected the full lump sum value by about age 79. Live past that and the check keeps coming. Die before it and, with a single-life payout, you got less than the cash would have been.

That's the number everybody quotes. It's also the weakest number on the page, because it pretends the $400,000 would sit under a mattress.

Step two: what the lump sum has to earn

Invested, the cash grows while you draw on it. So ask a better question: if I took the cash and withdrew $28,800 a year, how long would it last at different returns? Same example, withdrawals at the end of each year, before taxes:

  • At 0 percent: about 14 years. That's the plain break-even again.
  • At 3 percent: about 18 years. You're out of money near 83.
  • At 5 percent: about 24 years. Out near 89.
  • At roughly 6 percent: about 30 years. Out near 95.

Read that last line slowly. To match the check all the way to 95, your $400,000 has to earn close to 6 percent a year, every year, while you're pulling money out. In a bad stretch early on, it earns less and the hole gets deeper. This is what a check from an insurer or pension fund is really selling you: a return you can't be talked out of.

Now ask yourself honestly how likely you are to live to 95. Look at your parents and grandparents, your own health, and your spouse's. If the family tends to go at 78, the cash may well win. If your mother's still doing crosswords at 94, the check starts looking better.

What the math leaves out

Inflation. Many private pensions pay a flat amount forever. In our example, $28,800 a year at 3 percent inflation buys a little over 40 cents on today's dollar after 30 years. If the plan has a cost-of-living adjustment, the picture changes a lot. Check your plan for one before you compare anything.

Your spouse. The offer above is a single-life payout. If you're married, you'll usually be offered a joint-and-survivor option that pays less each month but keeps paying your spouse after you're gone. Federal rules generally require spousal consent to skip it, which tells you how seriously the law takes it. Run the break-even again on the joint option. And if your wife or husband is younger than you or healthier, weigh that more than anything else on this page.

Taxes. Monthly pension checks are generally taxed as ordinary income. A lump sum rolled directly into an IRA isn't taxed at the rollover, but withdrawals later are. Cash taken straight to your checking account can mean a big tax bill, and possibly a penalty if you're under the age the IRS sets. That's a CPA conversation, not a guess.

The company behind the check. Private pensions are generally backed by the plan and, up to limits, by a federal insurance agency, the PBGC. Those limits change. A public pension from a state or city has a different backstop. Know which one you've got.

The interest-rate quirk. Lump sums are calculated using interest-rate formulas. When rates are higher, the same pension usually converts to a smaller lump sum. Two people with identical pensions can get very different cash offers in different years. If you've got any flexibility on your retirement date, ask the plan administrator how the offer is calculated.

What the cash gives you that the check doesn't

Don't write off the lump sum. It has real advantages, and a sensible man or woman might choose it.

It's yours. If you die at 70, it goes to your family, not back to the plan (after a single-life payout, nothing is left to anyone). You can use it to cover a one-time need, like a paid-off mortgage or a medical bill. You decide how it's invested and when you draw it. And if you keep it in an IRA, you control the timing of withdrawals, which matters for taxes. Our piece on which account to spend from first walks through that order.

The cost of control is that you now carry the risks yourself: market drops, overspending, a bad adviser, and the temptation to treat a big balance as a prize. Self-reliance is a fine value. It works best when you're honest about your own habits.

A decision test that doesn't need a spreadsheet

Add up your fixed monthly costs: housing, utilities, food, insurance, taxes, and the truck payment you swore you'd retire without. Then add up the income that will arrive regardless of what the market does, such as Social Security and any pension check.

If guaranteed income covers the essentials, you have room to take risk with the rest, and the lump sum becomes more attractive. If it doesn't, the pension check may be the thing that lets you sleep. That's a judgment about your situation, not a rule.

Before you sign

The decision is usually permanent. Once you take the cash or start the check, most plans won't let you undo it. So slow down.

  • Get both offers in writing, with the lump sum calculation and any cost-of-living adjustment spelled out.
  • Ask for the joint-and-survivor numbers even if you think you won't need them.
  • Check your plan's rules and the current limits at IRS.gov, and your Social Security estimate at SSA.gov. Pension income can change when it makes sense to claim Social Security.
  • Hire a fee-only fiduciary adviser, who is paid by you and not by commissions on what you buy, and a CPA for the tax side. If you're weighing a purchased annuity instead of a pension, read what to ask before you sign an annuity contract first.
  • Make sure your beneficiary designations match your intentions, because they override your will. This explains why.

This article is general education, not individual financial, legal or tax advice. The break-even math won't pick for you, but it will keep you from choosing on a hunch. Ask yourself one question at the kitchen table: what happens if I'm still here at 95, and what happens to the person I love if I'm not?

Ray Okonkwo

Money & Business

Former commercial banker turned small-business owner. Covers salary, credit, margins and the arithmetic nobody does before signing.

Watch

Worth an hour of your evening

More from Retirement.

From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.

    Eric at The PeakFPOct 18

    The Hidden Social Security Math Nobody Shows Retirees

    Dr. Ed Weir, PhD, Former Social Security ManagerJul 18

    Social Security 62 vs 70: Everyone Is WRONG About the Math

    Rachael Camp CFP®Feb 27

    The Most Accurate Social Security Strategy You’ve Never Been Taught

    Uncle John Financial Jun 18

    401(k), Social Security or Pension: How Claiming Order Affects Tax