Skip to content
GuideEvergreen guide

The Tenth Amendment is 28 words, and one was left out on purpose

It's the shortest amendment in the Bill of Rights and the most misquoted. Here's what it reserves, what the courts have done with it, and how you use it.

By Marcus Vale · Editor-in-Chief6 min read
The Tenth Amendment is 28 words, and one was left out on purpose

Quick answer: The Tenth Amendment says Washington holds only the powers the Constitution gives it. Whatever isn't given to Washington, and isn't forbidden to the states, stays with the states or with the people. It's a rule about who holds the default, not a magic veto. It works best when citizens use it close to home.

Twenty-eight words

Here's the whole text, ratified in 1791 with the rest of the Bill of Rights:

"The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people."

Read it slowly and it sorts power into three piles. The first is delegated to the federal government, and that list lives mostly in Article I, Section 8. The second is prohibited to the states, such as coining money, making treaties, or taxing imports. Everything left over goes to the states "or to the people."

That third pile is huge. It covers most of what touches your week: the criminal code you'll most likely meet, the schools, the roads, property law, marriage and family law, professional licensing, and most of the rules your local police enforce. States hold what's called the general police power. Congress has no such thing. It has a list.

The word they refused to add

The Articles of Confederation, the failed first government, said the states kept every power not "expressly delegated" to Congress. The word expressly did a lot of work. It meant Congress could do almost nothing it hadn't been specifically handed.

When the First Congress drafted the Tenth in 1789, Thomas Tucker of South Carolina moved to put "expressly" back in. The House voted it down. Madison's argument, in short, was that no government can be confined to powers spelled out word for word, because no document could list every necessary detail.

Chief Justice Marshall leaned on that omission in McCulloch v. Maryland (1819) to show that Congress has implied powers along with express ones. So the amendment is not a leash. It's a boundary, and the boundary is the text of the Constitution itself. Anybody who tells you the Tenth shrinks Washington to a short list of literal verbs is overselling it. Anybody who tells you it means nothing is underselling it.

What the Supreme Court has actually done with it

The record is mixed, and a conservative reader should know the whole thing.

The low point. In United States v. Darby (1941), the Court called the amendment a truism: "all is retained which has not been surrendered." That treated it as a label with no teeth, and for decades it was.

The comeback, in three moves.

  • United States v. Lopez (1995) struck down a federal law banning guns near schools. Congress had no enumerated power to do it, and the Court said the Commerce Clause couldn't stretch to cover everything.
  • New York v. United States (1992) and Printz v. United States (1997) built the anticommandeering rule. Congress can't order a state legislature to pass a program or order local sheriffs to run federal background checks. Printz was 5-4, and gun owners should remember who carried that vote.
  • Murphy v. NCAA (2018) applied the rule again, striking down a federal ban on state sports-betting laws. You can like or dislike the betting. The principle is the point: Washington can regulate people, but it can't conscript states to do its regulating.

Money. In NFIB v. Sebelius (2012), seven of nine justices held that Congress went too far when it threatened states' existing Medicaid funding to force an expansion. Spending conditions are legal. Spending threats that leave states no real choice aren't.

The limit. In Gonzales v. Raich (2005), the Court let Congress reach marijuana grown at home and never sold, even where state law allowed it. The Tenth didn't stop that.

One more case, Bond v. United States (2011), makes a point worth keeping. A private citizen can raise a federalism challenge, because dividing power between governments protects individual liberty. The amendment says "or to the people." The Court has agreed that it means you, not only your governor.

What it doesn't do

Be honest about this, because bad arguments lose good fights.

The Tenth doesn't let a state ignore federal law that's within Congress's powers. Article VI makes the Constitution and valid federal laws supreme. Cooper v. Aaron (1958) rejected the idea that a state can nullify a Supreme Court ruling. And the Fourteenth Amendment, along with the Bill of Rights as applied to the states, means no state can strip you of your protected rights because the power was "reserved."

So the argument is never "the Tenth says no." It's "show me where the Constitution delegated this to Washington." That's a harder question for Congress to answer than it sounds, and a better one for you to ask.

Commentary: why this is the amendment worth fighting for

This section is opinion.

A federal government with a list of powers is a government you can hold accountable. A government with no list is a government that does whatever has the votes this year. The Founders split authority so that a bad idea in one state would stay in one state, and a good one could spread by example. You can move away from a bad state government. You can't move away from a bad federal one without leaving the country.

Over the last century, Congress has treated the Commerce Clause as a master key and the Court has often let it. We think that's backwards. A power that unlimited was not what the ratifiers were promised, and the Tenth was the promise. Washington needs to show its warrant, and when it can't, the matter belongs to the states and to you. You don't have to be angry about it. You just have to be exact.

How you use it this month

The Tenth only has force when somebody asks the question. These are the places you can ask it.

  • Read the authority statement. House rules require each bill to cite the constitutional authority behind it. Pull up any bill you care about on congress.gov and see what power Congress claims. If it's vague, tell your representative so.
  • Pick up your state's constitution. It's short, usually free online, and it governs the reserved powers. Many states let citizens put amendments or laws on the ballot. Check whether yours does.
  • Show up where the reserved powers live. Your state legislature writes more of your daily life than Congress does, as we covered in Your State Legislature Runs More of Your Life Than Congress Does. City councils, county boards and school boards sit just below. Attend one meeting. Most are lightly attended, and a calm, prepared citizen with a two-minute comment gets noticed.
  • Vote in the primary and the off-year. The people who decide the reserved powers are often chosen in elections where turnout is low.
  • Serve when summoned. Jury duty is the "or to the people" clause in its plainest form. Twelve citizens, not a bureaucrat, decide.
  • Know the formal route. Article V lets two-thirds of the states call a convention to propose amendments. It's never been used, but it's in the document, and it's there because the Founders expected states to push back.

For the larger picture, start with What each of the seven articles of the Constitution actually does and Why We Have a Bill of Rights and What Each One Says.

The amendment hands the power back to you. It doesn't mail it. You have to go pick it up.

Marcus Vale

Editor-in-Chief

Twenty years in magazines, most of it deciding what to cut. Writes about work, discipline and the decisions that compound.

Watch

Worth an hour of your evening

More from Civics.

From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.

    Kristina RodmanFeb 6

    Tricks To Remember the Bill of Rights

    Turning Point USAJul 1

    Charlie Kirk Debate - Best Argument For The Second Amendment

    The Singing History TeachersAug 7

    The First 10 Amendments - The Bill of Right Rap (Hamilton Style)

    CrashCourseJul 18

    Civil Rights & Liberties: Crash Course Government & Politics #23

    Turning Point USAJun 19

    Every Person's Natural Rights Should Be Protected

    Pacific Legal FoundationOct 4

    Bill of Rights Explained: Breaking down the amendments