Skip to content
GuideEvergreen guide

The most skipped line on your ballot might be your next governor

Forty-five states elect a lieutenant governor to take over when the governor can't serve. Here's how the office works and what the line of succession looks like.

By Marcus Vale · Editor-in-Chief5 min read
The most skipped line on your ballot might be your next governor

Quick answer: In 45 states, a lieutenant governor is elected to take over if the governor can't serve, and in most of those states the office also presides over the state senate. The five states without one name someone else, such as the secretary of state or the senate president. Your own state constitution spells out the order.

In 2018, Missouri's governor resigned. Lieutenant Governor Mike Parson took the oath and finished the term. No panic, no court fight, no guessing. The answer to "who's in charge now?" had been written down for generations, and most voters couldn't have named the person it pointed to.

That's the lieutenant governor in a sentence. It's the office you vote on once every four years, usually near the bottom of the ballot, for a job whose main purpose is to be ready on the worst day.

Where the office comes from

The U.S. Constitution doesn't create a lieutenant governor. It guarantees each state "a Republican Form of Government" (Article IV, Section 4) and leaves the design to the states. So the office exists because state constitutions create it, and every state wrote its own version.

The federal model is the Vice President, who is President of the Senate and "shall have no Vote, unless they be equally divided" (Article I, Section 3). Most states copied the idea. The lieutenant governor presides over the state senate and breaks ties. If you want the bigger picture of how the founding document divides the branches, what each of the seven articles actually does is a good companion.

Five states skipped the office entirely: Arizona, Maine, New Hampshire, Oregon and Wyoming. In Arizona, Oregon and Wyoming the secretary of state is first in line. In Maine and New Hampshire it's the senate president. Tennessee and West Virginia do it differently again. Their senate leader carries the title of lieutenant governor by statute.

One ticket or two races

States split on how they pick the person.

In a good number of states, governor and lieutenant governor run together. You vote once and get both. Candidates usually pick their running mate after the primary or at the same time, much like a presidential nominee.

In other states, including California, Texas and Virginia, the two offices are elected separately. That means a governor of one party can end up with a lieutenant governor of the other. It also means the person next in line was never vetted by the governor and may not agree with a single priority on the governor's agenda.

Commentary: The joint ticket is the saner design. A governor is accountable for an administration, and the person who steps into that job should be someone the voters already chose to carry the same agenda. A separately elected lieutenant governor with opposite goals turns a death, resignation or removal into a change of direction nobody voted for. Separate elections do add a check, and a reasonable person can prefer that. But when the succession actually happens, a clean handoff of the same mandate serves voters better than a surprise.

What the job looks like on an ordinary day

In most states, quiet. Presiding over the senate, casting a tie-breaking vote now and then, maybe chairing a commission or sitting on a board. Some lieutenant governors run an agency or a policy portfolio too. Powers vary a lot from state to state.

Texas is the exception that makes the point. Its lieutenant governor presides over the Senate and, under the Senate's rules, has major say over committee assignments and which bills get a hearing. That makes the office a serious power center, sometimes discussed as rivaling the governor's. If you live in Texas, that line on your ballot decides a great deal about what the legislature will and won't take up.

So don't assume the office is ceremonial where you live. Look it up.

When the governor can't serve

Two very different situations get lumped together, and the law treats them differently.

The office becomes vacant. The governor dies, resigns or is removed after impeachment. In most states the lieutenant governor becomes governor and serves the rest of the term. In Illinois in 2009, the Senate removed Governor Rod Blagojevich after impeachment and Lieutenant Governor Pat Quinn was sworn in. When Arizona's governor resigned that same year to join the federal cabinet, the secretary of state, Jan Brewer, took over. Different offices, same principle: the successor is named in advance.

The governor is temporarily unable. Illness, incapacity, or in many states being out of the state. Here the lieutenant governor generally becomes acting governor. That means exercising the powers of the office without taking the office itself. The governor comes back when the disability ends.

How a disability gets declared varies. Some constitutions let the governor say so. Some give the call to the legislature or the state supreme court. The federal version is the 25th Amendment, which lets the Vice President and a majority of the Cabinet declare the President unable to serve (Section 4), with a path for the President to contest it. State rules run from simple to elaborate.

The thing to notice is the design logic. Whoever decides must not be able to take the job for themselves on a whim. That's why removal runs through impeachment and trial, and why disability findings usually need someone besides the person who benefits.

What if the lieutenant governor can't serve either

States plan for this too, and the answers differ. Many name the senate president or the house speaker next. Others use the secretary of state or the attorney general. Some fill a vacant lieutenant governor's seat by appointment with legislative approval. Others leave it empty until the next election.

I can't give you your state's order without seeing your state's constitution, and neither can anyone else who hasn't read it.

Five things to do this month

  • Find the text. Search "[your state] constitution governor succession." It's usually a short section in the executive article.
  • Learn who's next. Name the lieutenant governor, or if you don't have one, whoever's first in line. Then name second.
  • Check how they're elected. Joint ticket or separate race. It changes how you vote.
  • Read their powers. Look at what the senate rules and statutes give the office. In Texas, it's a lot. In your state, it may be little.
  • Vote the whole ballot. The lieutenant governor race is the one most people skip. Don't. Primaries for it draw thin crowds, so a small number of informed voters carries real weight.

If you want to see where a lieutenant governor actually spends the day, watch your own legislature. Your State Legislature Runs More of Your Life Than Congress Does explains why that room matters, and Your State Capitol Has More Power Over You Than Congress covers the rest of the building.

Good constitutions are boring on purpose. The order of succession gets written when nobody's angry and nobody's in the hospital, so that on the bad day, everyone already knows the answer. Take ten minutes to know it too.

Marcus Vale

Editor-in-Chief

Twenty years in magazines, most of it deciding what to cut. Writes about work, discipline and the decisions that compound.

Watch

Worth an hour of your evening

More from Civics.

From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.

    Kristina RodmanFeb 6

    Tricks To Remember the Bill of Rights

    Turning Point USASep 22

    How The Left Reacts To SCOTUS Vacancy

    The Singing History TeachersAug 7

    The First 10 Amendments - The Bill of Right Rap (Hamilton Style)

    CrashCourseJul 18

    Civil Rights & Liberties: Crash Course Government & Politics #23

    Turning Point USAJul 6

    The American Trinity vs. The Leftist Trinity

    Pacific Legal FoundationOct 4

    Bill of Rights Explained: Breaking down the amendments