Skip to content
GuideEvergreen guide

Your City Council Only Has the Power the State Lent It

Ordinances are real law with real fines, but a city only holds the powers its state gave it. Here's how to tell when a local rule won't survive a challenge.

By Marcus Vale · Editor-in-Chief6 min read
Your City Council Only Has the Power the State Lent It

Quick answer: A city or county can only do what its state allows, and no local law can override state or federal law. When two collide, the higher law wins. A court decides whether they actually collide, not the council and not the code enforcement officer.

Say a letter arrives from the city. Your backyard fence is seven feet tall and the limit is six. There's a fine, and a deadline to fix it.

Your first question is probably whether they can do that. Fair question. The better one is where the city got the power to ask.

Your city is a tenant

The U.S. Constitution never mentions cities, counties or towns. They exist because a state legislature or a state constitution created them. The Supreme Court said so plainly in Hunter v. City of Pittsburgh (1907): municipalities are political subdivisions of the state, and the state can shape or restrict them as it sees fit.

How much room a locality gets depends on the state, and there are two broad models.

Dillon's Rule. Named for Iowa judge John Dillon, who laid it out in the 1800s. A local government has only the powers the state expressly grants, the ones necessarily implied by those, and the ones essential to its purpose. Doubt gets resolved against the city.

Home rule. The state constitution or a statute hands localities broad authority over local affairs. The city can act unless the state has said it can't.

Many states mix the two, with home rule for some cities and a tighter leash for others. Your state's version decides how much fight a city has in it when its ordinance gets challenged. Our piece on how your state legislature runs more of your life than Congress does covers where that authority comes from.

What an ordinance actually is

An ordinance is a local law. It's different from a resolution, which is usually a statement of position or an internal instruction with no force on the public.

The process varies by state, but the usual shape is this:

  1. A council member or staff drafts it.
  2. It appears on a posted agenda.
  3. It gets one or more readings, often with a public hearing.
  4. Members vote.
  5. It's published and added to the municipal code.

That code is where fences, parking, noise, business licenses, signs, burn bans and short-term rentals live. Zoning, which the Supreme Court upheld in Village of Euclid v. Ambler Realty (1926), is the biggest slice of it. Violations are typically civil fines, and some are misdemeanors. Treat them as real.

Three ways a local law loses

1. It violates the federal Constitution. The Bill of Rights was written to restrain Washington, but the Fourteenth Amendment brought most of it to bear on states and, through them, cities. In McDonald v. City of Chicago (2010), the Court held that the Second Amendment applies to local governments. Chicago's handgun ban fell. That's why a city can't ban a church, jail a man for a protected political sign, or take your property without due process. More on that in what each of the Bill of Rights says.

2. It conflicts with a federal statute. Article VI makes the Constitution and federal laws made under it "the supreme Law of the Land." Courts talk about three kinds of preemption. Express: Congress says in the statute that local rules are off the table. Field: federal law covers an area so thoroughly there's no room left. Conflict: you can't obey both, or the local rule stands in the way of the federal goal.

3. It conflicts with state law. This is the one that comes up most. A state may preempt local rules outright, or a local rule may simply contradict a state statute. Your state constitution can also limit what cities do, sometimes more tightly than the federal one.

The wrinkle that cuts the other way

Federal supremacy has a limit. In Printz v. United States (1997), the Court struck down a provision requiring local sheriffs to run federal background checks on handgun buyers. In Murphy v. NCAA (2018), it held Congress can't order a state to keep or write its laws a certain way. Washington can regulate people. It can't conscript state and local governments to do its work.

That doctrine is why a county can decline to spend its own money on certain federal programs. It does not mean a city can block federal officers from doing their own jobs. Courts have drawn that line case by case, and anyone telling you it's simple is selling something.

Opinion: local control is the default, but rights aren't local

This section is commentary.

We lean toward local decisions. The government closest to you is the one you can actually reach, and a county commissioner you can corner at the grocery store answers for his votes in a way a bureaucrat three time zones away never does.

But local control has a boundary, and it's the one the Constitution draws. Your rights don't change at the city limit.

Take firearms. A lawful carrier driving across a state shouldn't need to read forty municipal codes to find out whether his trip is legal in the next town. Most states have passed preemption laws setting one rule statewide, and we think that's right. A constitutional right shouldn't come with a patchwork of local permission slips.

The same logic works against overreach by the states. After Kelo v. City of New London (2005), when the Court allowed a city to take homes for private development, the loudest corrections came from state legislatures, many of which tightened their eminent domain laws. That's the system working: a bad local power, a bad ruling, then a fix by the level of government above the city.

How to check a local law, and what to do about it

Don't ignore an ordinance because you suspect it's illegal. Ignoring is how a small fine becomes a lien. Do this instead.

  • Read the actual text. Most cities post their code online through a code publisher or on the city site. Find the exact section cited in your notice.
  • Look for the authority. Good ordinances often cite the state statute they rest on. If there's no citation, that's a question worth asking at a meeting.
  • Search your state's code for preemption. Try the topic plus "preempt" or "political subdivision." Some states have preemption sections for firearms, wages, plastic bags, short-term rentals and more.
  • Contest it through the process. Most citations come with a hearing or appeal. Use it. Bring the text, not a speech.
  • Talk to a licensed attorney in your state. Whether a particular ordinance is preempted is a legal question with real money behind it. We can lay out the framework. We can't tell you how your case comes out. The path a challenge takes through the courts is laid out in how a case reaches the Supreme Court.

Change it before you have to fight it

Fighting a rule after it passes is slow and expensive. Stopping it as a draft costs a free evening.

Agendas are public, and open meetings laws require notice, though the lead time varies by state. Read the agenda for the next meeting. Most councils and planning boards set aside public comment, often three minutes a speaker. Three minutes is plenty if you cite the section number, name the problem and ask for one specific change.

Email the member who represents your district beforehand. Show up early. Be the person who thanks them when they get it right.

Many states also let residents force a vote through referendum or petition, and nearly all of them need volunteers for planning commissions, zoning boards and school boards. Those seats are filled by whoever applies.

The fence rule you're grumbling about was written by five or seven neighbors in a room. Next time, one of them could be you.

Marcus Vale

Editor-in-Chief

Twenty years in magazines, most of it deciding what to cut. Writes about work, discipline and the decisions that compound.

Watch

Worth an hour of your evening

More from Civics.

From channels we rate. Plays on YouTube.

    Tutor HawkFeb 9

    How to Remember The 27 Amendments

    Turning Point USASep 28

    We Don't Need Big Gov To Help Americans

    Homeschool PopJul 17

    Constitution for Kids | What It Is and Why It Matters

    Homeschool PopSep 8

    Learn All About the U.S. Constitution!

    Turning Point USASep 26

    Gun Control Myths Destroyed

    Rivera ESL Resources | Learn & Practice English!Apr 11

    The US Constitution | English for Civics | US Citizenship Test Qs 1-3 | ESL Vocab & History Lesson